Vegan Diet Cheats: Healthy Or Unhealthy?

Whether or not it is acceptable to cheat on a vegan diet depends on the individual's reasons for adopting veganism in the first place. For those who are vegan for ethical reasons, it doesn't make sense to have non-vegan cheat days. However, if health reasons or flexibility are the motivation, there is no issue with allowing cheat days. The term cheating vegan or chegan has been used to describe those who are vegan most of the time but make exceptions in certain situations. Some people who are vegan for health reasons may still feel guilty about having non-vegan cheat days, while others may not. Ultimately, it is a personal decision that depends on one's values and beliefs.

Vegan cheat days: good or bad?

In the context of diets, "cheat days" refer to days where an individual consumes food items that are typically restricted in their diet. This could be due to the food not aligning with their dietary goals or ethical values.

Veganism is a lifestyle and philosophy that aims to exclude, as far as possible, all forms of animal exploitation and cruelty. This includes the practice of refraining from consuming products derived wholly or partially from animals.

The answer to this question depends on the individual's reasons for adopting a vegan lifestyle.

If a person identifies as vegan for ethical reasons, having "cheat days" where they consume animal products may contradict their core values and principles. Veganism, for many, is not just a diet but a commitment to reducing animal suffering and refraining from participating in practices that exploit or harm animals.

However, if a person follows a vegan diet primarily for health reasons or flexible reasons, "cheat days" may be incorporated without conflicting with their values. It is essential to note that even in these cases, the frequency of "cheat days" should be considered, as consuming animal products multiple days a week may reduce the health benefits of a plant-based diet.

The challenges of being a vegan

Adhering to a vegan diet can be challenging, especially in social situations or when dining out. Some vegans may feel that having occasional "cheat days" helps them maintain their commitment to veganism in the long run, as it allows them to indulge in foods they crave without feeling overly restricted.

The impact of "cheat days" on the vegan community

Some vegans may feel frustrated or disappointed when they learn of others who identify as vegans but regularly consume animal products. This is particularly relevant in situations where vegan options are provided, and individuals who identify as vegans choose to consume animal products instead.

Final thoughts

Ultimately, the decision to incorporate "cheat days" into a vegan lifestyle depends on the individual's personal values and reasons for adopting veganism. It is essential to respect the varying approaches and definitions of veganism within the community and recognize that different people have different ethics and values that guide their choices.

For those who are new to veganism or struggling to maintain a fully vegan diet, it may be helpful to focus on gradual changes and aim for a reduction in animal product consumption rather than strict avoidance. This can be a more sustainable approach for those who find it challenging to be 100% vegan all the time.

The ethics of veganism

Veganism is a philosophy and way of living that seeks to exclude all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing, or any other purpose. The ethical case for veganism is based on the belief that it is wrong to cause animals suffering and to take their lives.

There are several ethical arguments in favour of veganism. Firstly, causing suffering to animals by caging and slaughtering them is seen as morally unacceptable by many people. Secondly, the concept of consciousness and personhood comes into play, with many scientists and philosophers believing that animals such as great apes, elephants, and livestock exhibit sufficient levels of consciousness to be classified as "people". This leads to the belief that these animals should be afforded similar rights and protections as humans. Thirdly, there are environmental concerns, as farming animals has a negative impact on the planet, which is ethically unacceptable to many vegans.

However, there are also ethical arguments against veganism. One argument suggests that a vegan diet results in more animal deaths than an omnivorous one, as crop harvesting kills more animals than eating cows that grazed on pasture. Another argument centres around the idea of humane slaughter, suggesting that killing animals quickly and painlessly is ethically acceptable. Additionally, some argue that arable farming for plant-based diets would increase the number of animal deaths, as field mice and other creatures are killed during harvesting.

The debate around the ethics of veganism is complex and multifaceted, with valid points on both sides. Ultimately, the decision to follow a vegan lifestyle or not depends on an individual's personal beliefs and values.

Veganism: a lifestyle or a diet?

Veganism is often associated with a diet, but it is more accurately described as a lifestyle or a philosophy. It is defined by a commitment to excluding, as far as possible, all forms of animal exploitation and cruelty in one's choices regarding food, clothing, and other purposes. This commitment extends to promoting animal-free alternatives for the benefit of animals, humans, and the environment.

From a dietary perspective, veganism involves refraining from consuming products derived wholly or partly from animals. However, the vegan lifestyle goes beyond food choices and encompasses a range of ethical choices and values.

