Veganism And Kashrut: Exploring Dietary Overlap And Differences

Veganism and Judaism are not mutually exclusive. In fact, a vegan diet can be kosher, as it does not include meat or dairy, which are prohibited from being mixed in the kosher diet. However, there are certain conditions under which vegan food may not be kosher. For example, if it is prepared by non-Jews, with non-kosher equipment, or without kosher supervision. Additionally, kosher produce must be cleaned to specific standards to avoid insects, and certain foods like wine, grape juice, and balsamic vinegar are not kosher unless certified.

Insects in produce

While a vegan diet is mostly kosher, there are some instances where this is not the case. One of these instances relates to insects in produce.

Vegan organisations have not taken as many measures as kosher certification organisations to ensure that vegan products are insect-free. It is very easy for insects to accidentally end up in vegan products during the harvesting of vegetables and fruits. Vegan foods can be certified as insect-free, but a small number of insects in the final product is usually tolerated.

In contrast, kosher certification requires a higher level of cleaning to ensure the removal of insects. Even a small amount of non-kosher food can contaminate an otherwise kosher dish. The Torah states, "All the swarming things that swarm on the ground you shall not eat" (Leviticus 11:42). This prohibition applies to insects that "live in the seas and in the streams", "fly in the air" and "creep on the ground".

However, there are some exceptions to the rule. For example, grasshoppers are permitted to be eaten according to the Torah, but a rabbinical decision banned the consumption of all grasshoppers due to uncertainty over which species are permitted. Worms found within a fish or hard or aged cheese are also allowed to be eaten, as long as they remain embedded in the food. Additionally, it is permitted to eat worms found in fruit that has been detached from its source of growth and has not been exposed to air.

In summary, while insects in produce are generally not kosher, there are some specific circumstances in which they are allowed to be consumed.

Food prepared by non-Jews

The rabbis of the Talmud instituted this rule to prevent intermarriage with non-Jews. The prohibition of bishul akum applies to a formal meal prepared exclusively by non-Jews, even if there are no other kosher food problems.

The prohibition applies only if the food is prepared exclusively by non-Jews. A small amount of Jewish participation can be enough to keep the food kosher. For example, a Jew may light the fire and place the pot on it to cook, or even make a slight adjustment to a fire that has already been lit.

The law applies only to foods that are "fit for a king's table" and are not generally eaten raw. Foods that would not be served at a state dinner are exempt from bishul akum and are kosher even if cooked totally by non-Jews, provided that all the other requirements of kosher food are met.

In contemporary practice, mashgichim (kosher-food supervisors) help start the stove and/or provide other participation in the cooking process to ensure that the rule of bishul Yisrael is complied with.

At certified kosher restaurants, they ensure that a Jewish person at least assists in the preparation of all the food. Sometimes, this is done just by having them light the flame that will cook all the food.

Food processed without kosher supervision

Food that is processed without kosher supervision may not be considered kosher. A rabbi or kashrut supervising agency must certify a restaurant or processed food product as kosher. Even a small amount of non-kosher food can render a dish non-kosher.

A reliable Orthodox kosher supervision and certification agency has the expertise and resources to research each stage and ingredient of a certified product. Most large kashrut organizations have registered symbols or logos that appear on product packages, signifying the agency's endorsement of the product. This kosher certification symbol is called a hechsher.

Food factories often incorporate ingredients and agents manufactured at other plants, which may contain previously processed ingredients. Many ingredients used by local food-processing factories are imported from countries that do not have reliable supervising rabbis.

A reliable mashgiach (kosher overseer) must supervise the koshering of equipment used to process both kosher and non-kosher products. Even a small amount, such as 1/60th, of a non-kosher ingredient can render a food product non-kosher.

Non-kosher kitchenware used

A vegan diet is generally kosher, but there are some instances where it is not. One of these instances is when non-kosher kitchenware is used.

For food to be strictly kosher, it must be prepared with kitchenware that is kosher. This means that if kitchen equipment has been used to prepare hot, non-kosher food, that equipment must be thoroughly cleaned (koshered) before it can be used to prepare kosher food.

The Torah requires kashering any utensils acquired from a non-Jew, as they are presumed to have been used with non-kosher foods and will therefore have absorbed non-kosher flavours. The basic principle to bear in mind when koshering is that the way the non-kosher food substance is absorbed into the walls of the utensil is the way it is expelled. For example, a pot used for stewing can be koshered by boiling, whereas a pan used for frying or baking can be koshered only by blowtorching (direct contact with heat).

There are several methods for koshering kitchenware, depending on the material and how it was previously used. Here are some examples:

• Libun Gamur (Burning)—For utensils used directly in the fire (e.g. BBQ grates), they must be placed back into the fire, burning away any absorbed non-kosher flavours.
• Libun Kal (Light Burning)—Can be used in place of hagalah (boiling) or when the need for libun (burning) is only an added stringency (e.g. stove grates). The utensil should be cleaned with hot water, left unused for 24 hours, then heated to a dry temperature of 550° F for a minimum of one hour.
• Hagalah (Boiling in water)—For utensils that were used to cook non-kosher items with liquid (e.g. silverware or pots), they must be cleaned with hot water, left unused for 24 hours, then immersed in a pot of boiling water.
• Iruy (Pouring boiling water)—For utensils that only came in contact with hot liquid being poured over them (e.g. a sink faucet), they should be cleaned with hot water, left unused for 24 hours, then have boiling water poured over them.

It is important to note that not all materials can be koshered. For example, earthenware, ceramic, china, porcelain, granite composite, and enamel-coated utensils cannot be koshered. On the other hand, metal, wood, stone, composite stone, natural rubber, fabric, glass, and leather can usually be koshered.

Wine, grape juice, and balsamic vinegar

Wine and grape juice are only kosher if the entire production process is certified as kosher. This is because even a very small amount of non-kosher food can contaminate a kosher dish. For example, if a non-Jew touches non-mevushal wine, it would become non-kosher. Therefore, wine and grape juice must be produced with kosher equipment and under kosher supervision.

Balsamic vinegar is also not kosher unless it is certified as such. This is because balsamic vinegar contains grape juice. Therefore, store-bought and vegan restaurant balsamic vinegar may not be kosher.

Frequently asked questions