Plant-Based Diets: Expensive Or Affordable?

There is a common misconception that veganism is expensive. However, this is not necessarily true. While some vegan specialty foods, like meat and dairy substitutes, are more expensive than their non-vegan counterparts, it is possible to be vegan on a budget.

Meat is one of the most expensive items on a grocery list. Replacing meat with cheaper alternatives like lentils, chickpeas, and beans can significantly reduce food costs. A study by Oxford University found that a vegan diet reduced food costs by up to one-third. Similarly, a study by the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine found that a low-fat vegan diet decreased food costs by 16%, amounting to savings of more than $500 a year.

Cooking from scratch and buying whole foods like fruits, vegetables, grains, and legumes is a cost-effective way to eat vegan. Buying in bulk, shopping seasonally, and opting for supermarket own-brand goods can also help reduce costs.

Vegan diets can be cheaper than omnivorous diets

The Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine found that food costs decreased by 16% on a low-fat vegan diet—a saving of more than $500 a year—compared to a diet that includes meat, dairy, and other animal products. This was mainly due to savings on meat and dairy.

However, vegan diets can be more expensive if they rely on processed foods and meat substitutes. One source suggests that the idea that vegan diets are more expensive stems from the notion that eating plant-based means simply replacing meat with substitutes, which can be costly.

Vegan diets that focus on whole foods such as lentils, chickpeas, and other pulses, as well as fruits and vegetables, are likely to be cheaper. Buying in bulk, shopping seasonally, and cooking from scratch can also help to keep costs down.

Vegan diets can be more expensive than omnivorous diets

The perception that vegan diets are more expensive is a common one, and it can be a barrier to people making the switch. However, several studies have shown that vegan diets can be cheaper. One study, published in the Lancet Planetary Health, found that vegan diets reduced food costs by up to one-third in high-income countries. Another study, by the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, found that a vegan diet reduced food costs by 16%, saving shoppers more than $500 a year.

There are several ways to keep costs down on a vegan diet. Buying seasonal fruit and vegetables is one way to save money, as well as buying in bulk. Cooking in batches and freezing meals is another way to save money, and it also saves time and energy. It is also a good idea to plan meals in advance and make a shopping list, so that you only buy what you need.

However, there are some drawbacks to a vegan diet. It can be time-consuming to cook everything from scratch, and it may be difficult to get all the nutrients you need, especially if you are not careful to plan your meals. It is also worth noting that meat and dairy prices are often kept artificially low due to government subsidies.

The difference in cost depends on the type of food

The difference in cost between plant-based and omnivorous diets depends on the type of food being consumed. A study by Oxford University found that vegan diets were the most affordable, reducing food costs by up to one-third due to the use of whole foods over meat and meat replacements. The study also found that vegetarian diets were a close second, and flexitarian diets with low amounts of meat and dairy reduced costs by 14%.

However, some argue that veganism can be more expensive, especially when it comes to vegan substitutes for meat and dairy products. For example, at one store, plant-based milk was priced at $4+ for 1.8 litres, while dairy milk was $3 for 3.8 litres. Similarly, plant-based sausage was priced at $4+ for a 4-pack, while meat sausage was $3-4 for an 8-pack.

The key difference in cost, therefore, seems to lie in the type of food being consumed. A plant-based diet that relies heavily on whole foods and home cooking is likely to be cheaper than an omnivorous diet that includes meat and dairy. On the other hand, a plant-based diet that relies heavily on processed and substitute foods may be more expensive than an omnivorous diet that includes cheaper, non-organic meat and dairy products.

It is worth noting that the cost of food is not the only factor to consider when choosing a diet. The environmental and health benefits of a plant-based diet may outweigh the potential cost savings of an omnivorous diet for some individuals. Additionally, cooking skills and access to affordable, fresh produce can also impact the cost of a plant-based diet.

The difference in cost depends on the type of diet

A study by Oxford University found that vegan diets reduced food costs by up to one-third, while vegetarian diets were a close second, and flexitarian diets with limited meat and dairy reduced costs by 14%. Similarly, a Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine analysis revealed a 16% decrease in food costs on a low-fat vegan diet, amounting to savings of over $500 per year.

The key to an affordable vegan diet is to opt for whole foods such as lentils, chickpeas, oats, pasta, rice, and beans, which are not only cheap but also versatile and nutritious. Cooking from scratch and buying in bulk can further reduce costs. In contrast, a diet reliant on processed vegan meats and frozen food can be expensive.

While some vegan specialty foods like prepared veggie burgers may be pricier than their non-vegan counterparts, it is important to remember that prepared food generally tends to be more expensive than cooking from scratch. Additionally, vegan staples like pasta, rice, tofu, and beans are often much cheaper than meat.

It is worth noting that the cost of a vegan diet can vary depending on location. In some places, plant-based milk, sausage, and cheese may be more expensive than their dairy and meat equivalents. However, this is not a universal experience, and prices can differ significantly between stores and regions.

Overall, a vegan diet can be more affordable than an omnivorous diet, but this depends on the specific foods chosen and the availability of affordable plant-based options in one's area.

The difference in cost depends on the type of country

However, in lower-income countries, such as those on the Indian subcontinent and in sub-Saharan Africa, eating a healthy and sustainable diet can be up to a quarter cheaper than a typical Western diet, but it is at least a third more expensive than current diets. This is because current low-income diets tend to contain large amounts of starchy foods and not enough of the foods known to be healthy.

Frequently asked questions