Honey And Veganism: Compatible Or Contradictory?

Honey is a food product that sparks a lot of debate among vegans. Some people who follow a plant-based diet have no objection to consuming honey, perhaps because they don't consider bees to be animals. However, honey is an animal product and, therefore, by definition, not vegan. Bees produce honey as a food source to sustain their colony over the winter, and taking this food source may harm the bees.

Honey is an animal product and therefore not vegan

Honey is not vegan because it is an animal product. Bees make honey for bees, and it is their energy source. Without it, they would starve. A worker bee will produce just one-twelfth of a teaspoon of honey in her entire one-month lifetime, and this is food for her colony.

Bees make honey from flower nectar, which they collect in a special stomach called a crop. Inside the crop, nectar is mixed with enzymes that change its chemical composition and break it down into simple sugars. When a bee returns to its hive, it passes the nectar to other bees through regurgitation. This process is repeated until the partially digested nectar is deposited into a honeycomb. Bees then fan the nectar with their wings to speed up the evaporation process, leaving thick, sticky honey.

Honey is not just a food source for bees, it is fundamental to the hive's wellbeing. Bees use honey to keep the hive warm during winter and as an energy source during the months when there is little to forage.

Commercial beekeepers often employ practices that are unethical by vegan standards. These include frequent queen replacement, using protein and carbohydrate supplements to feed the bees, and using antibiotics and synthetic chemicals for pest and pathogen control.

Honey bees are also artificially inseminated, and in the winter, they are often killed because it is cheaper than feeding them. Humans profit from bees in the honey industry by stealing their food and substituting it with inferior replacements, such as refined sugar or high-fructose corn syrup. These substitutes harm bees' immune systems and can cause genetic mutations that lower their natural defenses against pesticides.

Therefore, honey is an animal product and is not vegan.

Bees do not overproduce honey

Bees use honey as an energy source and to provide essential nutrients. Honey is made from the nectar of flowering plants, which bees collect and store in their stomachs. When they return to the hive, they regurgitate the nectar, which is then passed from one worker bee to another to reduce its water content. Once the water content drops from 70-80% to 18%, the nectar becomes honey, which is then stored in hexagon-shaped honeycomb cells.

Bees do not produce more honey than they need, as some people believe. Instead, they store it to ensure they have enough food to survive during the winter. In the spring, the hive uses its honey stores to feed the brood, heat the hive, and feed themselves. As the food is consumed, new areas are opened up for the queen to lay eggs, and the hive expands.

While it may seem that bees produce more honey than they need, this is simply because we do not know how much honey they require. Bees do not know how much honey they will need to get through the winter, so they store more than they might use. Any excess honey is turned into swarms the following year. From the bees' perspective, this is not waste but an investment in the next generation.

Additionally, honey never spoils, so bees continue to collect and store it. Over time, this has led to bees becoming extremely efficient at producing honey. However, this does not mean they overproduce it.

Honey production exploits bees

Secondly, large-scale honey production often involves practices that prioritise profit over the welfare of bees. This includes frequent queen bee replacement, the use of antibiotics and synthetic chemicals for pest control, and selective breeding to increase productivity, which narrows the gene pool and makes bees more susceptible to diseases.

Additionally, the mass breeding of honey bees can affect the populations of other nectar-foraging insects, including native bumblebees, and the transportation of honey bees over long distances can contribute to the spread of infections among wild pollinators.

Finally, some beekeepers cull bee colonies after harvesting honey to keep costs down, and they may clip the wings of queen bees to prevent them from leaving the hive and forming a new colony, which would reduce profitability. These practices demonstrate how honey production can exploit and harm bees, and why some people believe it is not compatible with a vegan lifestyle.

Honey production harms ecosystems

Honey production can negatively impact ecosystems, and here's how:

Firstly, it is important to note that honey bees are not native to North America and were imported to what is now the United States from Europe hundreds of years ago for agricultural purposes. The mass breeding and farming of honey bees affect the populations of other native nectar-foraging insects, including native bees, as they compete for the same resources. The rise in hobby beekeeping, often done with the intention of helping bee populations, has led to a decline in native bee populations. Honey bees are extreme generalist foragers and can monopolize floral resources, leading to exploitative competition, where they use up resources, leaving little for other species. This competition for resources can reduce the number and diversity of native pollinators, which can then have a detrimental effect on native plants that rely on these pollinators.

Secondly, the commercial honey industry often employs practices that are detrimental to bee health. To maximize profits, commercial bee farmers will frequently replace the queen bee, use protein and carbohydrate supplements to feed the bees, and use antibiotics and synthetic chemicals to control pests and pathogens. These practices can harm bee health and reduce their natural defenses against pesticides. Additionally, to be sold, honey is taken away from bees and replaced with sucrose or high-fructose corn syrup, which lacks the essential micro-nutrients found in honey and can harm the bees' immune systems.

Thirdly, the importing of honey, especially into countries that are not native habitats of honey bees, can increase the carbon footprint due to the emissions associated with transport. For example, in the UK, 95% of the honey consumed is imported, mostly from China and Turkey.

Lastly, diseases in honey bees can be spread to native bee populations, further endangering these already vulnerable species.

In conclusion, while honey bees are important for agriculture, their farming and commercial exploitation can have detrimental effects on ecosystems, particularly native bee populations.

There are many vegan alternatives to honey

Honey is an animal product and, therefore, not vegan. However, there are many vegan alternatives to honey, which can be used as direct substitutes in recipes or as sweet toppings.

Agave nectar is a sweetener commercially produced from the agave plant. It is sweeter than honey and tends to be less viscous. Agave nectar comes in various styles, ranging from dark amber to light, each with its distinct flavour. Dark agave has a caramel taste, while the lighter agave is more reminiscent of delicate honey. Agave is a good alternative to honey, but it is less healthy and its popularity has led some farmers to use environmentally taxing production methods.

Maple syrup is another alternative to honey. It is made from the sap of the maple tree and contains several vitamins and minerals and up to 24 protective antioxidants. It gives recipes a different flavour than honey but works well in baking, sauces, and beauty recipes.

Brown rice syrup, also known as rice malt syrup, is available in most grocery stores and is slightly less sweet than honey. It is made by exposing brown rice to enzymes that break down the starch found in rice to produce a thick, dark-coloured syrup.

Date syrup is a caramel-coloured sweetener made by extracting the liquid portion of cooked dates. It can also be made at home by blending boiled dates with water.

There are also some branded sweeteners that can be used as honey alternatives, such as Bee-Free Honee, which is made from apples, sugar, and fresh lemon juice, and MeliBio's Mellody, which is genuine honey made without exploiting honeybees.

Other alternatives include blackstrap molasses, barley malt syrup, coconut nectar, and sorghum syrup.

Frequently asked questions