Cheat Meals On Keto: Friend Or Foe?

Cheat meals are a controversial topic in the keto community. Some people believe that cheat meals are not necessary or encouraged on the keto diet, as they can kick you out of ketosis and slow down your progress. However, others argue that occasional cheat meals can be a helpful tool for sticking to the keto diet long-term. Ultimately, the decision to cheat or not is up to the individual, and there are ways to minimize the negative consequences of cheating.

Cheat meals on the keto diet typically refer to eating foods that are not allowed on the diet, such as high-carb foods like bread, pasta, rice, desserts, and sugary snacks. These foods can quickly kick you out of ketosis, especially if you are not yet fat-adapted. Being fat-adapted means that your body is running on ketones for fuel instead of glucose, and it usually takes around 4-6 weeks to achieve this state.

The consequences of cheating on the keto diet include increased hunger and carb cravings, bloating and intestinal discomfort, weight gain due to water retention, fatigue, and brain fog. These side effects usually subside within a day or two of returning to the keto diet. However, it may take up to a week to fully recover from a cheat meal, especially if you are in the adaptation phase.

If you decide to have a cheat meal, there are some strategies you can use to minimize the negative consequences. These include doing sports or brisk walking to burn off excess glycogen, having a small cheat meal instead of a full cheat day, and getting back on track with the keto diet as soon as possible. It is also important to be kind to yourself and not let guilt or shame derail your progress.

Cheat meals can kick you out of ketosis, but only temporarily

If you're following a ketogenic diet, you're probably aware that it involves eating very few carbs and a lot of fat. This diet puts your body into a metabolic state called ketosis, where it burns fat for energy instead of carbohydrates.

But what happens if you stray from your keto diet and eat something high in carbs? Will it kick you out of ketosis?

The short answer is yes, cheat meals can kick you out of ketosis. But the good news is that it's only temporary.

Here's what you need to do:

Understand the difference between being "in ketosis" and being fat-adapted

Ketosis is an ephemeral state that can be disrupted easily. On the other hand, fat adaptation is a much hardier state. It takes time and effort to get your body into fat-burning mode, but once you're there, a single high-carb meal won't undo all your progress.

Know the consequences of cheating

Cheating on your keto diet can have some unpleasant side effects. You may experience increased hunger and cravings, weight gain, fatigue, and brain fog. There's also a risk of triggering a seizure or migraine if you have certain neurological conditions. For people with diabetes, cheating can lead to dangerous spikes in blood sugar levels.

Have a plan for getting back on track

If you do cheat, don't beat yourself up about it. Accept that it happened and focus on getting back into ketosis. Cut down on carbs, drink plenty of water, and consider doing a short fast or a heavy workout to help your body burn off the extra glucose.

Be mindful of your reasons for cheating

There are bad and better reasons to cheat. If you're doing it out of politeness or to fit in, remember that most people aren't that interested in your food choices. Planned cheating can be empowering, but random cheating can undermine your progress. If you're doing it to take advantage of a rare opportunity, like a favourite dessert or a special trip, that's probably worth it. But an everyday treat like birthday cake in the break room is not a special occasion.

Learn from your mistakes

Cheating on your keto diet can be a learning experience. Analyze the situation that led to cheating and understand your craving triggers. This will help you avoid future setbacks and make you more mindful of your food choices.

Remember, everyone makes mistakes, and it's okay to indulge once in a while. Just get back on track as soon as possible and don't let guilt or shame keep you from reaching your goals.

Cheat meals can cause weight gain, but it's mostly water weight

When you eat a high-carb meal, your body will be kicked out of ketosis and your blood sugar will spike. This will cause an abundance of quick energy, and your body will switch back to using glucose as a source of fuel. Ketone production will stop, and your body will continue to use up the available glucose and glycogen stores until you run out.

A majority of the sugars you eat will likely be used to replenish glycogen stores, which may cause a temporary gain in water weight. This is why you may experience weight gain after a cheat meal, but it is mostly water weight.

Once you run out of glucose and glycogen, ketone production will resume, and you will be back in a state of ketosis.