Some people who identify as vegans may occasionally consume non-vegan food, which is sometimes referred to as having "cheat days." This practice is controversial within the vegan community, as it contradicts the ethical principles that underpin veganism. Those who oppose "cheat days" argue that veganism is not a diet to "cheat" on, but rather a set of core values and beliefs that one should consistently uphold.

However, others argue that the term "vegan" encompasses a broad range of interpretations and that individuals can decide what veganism means to them. If someone follows a vegan diet primarily for health reasons, they may be more inclined to allow themselves non-vegan "cheat days" without conflicting with their ethical beliefs.

Additionally, some vegans may unintentionally consume non-vegan food due to limited options or a lack of information about the ingredients in a particular dish. These accidental slip-ups are generally viewed more leniently within the vegan community.

Ultimately, whether one chooses to have "cheat days" or not depends on their personal definition of veganism and the reasons behind their dietary choices. For some, being 100% vegan aligns with their beliefs and feels more manageable than allowing occasional non-vegan indulgences. For others, strict adherence to a vegan diet may be challenging due to social pressures, convenience, or the desire to indulge in non-vegan foods.

Vegan cheat days: a slippery slope?

It's important to distinguish between two types of "vegan cheat days": eating non-vegan food (meat, dairy, eggs, or other animal products) and consuming vegan junk food (such as sugary treats). This article focuses on the former—including animal products in one's diet while generally adhering to veganism.

The decision to have non-vegan cheat days often stems from practical considerations, such as limited vegan options when eating out or attending social events. Some individuals may also crave non-vegan foods or view cheat days as a way to tolerate dietary restrictions for extended periods.

The ethics of vegan cheat days

The controversy surrounding vegan cheat days centres on the ethical principles of veganism. Many people adopt veganism due to their moral opposition to animal killing and confinement, making it challenging to justify flexible adherence to this belief system. However, others may be primarily motivated by health reasons or flexibility, in which case cheat days are less contentious.

The challenges of maintaining a vegan diet

Maintaining a strict vegan diet can be difficult, especially when socialising or travelling. Some individuals may also find it challenging to give up certain non-vegan foods, leading to cravings and temptations.

The potential consequences of cheat days

Allowing for cheat days can lead to a slippery slope, resulting in a diet that deviates significantly from veganism. It may become challenging to maintain control over one's diet and consistently make vegan choices.

Whether or not to incorporate cheat days into a vegan diet is a personal decision that depends on one's values and beliefs. While some may view cheat days as a practical solution to dietary restrictions, others argue that it undermines the ethical foundation of veganism. Ultimately, individuals must reflect on their reasons for adopting veganism and decide what aligns best with their values.

The vegan police: judgement and in-fighting

The idea of "cheating" on a vegan diet is a controversial topic within the vegan community. While some believe that it is acceptable to have non-vegan "cheat days" or "cheat meals", others argue that this goes against the core values and principles of veganism. This disagreement has led to in-fighting among vegans, with some judging and criticising those who don't adhere to a strict vegan diet.

"Cheating" on a vegan diet refers to intentionally consuming non-vegan food, such as meat, dairy, eggs, or other animal products. It is different from accidentally consuming non-vegan food due to misinformation or a lack of vegan options.

Some people follow a vegan diet for health reasons or flexible reasons, and they may allow themselves to consume non-vegan food occasionally as a treat or when there are limited vegan options available. They may view their diet as primarily plant-based rather than strictly vegan.

Veganism is often based on ethical principles, such as opposing the killing and confinement of animals for food. For these vegans, "cheat days" go against their moral beliefs, as it still supports the meat industry and animal exploitation. They argue that if someone is truly vegan, they should not need or want to cheat, as non-vegan food becomes unappealing or even repulsive to them.

The impact of "cheating"

The debate around "cheat days" has led to judgement and in-fighting within the vegan community. Some strict vegans criticise flexible vegans for distorting the meaning of veganism and not being "real" vegans. Meanwhile, flexible vegans may feel judged and alienated by the strict expectations of the "vegan police". This in-fighting can create a divide in the community and impact the perception of veganism by non-vegans.

Navigating the grey areas

The definition of veganism can vary among individuals, and it is important to respect these differences. While some may adhere to a strict interpretation of veganism, others may have a more flexible approach. Navigating these grey areas can be challenging, and it often comes down to personal values and beliefs. Ultimately, the decision to have "cheat days" or remain strictly vegan is a personal choice that should be respected by others in the community.

Frequently asked questions