Vegan Burgers: Friend Or Foe On Plant-Based Diet?

Vegan burgers are allowed on a plant-based diet. Plant-based burgers are made from plant sources such as peas, soybeans, and black beans, and do not contain meat or animal-derived products like eggs and dairy. While vegan burgers are a good option for those looking for a more ethical and environmentally-friendly alternative, they may not be the healthiest option due to high levels of sodium and saturated fat.

Vegan burgers are allowed on a plant-based diet

Plant-based burgers get their ingredients from plant sources such as peas, soybeans, black beans, and more. They do not contain meat or animal-derived products like dairy or eggs.

There are many options available for people following a plant-based diet, including burgers. However, it is important to note that not all plant-based burgers are the same. Some may be highly processed and contain added sugar, salt, colour additives, flavour enhancers, or preservatives that individuals may want to avoid.

For example, the Impossible Burger, made primarily of soy protein concentrate, coconut and sunflower oil, vitamins, minerals, and heme, which makes the burger "bleed" and brown like meat, contains around 40% of the daily value for saturated fat and 370 mg of sodium, which is more than four times as much as a beef patty.

The Beyond Burger, made from pea and mung bean protein, coconut oil, cocoa butter, potato starch, and beet juice extract, has been reformulated to be healthier. The latest version, introduced in 2024, contains 60% less saturated fat and lower sodium levels than previous versions.

If you are looking for a healthier option, you may want to consider making your own veggie burgers at home using beans, whole grains, herbs, seeds, and nuts. This gives you more control over the ingredients and cooking methods used.

Overall, vegan burgers are allowed on a plant-based diet, but it is important to read labels and be mindful of the ingredients and processing methods used.

Vegan burgers are made from plant sources

Vegan burgers are typically made from a combination of plant-based ingredients such as peas, soybeans, black beans, and other vegetables. Some common ingredients include oats, pinto beans, green peas, brown rice, pecans, sweet potato, and black beans.

While the specific ingredients and combinations vary across brands, the goal is often to replicate the taste, texture, and experience of a traditional diner burger, including the juices and flame-broiled taste. This has been achieved through the addition of specific ingredients like coconut oil and plant heme, which provide the desired meaty texture, juiciness, and flavour.

The processing methods for vegan burgers are similar to those for animal meat. The plant-based ingredients are mixed, ground, and formed into patties, which are then frozen for transport and sold in packages of four to six.

It is important to note that vegan burgers may contain highly processed ingredients, added sugars, salt, colour additives, flavour enhancers, and preservatives. As such, they may not be the healthiest option, and some individuals may prefer to make their own burgers at home using whole food, plant-based ingredients.

They are highly processed

Vegan burgers are highly processed, and it is this level of processing that has enabled food manufacturers to create a product that mimics the taste and texture of meat.

Vegan burgers are made from a variety of ingredients, including pea protein, coconut oil, cocoa butter, calcium, iron, potato starch, beetroot juice, and soy protein concentrate. These ingredients are processed in a similar way to animal meat, going through a mixing/grinding process to create a ground beef consistency. The resulting "meat" is then pressed into patties and frozen for transport.

While vegan burgers have the benefit of being free from cholesterol, they are often high in saturated fat and sodium. For example, the Impossible Burger has been found to have 40% of the daily value for saturated fat, and 370 mg of sodium, which is more than four times as much as a beef patty. The Beyond Burger also had similar nutritional issues until it was reformulated in 2024, with the new version containing 60% less saturated fat and lower sodium levels.

The level of processing and the inclusion of ingredients such as coconut oil mean that vegan burgers may not be the healthiest option, especially for those following a heart-healthy diet. As Registered Dietitian Ginger Hultin explains, "They use a blend of ingredients that includes saturated fat, similar to a beef burger, but from coconut oil."

While vegan burgers can be a good option for those looking to reduce their meat consumption, it is important to be aware of the potential health risks associated with highly processed foods.

They may not be the healthiest option

Vegan burgers are allowed on a plant-based diet, but they may not be the healthiest option. While vegan burgers are a great alternative to meat and are better for the environment and animal welfare, they are often highly processed and may contain high levels of saturated fat, sodium, and calories.

The Impossible Burger, for example, has been criticised for its high levels of saturated fat, mainly due to the use of coconut oil. It also has 370 mg of sodium, which is more than four times the amount found in a beef patty. The Beyond Burger, another popular vegan burger, has also been found to have high levels of sodium, although the company has since released a new version with lower levels of saturated fat and sodium.

Vegan burgers are often highly processed, and some contain genetically modified ingredients, which may be a concern for those seeking a more natural, whole-food diet. The reality is that just because something is plant-based, does not automatically make it healthy.

Some people may also be concerned about the long list of ingredients in vegan burgers, which can include binders, vitamins, minerals, and various plant-based proteins and fats. While these ingredients are used to replicate the taste and texture of meat, they may not be as healthy as a homemade veggie burger made from beans, whole grains, herbs, seeds, and nuts.

In addition, the cooking methods used for vegan burgers, both in restaurants and at home, can affect their healthiness. For example, they may be cooked in oil, adding extra fat, or served on the same grill as meat products, which may be a concern for some vegetarians and vegans.

While vegan burgers can be a good option for those looking to reduce their meat consumption, they may not be the healthiest choice for those primarily concerned with improving their health. It is always important to consider the ingredients and nutritional information of any food product, including vegan burgers, to ensure it aligns with your specific health goals and dietary needs.

They are better for the environment

Vegan burgers are allowed on a plant-based diet. However, it is important to note that plant-based diets are not entirely vegan. While they prioritize calories from plants, fruits, and vegetables, they do not necessarily eliminate meat, fish, or animal-derived products.

Vegan burgers are better for the environment than meat burgers. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, livestock accounts for 14.5% of annual worldwide greenhouse gas emissions produced by human activity, with cattle (raised for beef and milk) alone producing 65% of those emissions.

Vegan burgers have a significantly smaller carbon footprint than their meat-based counterparts. For example, the Beyond Meat burger uses 99% less water, 93% less land, and 90% less fossil fuel emissions than a quarter-pound of regular ground beef. Similarly, the Impossible Burger uses 87% less water, 96% less land, and 89% less fossil fuel emissions.

If everyone in the US reduced their meat consumption by a quarter and replaced it with plant-based proteins, it would save 82 million metric tons of greenhouse emissions each year. This shift towards plant-based diets is critical to mitigating and adapting to climate change, as simply cutting carbon emissions from automobiles and factories will not be enough to prevent an impending crisis.

However, it is worth noting that vegan burgers are not a "magic bullet." They are still more processed than whole foods and legumes, and some researchers argue that unprocessed plant-based diets are healthier and better for the planet than processed vegan burgers.

Frequently asked questions