Fiber Vs Carbs: Keto's Surprising Fiber Advantage

The Ketogenic Diet is a low-carbohydrate method of eating. When following a keto diet, it is important to calculate net carbs, which are the carbohydrates your body uses for energy. Net carbs can be calculated by taking the total carbohydrates in a food and subtracting the dietary fibre and certain sugar alcohols. However, it is important to note that not all sugar alcohols are truly carb-free, and some can impact your blood sugar levels and kick you out of ketosis. Additionally, food labels can be confusing, as the way companies calculate net carbs can differ, and there is no official definition of net carbs. Furthermore, while some sources suggest that foods with more fibre than carbs can be considered zero net carbs, others disagree, stating that fibre is a type of carb and cannot cancel out carbohydrates. Therefore, it is important to carefully read nutrition labels and understand how net carbs are calculated to ensure you are staying within your desired carb intake when following a keto diet.

The difference between net carbs and total carbs

The terms "net carbs" and "total carbs" are often used in discussions about the keto diet and weight loss. Carbohydrates, or carbs, are one of the three macronutrients that the body needs to function properly. The other two are protein and fat. However, the difference between net carbs and total carbs lies in their composition and how they are calculated and used in dietary planning.

Total carbohydrates refer to all three types of carbs: starch, fibre, and sugar. This term is commonly used on food packaging and nutrition labels, overseen by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The total carbohydrate amount listed on a food label includes the grams of simple and complex carbohydrates that the food item contains.

Net carbs, on the other hand, refer to the total amount of digestible carbohydrates in a food product or meal. They are calculated by subtracting the amount of fibre and some sugar alcohols, which are not digestible, from the total carbohydrates. Net carbs represent the carbohydrates that the body can fully digest into glucose.

The calculation of net carbs can vary depending on the specific food item and individual dietary needs. For example, some people may subtract only the non-digestible carbs like dietary fibre from total carbs, while others may also factor in other non-digestible carbs like sugar alcohols. It is important to note that the term "net carbs" does not have a legal definition recognised by the FDA or the American Diabetes Association.

When following a keto diet or aiming for weight loss, understanding the difference between net and total carbs is crucial. Total carbs provide an overall picture of the different types of carbohydrates in a food item, while net carbs help individuals track their carbohydrate intake more precisely, especially if they are trying to manage their blood glucose levels or lose weight.

How to calculate net carbs

Net carbs refer to the total amount of digestible carbohydrates in a food product or meal. They are calculated by subtracting the amount of indigestible carbohydrates (fibre and some sugar alcohols) from the total amount of carbohydrates.

To calculate net carbs, you need to know the total amount of carbohydrates and the amount of fibre and sugar alcohols in a product. This information can be found on the nutrition label.

First, subtract the amount of fibre from the total amount of carbohydrates. Then, subtract half the amount of sugar alcohols from this new total, unless the sugar alcohol is erythritol, in which case you can subtract the full amount.

For example, if a food product has 20 grams of total carbohydrates, 10 grams of fibre, and 10 grams of sugar alcohols, you would calculate the net carbs as follows:

• 20 grams (total carbohydrates) - 10 grams (fibre) = 10 grams
• 10 grams - 5 grams (half the sugar alcohols) = 5 grams of net carbs

Variations in Labelling

It is important to note that the way carbohydrates are listed on nutrition labels varies between countries. For example, in the US, nutrition labels list total carbohydrates, whereas in the EU, they list net carbohydrates. Additionally, some countries, such as Canada, use the UK spelling of "fibre" instead of "fiber".

When calculating net carbs, it is also important to pay attention to serving sizes, as the nutritional information on labels is specific to a particular serving size.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Counting Net Carbs

Counting net carbs can be beneficial for people with diabetes, as it helps them track their intake of dietary fibre and balance their medication with their carbohydrate intake. It can also increase the number of food choices available, as many fruits and vegetables are rich in fibre and contribute fewer net carbs.

However, counting net carbs can also lead to an increased consumption of sugar-free treats, which may not be carb-free. Additionally, nutritional labels can vary and may cause confusion, and methods for calculating net carbs are only estimations, as everyone's digestive system is different.

Understanding Net Carbs

Net carbs refer to the carbohydrates that your body digests and absorbs. They are also known as digestible or impact carbs. Simple carbs, such as those found in table sugar and regular pasta, are easily and quickly digested by the body. Complex carbs, on the other hand, are harder for the body to break down and are commonly found in vegetables, whole grains, nuts, and fruits, which are usually high in fibre.

Fibre is a type of complex carb that the body cannot fully digest. It passes into the large intestine and is eliminated through stool, or it is fermented by the colon into short-chain fatty acids, which are important for gut health.

