Calorie Counting On Keto: Friend Or Foe?

The ketogenic diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that has gained popularity in recent years. While the keto diet does not require calorie counting, it is important to understand the role of calories in weight loss and how they relate to the keto diet. Calories are a unit of energy that the body uses for various functions, and weight loss occurs when there is a calorie deficit. On keto, the reduction of carbohydrates and increase of fat and protein intake can lead to a natural reduction in calorie intake, especially for those who are overweight. However, it is still possible to consume too many calories on a ketogenic diet, and portion control and physical activity are important factors in creating a calorie deficit. Additionally, the type of calories consumed also matters, as different macronutrients have varying calorie contents and metabolic effects. Overall, while calorie counting may not be necessary on keto, being mindful of calorie intake and prioritizing quality over quantity can help individuals achieve their weight loss goals.

Calorie Counting: A Flawed Process

Calorie counting is a flawed process for several reasons. Firstly, it requires a lot of cognitive effort to determine the number of calories consumed accurately. People often struggle to quantify their food intake accurately, and even those who meticulously track their calories can still make significant errors. This is because digestion, nutrient partitioning, and individual variations in calorie absorption make it challenging to calculate the exact number of calories derived from a particular food.

Secondly, calorie counts for the same food can vary depending on the database or source used, introducing further inaccuracies. For example, the calorie content of produce can differ based on where it was purchased and other factors. Therefore, it is challenging to get an exact count of calories consumed, and one can only estimate a ballpark figure.

Additionally, the "calories in, calories out" model assumes that all calories are created equal, which is not the case. Different types of macronutrients (carbohydrates, proteins, and fats) have varying calorie contents and are processed differently by the body. This concept is known as the "thermic effect of food" (TEF), and it means that the composition of your diet influences energy balance. For instance, protein has a higher thermic effect than carbohydrates or fat, requiring more energy to be metabolized.

Furthermore, the "calories in, calories out" model does not account for individual variations in metabolic rate, physical activity levels, and other factors that influence energy expenditure. Resting metabolic rate can also be affected by diet composition, with low-carbohydrate and high-protein diets potentially preserving or even increasing it during weight loss.

Lastly, calorie counting can be time-consuming and unpleasant, requiring individuals to restrict their food intake and feel hungry frequently. This can make long-term adherence to a calorie-restricted diet challenging and increase the likelihood of weight regain.

In conclusion, while calorie counting can provide a rough estimate of calorie intake, it is inherently flawed due to the complexities of human physiology, metabolism, and individual variations in calorie absorption and expenditure.

Ketogenic Diets and Weight Loss

The ketogenic diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that has been shown to aid in weight loss, while also suppressing appetite and lowering cholesterol. The diet was initially used to treat epilepsy in children but has since become a mainstream lifestyle for many.

Calories and Ketogenic Diets

The question of whether calories need to be monitored on a ketogenic diet is a highly debated topic. The traditional weight-loss model follows the "calories in, calories out" approach, which simply states that to lose weight, an individual must consume fewer calories than they burn. However, this model has been criticised for its oversimplification of weight loss and has been deemed unsuccessful by some.

Calories In

Determining the exact number of calories consumed is challenging due to various factors, such as individual differences in calorie extraction from food and the inherent errors in calorie counting methods. Additionally, the "calories in, calories out" model does not account for metabolic changes that occur with calorie restriction, which can lead to a weight loss plateau or even weight regain.

Calories Out

Furthermore, not all calories are created equal. Different macronutrients (carbohydrates, proteins, and fats) have different calorie contents and are processed differently by the body. A calorie derived from protein will have a different impact compared to a calorie from fat or carbohydrates. This concept is known as the "thermic effect of food" (TEF).

Ketogenic Diets and Calorie Counting

Ketogenic diets are unique in that they naturally regulate calorie intake without the need for explicit calorie counting. The diet eliminates junk food, prevents blood sugar highs and crashes, and promotes satiety through protein- and fat-rich foods. As a result, individuals tend to eat less without having to consciously restrict their calorie intake.

While calories do play a role in weight loss, the ketogenic diet addresses weight management through several mechanisms, including hormonal regulation, appetite suppression, and metabolic changes. Therefore, while some individuals may benefit from initial calorie counting to get a general idea of their intake, strict calorie control is not necessary for successful weight loss on a ketogenic diet.

The Metabolic Advantage of Ketogenic Diets

The ketogenic diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that has been around for nearly 100 years. It was initially used as a natural treatment for epilepsy but fell out of favour after the discovery of new anti-seizure drugs. The keto diet has since gained popularity as a weight-loss method, with many people reporting success in a short period.

Calories and Ketogenic Diets

The idea that "a calorie is a calorie" is a simplistic conclusion. While it is true that a calorie deficit is necessary for weight loss, this does not mean that all calories are created equal. The thermic effect of food (TEF) and the "calories in, calories out" model (CICO) are important factors to consider when discussing the metabolic advantage of ketogenic diets.

The Thermic Effect of Food (TEF)

The thermic effect of food refers to the amount of energy required to process and store different types of food. Protein, for example, takes more energy to metabolise compared to carbohydrates and fat. Studies have shown that a diet with a high protein intake resulted in twice the energy expenditure compared to a high-carbohydrate, low-fat diet. This increase in energy expenditure contributes to the metabolic advantage of ketogenic diets.