If your primary goal is to lose weight, an occasional cheat meal on your keto diet is not going to destroy your progress. As long as you are maintaining calorie control overall, those extra carbs are not going to ruin all of your hard work.

However, it is important to note that cheat meals can have other negative consequences. For example, eating high-carb, high-sugar foods can lead to hunger and cravings, and cheating can strengthen these pathways, making it harder to avoid sugary treats in the future. Additionally, cheating can cause a sugar crash, and you may experience repeat symptoms of the "keto flu" when resuming your keto diet.

If you are considering a cheat meal, it is important to be mindful of the potential consequences and to make sure that you are not undoing your progress. It is also a good idea to have a plan in place to get back on track after a cheat meal, such as tracking your carb intake or trying intermittent fasting.

Cheat meals can cause cravings and hunger

One of the best perks of the keto diet is that it is very low craving or almost craving-free. Once you are fat-adapted and well deep in ketosis, you will experience reduced appetite and hunger cravings. This is because the keto diet is perfect for stabilising blood glucose.

However, when you start eating pizza, your blood sugar will spike, and you will start wanting more. Carbs will make you hungry. From there, it’s very easy to step into a downward spiral.

The interesting thing about food cravings is that scientific studies have shown that when we are craving junk food, we actually are craving fat. Wait, that is what keto is about, right? Yes. But most people mistake these cravings for a carb craving, because it’s everywhere.

The problem with cheat meals is that what starts out as a moderate carb snack will quickly end up a weekend binge-eating contest which will often start a physical as well as an emotional downward spiral.

The more you cheat, the more you will crave carbs and sugar. By veering away from your keto meal plan and removing your body from a ketogenic state, you may find yourself craving carbs and sugar more than before.

If you do find yourself craving sweets and carbs, opt for keto-friendly alternatives like at-home keto pizza or already-made keto cookies.

Cheat meals can affect your fat adaption

When you eat a high-carb meal, your body increases its metabolism, causing you to burn calories faster. This is caused by increased levels of leptin, a hormone secreted by fat cells and responsible for maintaining energy balance in the body. After eating a larger meal than usual, your body increases leptin production by as much as 30 percent for up to 24 hours.

However, the surge in leptin after a cheat meal is only temporary. After an acute spike, levels quickly drop back to normal. This transient increase in leptin doesn’t meaningfully increase metabolic rate, decrease hunger signaling, or help you hold onto muscle.

If you’re following the keto diet because of health reasons, it’s important to know that eating cheat meals can cause blood sugar levels to spike. Plus, since your glucose tolerance has depleted on keto, chances are you’ll experience a nasty sugar hit. If you eat dessert or high-carb food and don’t feel well the next day, it’s probably best to avoid it.

By veering away from your keto meal plan and removing your body from a ketogenic state, you may find yourself craving carbs and sugar more than before.

Cheat meals can cause keto flu symptoms

Ketosis is when your body burns fat for energy instead of carbohydrates, its preferred source. Usually, our bodies run on glucose in the form of foods like flour, grains, vegetables, and fruit. But dramatically reducing your carb intake forces your body to burn stored fat, instead. Your liver uses fat to make acids called ketones, which are released into your bloodstream and used for energy.

As soon as you introduce carbohydrates to your system, your body will use them for fuel. It will stay that way until you begin your keto regimen again. Even one bite of a high-carb food could do it, depending on what it is.

When you go back to a ketogenic diet after being off it for a day or a period of time, you can easily get back to the diet the next day, but it will take a couple of days to get your body back into a state of ketosis. You may experience "keto flu" symptoms again, depending on your metabolism and what kind of keto break you took. You might also have headaches, nausea, fatigue, stomach pain and body aches, brain fog, and mood swings. These should go away quickly as long as you don't bump yourself out of ketosis.

The amount of time it takes to get back into that coveted fat-burning zone will vary based on the person, but it generally takes one to three days. If you're used to restricting to a maximum and then suddenly introduce carbs, it could take longer to get back into ketosis. Likewise, if you eat a ton of carbs on a cheat day, rather than just a few extra grams, it may also take a little extra time.

Frequently asked questions