Vegan Diets For Babies: Sacred Cow Or Child Abuse?

Veganism is an increasingly popular lifestyle choice, with more and more people choosing to cut out animal products from their diets. However, the question of whether this diet is suitable for babies and young children is a highly contested issue. While some argue that a vegan diet can provide all the necessary nutrients for a growing child, others claim that it poses serious health risks and should be made illegal. So, should vegan diets for babies be illegal? This article will explore the arguments on both sides of the debate and consider the potential consequences of allowing or restricting veganism in early childhood.

Babies on vegan diets are at risk of malnutrition and developmental issues

Veganism has gained notable attention worldwide, with many people transitioning to a plant-based diet. While vegan diets can be healthy for adults, they can be dangerous for young children and infants. Babies and toddlers have extremely rapid growth rates, and their bodily demands for growth require adequate nutrients from the most efficient sources possible.

Nutritional Deficits

Vegan diets may not meet the nutritional needs of growing babies and toddlers. They are at risk of nutritional deficits, particularly in protein, calcium, vitamins D and B12, iron, and zinc. These nutrients are abundant in milk and milk products, which vegan diets do not allow. While breastfeeding or soy-based infant formulas can ensure a healthful vegan diet for newborns, it is more difficult to maintain proper nutrition after the age of one. Babies and toddlers need diets high in fat and protein and low in fiber, which is the opposite of many vegan diets.

Health Risks

A study from the UK found that vegan children are over an inch shorter than their peers, with weaker and brittle bones. They are also three times more likely to be vitamin B12 deficient than omnivores. B12 deficiency has been linked to abnormal mood and brain disorders, depression, weakness, changes in balance or coordination, damage to the optic nerve, and inflammatory processes. There have been numerous reports of children in the US and abroad who have suffered detrimental consequences of vegan diets, including malnutrition and even death.

Legal Implications

With story after story of child malnutrition and death related to veganism, some countries have implemented protective laws to prevent more tragedies. In 2019, Belgium's Royal Academy of Medicine labeled vegan diets for children as "unethical" and encouraged prosecution of parents who enforce this diet. In Italy, a controversial bill has been proposed to jail parents who restrict their children to a vegan diet, claiming that these diets are "devoid of essential elements for [children's] healthy and balanced growth".

There have been cases of criminal prosecution for parents who enforce a vegan diet on their children

There have been several cases of criminal prosecution for parents enforcing a vegan diet on their children. In 2019, an Australian couple pled guilty to failing to provide their child with the necessities of life by forcing her to follow a strict vegan diet. The child was severely malnourished, and her growth was stunted. In 2017, a Belgian judge convicted two parents after their seven-month-old baby died as a result of being fed a vegan diet. The infant was underweight, and his organs had shrunk.

In Italy, Elvira Savino, the deputy of the centre-right Forza Italia party, has proposed legislation that would see parents who give their children aged 16 and under an "inadequate" diet sentenced to up to six years in prison. This follows a string of high-profile cases of malnutrition brought on by veganism. In one case, a one-year-old boy in Milan raised on a strict vegan diet was removed from his parents' custody after being found severely malnourished. In another instance, a two-year-old toddler spent several days in intensive care in a pediatric hospital in Genoa, being treated for vitamin deficiencies as a result of her vegan diet.

In the United States, there have also been cases of intervention and prosecution. In 2019, a Florida couple faced criminal charges after their one-year-old son died due to malnutrition from a vegan diet. In Pennsylvania, a similar case occurred in which a woman was charged with feeding her 11-month-old baby an extreme vegan diet, resulting in development delays.

The American Dietetic Association says vegan diets are suitable for children but require careful planning

The American Dietetic Association (ADA) states that well-planned vegan diets can be "healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases". This includes during infancy and childhood. The ADA also notes that a vegetarian diet can meet current recommendations for nutrients such as protein, n-3 fatty acids, iron, zinc, iodine, calcium, and vitamins D and B-12.