"Calories In, Calories Out" Model (CICO)

The CICO model states that weight loss can be achieved by consuming less energy than you expend. However, this model does not account for the fact that people are often inaccurate in quantifying how much they eat, and it fails to consider the thermic effect of food. Additionally, as you reduce calories, your resting energy expenditure drops as your metabolism slows down to defend body weight. This can lead to a vicious cycle of further calorie restriction to continue weight loss.

Ketogenic Diets and Weight Loss

Ketogenic diets have been shown to be better for weight loss and long-term weight loss maintenance. In a meta-analysis of 13 diet studies, individuals on a very-low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet (<50g carbohydrates/day) lost significantly more body weight in the long term compared to conventional low-fat diets. This is likely due to the high thermic effect of protein and the fact that ketogenic diets are high in fat and moderate in protein, which are more satiating nutrients than carbohydrates.

The Metabolic Advantage

When matched for calories, low-carbohydrate diets (higher fat and protein intake) have a "metabolic advantage" compared to low-fat, high-carbohydrate diets. This means that for the same amount of calories, low-carb diets result in greater weight loss. This is supported by studies showing superior weight loss on ketogenic diets compared to low-fat diets, as well as trials that measure basal metabolic rate (BMR). Low-carb diets might increase energy expenditure by 100-500 calories per day.

Appetite Suppression

One of the benefits of ketogenic diets is their ability to suppress appetite and regulate hunger. This is likely due to the macronutrient composition of keto diets, which are high in fat and moderate in protein. Ketosis has also been shown to suppress ghrelin, the "hunger hormone". As a result, ketogenic diets might promote a decreased caloric intake, leading to weight loss.

While calorie counting is not necessary on a ketogenic diet, it may be helpful initially to get a general idea of how much you are eating. Ketogenic diets offer a metabolic advantage due to the thermic effect of food and the high satiety value of fat and protein. This leads to a greater energy expenditure and a reduced caloric intake, resulting in weight loss.

Appetite Suppression

One of the most well-known and research-backed aspects of the ketogenic diet is its ability to suppress appetite. This is likely due to the high fat and protein content of keto diets, which are more satiating than carbohydrates.

Ketosis has been shown to suppress ghrelin, often known as the "hunger hormone". Endogenous or exogenous ketosis can have this effect. Exogenous ketosis can be achieved through ketone supplements, which have been shown to suppress appetite by lowering ghrelin.

Medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs) are highly ketogenic and can be used to help reduce hunger. MCTs can be added to coffee or other drinks to help curb hunger throughout the day.

Ketogenic diets are high in fat and protein, which are claimed to be more satiating than carbohydrates. This means that people on keto diets are less likely to overeat and are more likely to stick to their diets.

The ability to go long periods without hunger and control appetite can be empowering and can lead to successful weight loss.

Calorie Counting on Keto

While calorie counting is not necessary on a keto diet, it may be beneficial to do so initially to get a general idea of how much you are eating. Keto foods are inherently high in fat and therefore calorically dense, so it is possible to overindulge.

Additionally, if you are not getting the weight loss results you expected, it may be because you are eating too many calories, mostly in the form of fat. While keto diets can burn fat, a lot of this fat may be coming from dietary sources rather than body fat.

Therefore, while strict calorie control is not necessary on keto, being mindful of your calorie intake and ensuring you are not overeating can help you achieve your weight loss goals.

Calories In, Weight Out

The ketogenic diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that has been around for nearly 100 years. It was initially used to treat epilepsy but has since become a popular way to lose weight. The diet involves drastically reducing carbohydrate intake and increasing fat consumption, which causes the body to burn fat for energy instead of glucose. This state is called ketosis.

Calories In

When it comes to weight loss, it is important to create a calorie deficit. This means consuming fewer calories than your body needs, so it starts burning fat for energy. While calories are important, they are not the only factor in weight loss. The types of food you eat and your body's unique metabolic processes also play a role.

Calories Out

The energy your body uses to perform tasks, like walking and breathing, is measured in calories. The number of calories your body needs to perform these basic functions is called your basal metabolic rate (BMR). Your BMR is influenced by factors like age, gender, body composition, and genetics. Physical activity also plays a role, as the more active you are, the more calories you need.

The Keto Difference

On a keto diet, you may naturally eat fewer calories without realizing it. This is because keto diets tend to be high in protein and fat, which are more filling than carbohydrates. In addition, keto diets eliminate junk food engineered to make you eat mindlessly, and they prevent blood sugar highs and crashes, reducing the need to snack.

Counting Calories on Keto

While calories do matter on a keto diet, strict calorie counting is not always necessary. Keto diets are naturally satiating, so you are less likely to overeat. However, if you are not losing weight, counting calories for a few days can help you identify any problem areas, such as eating too many keto-friendly snacks.

The Bottom Line

To lose weight on a keto diet, you need to burn more calories than you consume. However, the composition of your diet also matters. Eating whole, nutritious, low-carb foods and staying active will help maximize weight loss on a keto diet.

Frequently asked questions