Alkaline Diets: Are They Truly Vegan-Friendly?

The alkaline diet and veganism are two distinct concepts, with some similarities and differences. Veganism is a lifestyle and dietary choice that abstains from all animal products, motivated by concerns for animal welfare and the environment. In contrast, the alkaline diet focuses on the belief that eating alkaline-forming foods can optimise cell function and prevent diseases. While both diets promote plant-based eating, the alkaline diet allows for some animal products, such as ocean fish and goat's cheese, which are considered moderately acidic. The alkaline diet also emphasises the avoidance of sugar, fungus, and yeast, which are not always excluded by vegans. Ultimately, the alkaline diet is mostly vegan, but a vegan diet is not always alkalarian.

Alkaline diets are based on the unproven claim that eating foods with a higher pH will reduce the risk of chronic diseases

The alkaline diet is based on the unproven claim that eating foods with a higher pH will reduce the risk of chronic diseases. Proponents of the alkaline diet believe that eating certain foods can alter the pH of the body. The diet recommends eating alkaline-forming foods such as fruits, vegetables, nuts, and legumes, while avoiding acid-forming foods like meat, dairy, eggs, grains, and alcohol.

The theory behind the alkaline diet is that the metabolic waste, or "ash," produced when food is converted into energy can affect the body's acidity. Alkaline ash is believed to protect against illness, while acidic ash is thought to make the body vulnerable to disease. By choosing more alkaline foods, followers of the diet aim to “alkalize” their bodies and improve their health.

However, there is no scientific evidence to support the claim that the alkaline diet can change the body's pH level. The body tightly regulates blood pH levels, and food does not significantly affect blood pH. While food can change the pH of urine, this is not a reflection of the body's overall pH.

Despite the lack of evidence supporting its main premise, the alkaline diet does encourage healthy eating patterns, such as emphasizing unprocessed and plant-based foods. Some studies have found that following the alkaline diet may increase certain micronutrients and offer health benefits such as improved cardiovascular health and reduced risk of hypertension and stroke.

In conclusion, while the alkaline diet may offer some health benefits due to its focus on healthy foods, the claim that it reduces the risk of chronic diseases by altering the body's pH remains unproven.

Alkaline diets focus on eating foods that create an alkaline environment in the body

The alkaline diet, also known as the acid-alkaline or alkaline ash diet, claims that eating certain foods can alter the pH of your body. Metabolism is like a chemical reaction that converts food into energy and leaves behind an "ash" residue known as metabolic waste. This waste consists of acidic, neutral, or alkaline ash. Proponents of this diet argue that the acidity of the ash affects your body's acidity. Alkaline ash is believed to protect you from illness, while acidic ash can make you vulnerable.

According to the diet, foods that are acidic and should be avoided include meat, poultry, fish, dairy, eggs, grains, and alcohol. Neutral foods, which should be limited, include natural fats, milk, starches, and sugars. Alkaline foods, which should be consumed in abundance, include fruits, nuts, legumes, and vegetables.

It is important to note that the claim that the alkaline diet can change your body's pH level is unproven. While the diet does promote healthy eating patterns and can offer health benefits, it is not necessarily due to its impact on body pH levels.

Alkaline diets are mostly vegan, but vegans do not always follow an alkaline diet

The alkaline diet is based on the claim that eating foods with a higher pH, or those that are more alkaline, will help reduce your risk of chronic diseases like cancer. It is also known as the acid-alkaline or alkaline ash diet. The diet suggests that eating certain foods can alter the pH of your body.

The alkaline diet is mostly vegan, as it recommends eating lots of fruits, vegetables, nuts, and legumes, and avoiding meat, dairy, eggs, grains, and alcohol. However, it is not entirely vegan, as some alkaline dieters eat ocean fish and goat's cheese, which are considered moderately acidic foods. Vegans, on the other hand, do not consume any animal products, so they would not eat these foods. Additionally, vegans may still eat some processed foods, such as sugar and mock meat, which are not recommended on the alkaline diet.

The alkaline diet is also more restrictive than a vegan diet in other ways. For example, alkaline dieters avoid all types of sugar, including high-sugar fruits, and fermented foods, which are not typically restricted on a vegan diet.

While there is some overlap between the two diets, it is important to note that they are not the same. The alkaline diet is primarily focused on balancing the body's pH levels, while veganism is centered around animal welfare and the environment.

Alkaline diets are not designed for weight loss

Registered dietitian Kathleen Zelman notes that when you start eliminating so many foods and most of your foods are fruits, vegetables, and water, you will likely lose weight. However, she says that this type of diet is not sustainable because people often feel unsatisfied and return to their normal eating habits. She warns that fad diets like the alkaline diet may cause a yo-yo effect, where people regain the weight they lost and sometimes even gain a few extra pounds.

Zelman also points out that the alkaline diet is too restrictive and does not include enough protein and calcium. She says that a balanced diet should include whole grains, dairy, and protein, which are restricted on the alkaline diet. Additionally, there is no mention of exercise in the alkaline diet plan, which is an important component of a healthy lifestyle.

While the alkaline diet may promote weight loss in the short term, it is not designed for sustainable weight loss due to its restrictive nature and lack of emphasis on physical activity.

Alkaline diets are not recommended for people with cancer, kidney disease, osteoporosis, or any other chronic health condition

Firstly, it is important to note that the alkaline diet is based on the misconception that consuming or avoiding certain foods can change the body's pH levels. This is not true. While the diet may cause a change in the pH of urine or saliva, it will not alter the pH of the blood. The body is designed to maintain a very specific pH of the blood, and any major changes in blood pH could be life-threatening.

Secondly, the alkaline diet is often promoted as a way to prevent or treat cancer. However, there is no scientific evidence to support these claims. While some research suggests that cancer cells grow more rapidly in an acidic environment, this does not mean that an alkaline diet will prevent cancer or slow its progression. In fact, cancer can occur in all parts of the body, regardless of the pH level.

For people with kidney disease, the alkaline diet may provide some benefits, but it is not necessary to follow a specific alkaline diet. Simply reducing protein intake may help improve symptoms or slow the progression of the disease. A low-protein diet can be hard on the kidneys, so it is important to ensure you are still getting enough protein from plant-based sources.

The alkaline diet is also not recommended for people with osteoporosis, as it may contribute to bone mineral density loss. While the theory suggests that the body takes alkaline minerals from the bones to buffer acids from acid-forming foods, this ignores the function of the kidneys and lungs in regulating blood pH levels. Recent scientific evidence suggests no link between dietary acid and bone health. Instead, a high-protein, acid-forming diet may be linked to better bone health.

Finally, the alkaline diet may not be suitable for people with other chronic health conditions, as it can be restrictive and may increase the risk of vitamin, mineral, and protein deficiencies. It is always recommended to speak with a doctor or dietitian before starting any new diet, especially if you have a medical condition.

Frequently asked questions