However, it is important to note that vegan diets for babies and young children require careful planning to ensure they receive adequate nutrition. The ADA and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) emphasize the importance of parents providing appropriate foods for vegan infants. Key considerations include the composition of breast milk from vegan mothers, appropriate breast milk substitutes, supplements, the type and amount of dietary fat, and the introduction of solid foods.

Breast milk or soy-based infant formula should be the sole source of nutrition for the first 4 to 6 months of a baby's life. After this period, solid foods can be introduced, with tofu, dried beans, and meat alternatives offered as protein sources. To ensure adequate nutrition, older infants may require supplements such as vitamin B12, vitamin D, zinc, and iron.

While vegan diets can be suitable for children, they may not be appropriate for all. Some circumstances where a vegan diet may not be the best choice include children with feeding difficulties or health conditions that affect their ability to eat or digest food. Additionally, babies born prematurely may benefit from the growth-promoting proteins and fats found in animal products. It is crucial to consult with a pediatrician and, if necessary, a pediatric dietitian to ensure the child's nutritional needs are met.

The Royal Academy of Medicine in Belgium has labelled vegan diets for children as unethical

The Royal Academy of Medicine in Belgium has taken a strong stance against vegan diets for children, going so far as to label the practice as unethical. This statement was made in response to several cases of child malnutrition and even death related to vegan diets in the country. The Academy's report stated that vegan diets were "unsuitable for unborn children, children, teenagers, and pregnant and lactating women".

The report suggested that vegan diets are likely to be deficient in essential nutrients such as high-quality protein, vitamins D and B12, calcium, iron, zinc, iodine, and DHA. It argued that these nutrients must be obtained from animal products and that the potential for deficiency poses serious health risks to children, who have higher requirements for these nutrients due to their rapid growth and development.

However, the report from the Royal Academy of Medicine of Belgium has been met with criticism from some health professionals and doctors of science. A separate group of Belgian doctors analysed the studies on which the opinion of the Royal Academy of Medicine is based and found that many of the sources cited actually conclude that a well-planned and balanced vegan diet is beneficial for health at all stages of life. They argue that the report is "poorly referenced" and contains "long-discredited myths about vegan diets".

The Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, a US non-profit body of more than 12,000 doctors, stated that the Belgium report was “erroneous and misleading”. They noted that people eating vegan diets received twice the protein their bodies needed and had adequate intakes of vitamins B12 and D, calcium, omega-3 fats, iron, and zinc. The only essential nutrient that is not obtained reliably from food alone in a vegan diet is vitamin B12, which can be easily supplemented.

The debate around vegan diets for children is complex and multifaceted. While some argue that it is unethical and dangerous, others maintain that a well-planned and balanced vegan diet can be suitable and even beneficial for children. It is important for parents to carefully consider the nutritional needs of their children and consult with paediatricians and nutritionists to ensure their children's dietary needs are met.

Italy has proposed a bill to jail parents who enforce a vegan diet on their children

The bill specifically targets parents who pursue a vegan diet "to the detriment of minors", aiming to "stigmatise the reckless and dangerous eating behaviour imposed by parents". It follows several high-profile Italian cases where malnourished children have been taken into care, including four cases over the last 18 months where children were hospitalised after being fed a vegan diet.

The proposed bill has sparked debate, with some nutrition experts challenging its validity. Critics argue that there is a more pressing need to address Italy's childhood obesity problem and that better public health education would be more effective than punitive measures. Others caution that the bill's imprecise wording could be used to penalise a wider range of parents, not just vegans or vegetarians.

Supporters of the bill, including Savino, argue that vegan diets can be dangerous for children, leading to severe malnutrition and neurological problems. They contend that vegan diets often lack essential nutrients such as vitamin B12, vitamin D, calcium, iron, zinc, and protein, which are critical for proper growth and development. Savino also highlights the belief in Italy that a vegan diet offers "substantial health benefits", which she claims is spreading without proper scientific knowledge or medical consultation.

While the debate around the legality of vegan diets for babies and children continues, it is clear that there are valid concerns about the potential health risks associated with these diets. It remains to be seen whether Italy will pass the controversial bill and what impact it could have on vegan practices in the country.

Frequently asked questions