Vegan Vs. Mediterranean: Which Diet Reduces Inflammation Better?

The vegan and Mediterranean diets are two popular eating plans that have been well-studied for their potential health benefits. Both diets emphasise plant-based foods, but differ in their inclusion of animal products. The Mediterranean diet is less restrictive, allowing moderate consumption of animal products like poultry, eggs, and dairy, while the vegan diet eliminates all animal products. This raises the question: which diet is better for reducing inflammation?

Research suggests that a low-fat vegan diet may be more effective at reducing harmful inflammatory compounds called advanced glycation end-products (AGEs) than the Mediterranean diet. A study found that a low-fat vegan diet reduced AGEs by 73%, while the Mediterranean diet showed no reduction. AGEs are linked to inflammation and chronic diseases like heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

In addition to reducing AGEs, the vegan diet led to an average weight loss of 13 pounds, compared to no change on the Mediterranean diet. The reduction in AGEs on the vegan diet was attributed to the exclusion of meat, minimised consumption of added fats, and avoidance of dairy products.

While the Mediterranean diet has been extensively studied for its heart health benefits, the vegan diet has also been shown to promote heart health and improve blood sugar control. However, research on the vegan diet's effects on brain health is more limited compared to the Mediterranean diet.

In conclusion, both the vegan and Mediterranean diets offer potential health benefits, but the vegan diet may have an edge when it comes to reducing inflammation and promoting weight loss.

A vegan diet reduces harmful inflammatory compounds by 73%

A vegan diet has been proven to reduce harmful inflammatory compounds by 73%. This is compared to a Mediterranean diet, which showed no reduction in inflammatory compounds. The vegan diet achieves this reduction by excluding meat (41%), minimising the consumption of added fats (27%), and avoiding dairy products (14%).

The Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine (PCRM) published research in the journal Frontiers in Nutrition, which revealed that a low-fat vegan diet reduces harmful inflammatory dietary compounds called "advanced glycation end-products" (AGEs) by 73%. AGEs are formed when proteins or fats combine with sugar in the body and often lead to chronic inflammation. This inflammation is linked to various diseases, including heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

The PCRM study compared a low-fat vegan diet to a Mediterranean diet. The vegan diet consisted of fruits, vegetables, grains, and beans, while the Mediterranean diet included fruits, vegetables, legumes, fish, low-fat dairy, and extra-virgin olive oil. Neither group had a calorie limit. The study found that participants on the vegan diet lost an average of 13 pounds and had a significant reduction in AGEs, while those on the Mediterranean diet showed no change.

The lead author of the study, Hana Kahleova, MD, PhD, emphasised that choosing a low-fat vegan diet helps reduce the intake of harmful AGEs, leading to significant weight loss. She added that a vegan diet is a simple and delicious way to maintain a healthy weight and fight chronic disease.

The vegan diet's ability to reduce inflammatory compounds by 73% highlights its potential as an effective approach to combat chronic inflammation and improve overall health.

The Mediterranean diet is ineffective at reducing these compounds

Research by the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine found that a vegan diet is more effective than the Mediterranean diet in reducing harmful inflammatory dietary compounds called advanced glycation end-products (AGEs). AGEs are linked to inflammation and oxidative stress, which contribute to chronic diseases like heart disease and type 2 diabetes. The vegan diet reduced these compounds by 73%, while the Mediterranean diet showed no reduction.

The Mediterranean diet includes fruits, vegetables, legumes, fish, low-fat dairy, and extra-virgin olive oil. While it does contain anti-inflammatory foods such as fruits and vegetables, it also includes foods that are high in AGEs, such as dairy and fish. The vegan diet, on the other hand, excludes all animal products, which are generally higher in AGEs than plant foods.

The reduction in AGEs on the vegan diet came mainly from excluding meat, minimizing added fats, and avoiding dairy products. Meat contributed to 41% of the reduction, added fats 27%, and dairy 14%. By contrast, the Mediterranean diet does not restrict these foods, and therefore does not effectively reduce the intake of AGEs.

