Protein Overload: Hindering Keto Weight Loss?

The keto diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that has gained popularity in recent decades as a weight loss and body composition improvement strategy. One common mistake people make on a keto diet is eating too much protein, which can affect weight loss goals.

The keto diet recommends consuming 70-80% of daily calories from fat, 10-20% from protein, and 5-10% from carbohydrates. Eating too much protein can cause the body to produce glucose from excess amino acids through a process called gluconeogenesis, which can sabotage weight loss efforts and prevent the body from entering ketosis.

However, eating enough protein is crucial for overall health and can help preserve muscle mass during weight loss. It also increases satiety and boosts metabolism, aiding in weight management.

So, can eating too much protein limit weight loss on keto? The answer is yes, as excessive protein intake can hinder ketosis and weight loss goals. However, protein intake is essential, and finding the right balance is key to a successful keto diet.

Excess protein can be converted to glucose, which may hinder ketosis

Gluconeogenesis is a metabolic process that happens in the liver and kidneys, where non-carb sources such as amino acids (protein building blocks) are converted into glucose. This happens regardless of your protein intake because certain tissues in the body rely exclusively on glucose, such as red blood cells, the renal medulla, and testes.

However, the idea that too much protein can hinder ketosis is only partially true. While it's true that gluconeogenesis can lead to increased glucose levels, this process is necessary for survival and maintaining ketosis. The body still requires small amounts of glucose to support vital functions, even when in ketosis.

Additionally, studies have shown that extra protein availability does not lead to a significant increase in gluconeogenesis. Gluconeogenesis is a stable process that is not easily influenced by increased protein intake.

It's important to note that a well-formulated low-carb diet should be high in fat and moderate in protein. A good range to aim for is 0.7-0.9 grams of protein per pound of body weight.

In summary, while excess protein can be converted to glucose through gluconeogenesis, this process is necessary for survival and maintaining ketosis. The concern that it may hinder weight loss on a keto diet is largely a myth.

The body can produce glucose from non-carb sources, including protein, via gluconeogenesis

Gluconeogenesis (GNG) is a metabolic pathway that allows the body to produce glucose from non-carbohydrate sources. The word "gluconeogenesis" is derived from the Greek root "glukos", meaning "sweet wine", and "genesis", meaning "creation". This process occurs primarily in the liver and, to a lesser extent, in the cortex of the kidneys.

During GNG, the body uses compounds like lactate, glycerol, and certain amino acids (proteins) to manufacture glucose when carbohydrates are unavailable. This process is separate from glycolysis, which is the breakdown and extraction of energy from glucose. While glycolysis quickly creates energy from glucose, GNG ensures that critical levels of glucose are maintained when carbohydrates are absent.

GNG is an important process for survival, especially during periods of fasting, starvation, or intense exercise. It helps prevent hypoglycemia by maintaining healthy blood sugar levels and fuelling tissues that cannot use ketones, such as red blood cells, the kidney medulla, testicles, and certain portions of the brain. Additionally, GNG resupplies glycogen stores, which are crucial for muscle recovery after workouts.

While some people believe that excess protein intake can increase glucose production through GNG and hinder weight loss on a keto diet, this claim has been disproven. GNG is a stable process that is not easily influenced by increased protein consumption. Studies have shown that GNG production does not increase even with extra amino acids. Furthermore, protein intake is essential on a keto diet as it helps with fat loss, provides fewer calories than fat, and prevents health issues associated with protein deficiency.

Too much protein may decrease ketone levels due to its moderate insulin-stimulating effect

The ketogenic diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet. It is often undertaken for weight loss and body composition improvement. The keto diet recommends a moderate protein level, with 10-20% of your daily calories coming from protein.

Protein is an essential macronutrient with a wide range of important bodily functions. It is a building block of life and a necessary component of any diet. However, there is a common misconception in the keto community that too much protein can kick you out of ketosis.

Ketosis is a metabolic state in which the body burns fat (ketones) for energy instead of glucose. The body can be knocked out of ketosis if insulin levels increase, as this decreases fatty oxidation and inhibits ketone production. Protein has a moderate insulin-stimulating effect, so it is true that too much protein may decrease ketone levels. Research also suggests that the amino acid alanine may suppress ketone production.

However, it is important to remember that gluconeogenesis—the process by which the body makes glucose from non-carb sources—is essential for maintaining ketosis. Certain tissues in the body rely exclusively on glucose, so the body will use gluconeogenesis to produce glucose when there are no carbs available. Gluconeogenesis is a stable process and is not easily increased by extra protein. Therefore, while too much protein may decrease ketone levels, it is not something to be feared, as it is necessary for the body to function normally during ketosis.

The amino acid alanine may suppress ketone production and could be antiketogenic

Alanine is an amino acid that can be formed from pyruvate, a product of glycolysis. Pyruvate is also a key molecule in the formation of ketone bodies. Ketone bodies are molecules produced by the liver from fatty acids during periods of low food intake, starvation, or a ketogenic diet. They are an important source of energy for the body, especially the brain.

Research has shown that alanine can suppress ketogenesis in humans by a direct hepatic effect independent of insulin and glucagon. This forms part of a negative feedback substrate cycle between alanine and ketone bodies. In other words, the presence of ketone bodies can decrease the formation of alanine, and the presence of alanine can decrease the formation of ketone bodies.

In a study, five normal subjects were given somatostatin infusions for 3 hours. After 1 hour, either alanine or isotonic saline was infused for 2 hours. With saline, blood ketone levels rose steadily. However, with alanine, ketone levels plateaued at a lower level. This indicates that alanine can suppress ketone production in the body.

Another study found that ketone bodies inhibited the formation of alanine in isolated skeletal muscle from fasted chicks. The addition of glucose increased the formation of alanine in the absence of ketone bodies but had no effect in the presence of ketone bodies. This further suggests that ketone bodies can suppress the production of alanine.

While alanine may have an antiketogenic effect, it is important to note that gluconeogenesis, the process of creating glucose from non-carb sources, is necessary for survival and makes ketosis possible in the first place. Therefore, while alanine may suppress ketone production, it is not necessarily detrimental to ketosis.

People with diabetes may be knocked out of ketosis by eating too much protein

Research shows that protein is important for overall health. It helps with growth, structure, recovery from injury, fluid balance, and energy production. However, the question of whether too much protein can kick someone out of ketosis is a common one in the keto community. This is because, during low-carbohydrate intake, the body can use protein to produce glucose through a process called gluconeogenesis.

Gluconeogenesis is a metabolic pathway that allows the liver and kidneys to make glucose from non-carbohydrate sources. It is necessary for survival and makes ketosis possible in the first place. Gluconeogenesis happens continuously, regardless of protein intake, because certain tissues in the body rely exclusively on glucose. These include red blood cells, the renal medulla (the innermost part of the kidney), and the testes.

While gluconeogenesis is not something to be feared, too much protein may decrease ketone levels. Research suggests that the amino acid alanine may be antiketogenic, meaning it suppresses ketone production. Additionally, those with insulin deficiency, such as diabetic individuals, may be knocked out of ketosis by eating too much protein. The more insulin-sensitive someone is (meaning they are not at risk for diabetes), the less likely their insulin is to increase after a protein-rich meal.

For those who are diabetic or prediabetic, it is recommended to consume slightly lower levels of protein. It is important to monitor ketone levels if concerned about being knocked out of ketosis.

Frequently asked questions