Sugar alcohols, which are used to add sweetness to many low-carb foods, are processed by the body similarly to fibre. However, some sugar alcohols, such as erythritol, are not digested at all and can be subtracted in full from the total carbohydrate amount when calculating net carbs.

The importance of counting carbs on the keto diet

The keto diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet. It involves eating a very low amount of carbohydrates and substituting them with fats to stimulate the body's fat-burning processes. The body enters a state of ketosis, where it uses ketones created from fat metabolism as its primary energy source instead of glucose.

Counting carbs is essential for keto dieters to ensure they stay in ketosis. The recommended amount of carbs to consume per day to stay in ketosis is up to 50 grams. This amount can vary slightly between individuals, depending on age, weight, gender, and physical activity levels.

When counting carbs, it is important to focus on "net carbs" rather than "total carbs." Net carbs are the ones that are absorbed into the body and used for energy. Total carbs include all types of carbohydrates, including fiber and sugar alcohols, which are not fully absorbed by the body.

To calculate the number of net carbs in a serving, subtract the amount of fiber from the total number of carbs. If the food is processed, also subtract half of the sugar alcohol content.

Some examples of foods that are low in net carbs and suitable for the keto diet include:

• Meats such as beef, veal, lamb, pork, chicken, and turkey
• Fish such as cod, sardines, tuna, and salmon
• Green and leafy vegetables
• Low-carb fruits such as berries and tomatoes
• Dairy products like cheese, heavy cream, and sour cream

In addition to counting carbs, it is important to note that the keto diet can be challenging to sustain long-term due to its restrictive nature. It may also have potential negative effects on cholesterol levels and increase the risk of kidney stones due to its high protein intake. Therefore, it is important to consult a doctor or dietitian before starting the keto diet to ensure it is safe and suitable for your individual needs.

The impact of sugar alcohols on blood sugar

Sugar alcohols are becoming more popular as "keto-friendly" sweeteners. They are not the same as the alcohol that causes drunkenness. The term "alcohol" in this context refers to the shape of the molecule. Sugar alcohols are less sweet than sugar but have fewer calories per gram, making them a "low-calorie" sweetener. They are often used in “sugar-free” foods like chewing gum, candy, ice cream, and fruit spreads.

Sugar alcohols are a type of carbohydrate, and they can raise blood sugar. However, they are processed by the body in a different way than other carbohydrates, and their impact on blood sugar levels is less than that of standard sugar. For example, erythritol is a type of sugar alcohol that may not increase blood sugar at all, making it a popular ingredient in low-carb "keto" foods.

Sugar alcohols are safe to consume and may be a good option for people with diabetes. However, they can cause stomach issues when eaten in large amounts, and some sugar alcohols can raise blood sugar levels. It is important to read labels carefully and be aware that "sugar-free" does not mean carbohydrate-free. Sugar alcohols are also harder for the body to digest, and consuming too much may lead to digestive issues such as gas, bloating, and stomach aches.

In terms of keto, it is important to note that fiber is a type of carbohydrate. Therefore, it is not possible for a food to have more fiber than carbohydrates. When calculating net carbs, fiber is already deducted, so the total carbs minus fiber equals net carbs. It is also important to consider calories; eating at a calorie surplus can lead to weight gain, regardless of whether one is on a keto diet or not.

The accuracy of food labelling

Food labels are an essential tool for consumers to make informed decisions about their dietary choices. However, the accuracy of food labelling, especially regarding fibre and carbohydrate content, has been a topic of discussion, as evident in the example of a keto diet.

The calculation of net carbs, which is essential for keto dieters, relies on accurate information about total carbohydrates and fibre content. However, the way these values are presented on food labels can vary across countries. For instance, in the United States, food labels typically list total carbs, while in the United Kingdom, Europe, and Australia, fibre is already subtracted from the total carbohydrate value, resulting in net carbs. This discrepancy can cause confusion for consumers, especially when purchasing products from different countries.

Furthermore, the presence of hidden sugars and misleading brand claims can further complicate the accuracy of food labelling. Some products may have cryptically named sugars or artificial sweeteners that consumers might not immediately recognize. Additionally, brands often use buzzwords and make claims like "low-carb" or "high in fibre" that may not be supported by the actual nutritional content or scientific evidence. This discrepancy between marketing and reality can lead consumers to make choices that contradict their dietary goals or negatively impact their health.

To navigate these challenges, consumers should be vigilant about reading and understanding food labels. They should focus on the nutritional information on the back of the package rather than brand claims on the front. Additionally, calculating net carbs and considering the macronutrient balance can help make informed choices. It is also essential to be aware of the different naming conventions for sugars and sweeteners and the varying practices in food labelling across countries. By being informed and proactive, consumers can make more accurate decisions about their dietary choices.

Frequently asked questions