The ineffectiveness of the Mediterranean diet in reducing AGEs may be due to the inclusion of animal products and added fats. While it does contain anti-inflammatory foods, the presence of these other compounds may counteract their beneficial effects. Therefore, the vegan diet is more effective at reducing harmful inflammatory compounds.

Vegan diets are more restrictive and harder to maintain

While a vegan diet has been shown to be more effective in reducing harmful inflammatory compounds, it is also more restrictive and harder to maintain than a Mediterranean diet.

Vegan diets eliminate all animal products, including meat, dairy, eggs, and seafood, as well as animal-derived additives like honey, gelatin, and butter. This makes vegan diets more restrictive than Mediterranean diets, which allow moderate consumption of animal products. The vegan diet focuses mainly on which foods to avoid, rather than which foods to eat, and this can make it feel more challenging to follow.

The restrictive nature of veganism may lead to a higher risk of nutritional deficiencies, especially without careful planning. For example, vitamin B12 and iron deficiencies are common concerns for vegans. On the other hand, the Mediterranean diet encourages a variety of nutrient-dense foods, making it easier to meet nutritional needs. It emphasizes heart-healthy fats, fiber-rich fruits and vegetables, and whole grains.

Additionally, the Mediterranean diet promotes a more social aspect to eating, encouraging meals to be shared with others whenever possible. This social aspect of eating can also contribute to overall wellness and make the diet easier to stick to in the long term.

While a vegan diet may offer more significant reductions in inflammation, it is important to consider the restrictiveness and long-term feasibility of the diet. The Mediterranean diet, with its variety of food options and social aspects, may be easier to maintain and can still offer notable health benefits.

The Mediterranean diet is more nutritionally balanced

The Mediterranean diet is based on the traditional eating patterns of countries like Greece, Spain, and Italy. It includes a variety of nutrient-dense, plant-based foods, such as fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and legumes, as well as animal products in moderation, including poultry, eggs, and seafood. Red meat and processed meat are limited. The diet also emphasizes heart-healthy fats, whole grains, and sharing meals with others. By contrast, the vegan diet is more restrictive, focusing on avoiding animal products and ingredients.

The Mediterranean diet is also less restrictive in that it does not set strict rules on which foods are permitted. While it recommends limiting processed foods, refined grains, and added sugars, it does not require the same level of restriction as a vegan diet. This flexibility makes it easier to stick to the Mediterranean diet long-term and ensures that nutritional needs are met.

The Mediterranean diet has been linked to improved brain function and extensively studied for its ability to improve heart health and protect against heart disease and stroke. It has also been associated with improved blood sugar control and a reduced risk of developing type 2 diabetes. While the vegan diet has been shown to promote heart health and lower cholesterol, the research on its effects on brain function is limited.

In conclusion, while both diets emphasize plant-based foods, the Mediterranean diet is more nutritionally balanced. It includes a wider variety of nutrient-dense ingredients, is less restrictive, and is easier to follow, ensuring that individuals meet their nutritional needs.

Both diets are anti-inflammatory

The Mediterranean diet is based on the traditional eating patterns of Mediterranean countries like Greece, Spain, and Italy. It promotes a variety of flavorful and nutritious foods, including fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, legumes, poultry, eggs, dairy, and seafood. Red meat and processed meat products are not excluded but are limited. This diet also encourages enjoying heart-healthy fats and sharing meals with others.

The vegan diet, on the other hand, focuses on plant-based foods and eliminates all animal products, including meat, dairy, eggs, and honey. It is associated with health and environmental benefits, providing extra fiber and phytochemicals from plant-based proteins. A vegan diet can also be a healthy way to combat chronic inflammation.

Research has shown that a low-fat vegan diet can reduce harmful inflammatory compounds called advanced glycation end-products (AGEs) by 73%, resulting in an average weight loss of 13 pounds. This reduction in AGEs is mainly due to the exclusion of meat, added fats, and dairy products. The Mediterranean diet, while not showing a reduction in AGEs, has been linked to improved heart health and a reduced risk of heart disease and stroke.

Both diets emphasize anti-inflammatory principles by including fresh fruits and vegetables, whole grains, and healthy fats. They are both effective in managing inflammation and offer notable health benefits, although the vegan diet may provide more significant weight loss results.

Frequently asked questions