Vegan Diet: Are Milk And Eggs Deal-Breakers?

A vegan diet is a plant-based diet that excludes all animal products, including meat, dairy, and eggs. Some people who follow a vegan diet, known as veggans, choose to include eggs in their diet, specifically from ethically raised hens. However, the inclusion of eggs in a vegan diet is controversial, as the majority of vegans do not consume eggs due to health, environmental, and ethical concerns. From a health perspective, eggs are high in cholesterol and saturated fat, contributing to an increased risk of cardiovascular disease. Additionally, the egg industry has been linked to environmental damage and water pollution. Lastly, ethical vegans object to the consumption of eggs as it involves the exploitation and cruelty towards hens, such as cramped living conditions and forced molting. Therefore, the inclusion of milk and eggs in a vegan diet contradicts the fundamental principles of veganism, and regular consumption may indeed ruin the potential health benefits of a vegan diet.

The health risks of eggs and milk

A vegan diet is based on plants and foods made from plants, and it excludes anything that comes from animals, including dairy products and eggs. However, some people who identify as vegans are open to including eggs in their diet, and this is known as a "veggan" diet.

Health Risks of Eggs

Eggs are a major source of dietary cholesterol. A medium-sized egg of 58 grams contains 200 milligrams of cholesterol. To put that into perspective, that's more than double the amount in a Big Mac.

The fat and cholesterol found in eggs can harm heart health and lead to diabetes, as well as prostate and colorectal cancers. About 60% of the calories in eggs come from fat, much of which is saturated fat. Eating eggs increases the risk of dying from heart disease, according to research. A meta-analysis found that compared to eating no eggs, consuming one to three eggs per day significantly raised LDL cholesterol. This is important because the longer a person lives with elevated LDL cholesterol, the higher their risk of heart disease.

In addition to heart disease, eating eggs has been linked to a higher risk of developing certain types of cancer. One meta-analysis that combined the results of 55 studies and over 2.7 million people found that each additional egg eaten per day increased the risk of dying from cancer by 13%. Another study found that men who ate 2.5 or more eggs per week had an 81% increased risk of lethal prostate cancer when compared to men who consumed less than half an egg per week.

Health Risks of Milk

Milk is not part of a vegan diet, and vegans can get their calcium from other foods, such as green leafy vegetables like broccoli, cabbage, and okra, as well as fortified unsweetened soya, pea, and oat drinks, sesame seeds, and tahini.

In conclusion, eggs and milk can be detrimental to a vegan diet due to the health risks associated with their consumption. While some people who identify as vegans may be open to including eggs in their diet, it is important to be aware of the potential health risks associated with egg consumption, such as increased risk of heart disease, diabetes, and certain types of cancer.

The environmental impact of eggs and milk

Environmental Impact of Eggs

The egg industry has transformed from small, local farms to large-scale, intensive poultry farms driven by technological advancements, increased demand, and the pursuit of efficiency. This shift has had several ecological consequences:

• Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Egg production contributes to greenhouse gas emissions, particularly methane, nitrous oxide, and ammonia. The manure produced by poultry is a significant source of these emissions, which contribute to climate change and ozone depletion.
• Land Use: Egg production requires substantial land areas, with estimates ranging from 35 to 48 square meters of land needed to produce one kilogram of egg protein (approximately 10 dozen eggs). Free-range systems typically require more land than intensive egg production but offer hens more space and a more natural lifestyle.
• Housing Systems: Intensive egg farming often involves caging systems, such as battery cages, which overcrowd birds and restrict their movements. These practices raise animal welfare concerns and can lead to stress, physical health problems, and increased disease susceptibility.
• Feed Production: The production of chicken feed, especially soy, can contribute to deforestation, habitat destruction, and increased greenhouse gas emissions. This feed production and transportation also have carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide emissions associated with fuel consumption and fertilizer production.
• Waste and Packaging: Intense poultry farming produces significant amounts of waste, which can contaminate the environment if not properly disposed of. Additionally, the plastic packaging used for eggs contributes to plastic pollution and landfill waste.
• Antibiotic Use: The widespread use of antibiotics in intensive poultry farming can lead to antibiotic resistance in humans and the emergence of hard-to-treat diseases in both animals and humans.

Environmental Impact of Milk

Milk production, particularly from cows, also has significant environmental implications:

• Greenhouse Gas Emissions: Cows produce large amounts of methane, a potent greenhouse gas. Milk production and dairy farming contribute significantly to climate change.
• Land Use: Milk production requires substantial land areas for cattle grazing and feed crop cultivation. This can lead to deforestation and habitat destruction.
• Water Use: Dairy farming is water-intensive, and improper waste management can lead to water pollution.
• Waste and Runoff: Manure and other waste products from dairy farms can contaminate water sources if not properly managed.
• Feed Production: Similar to egg production, the feed required for dairy cows contributes to deforestation and increased greenhouse gas emissions.

Comparison and Conclusion

Both egg and milk production have environmental impacts, with milk production generally considered more detrimental due to the higher greenhouse gas emissions associated with ruminants like cattle. However, it is essential to consider the overall diet and consumption patterns when assessing the environmental impact of specific food items.

While veganism is considered the most environmentally friendly diet, vegetarianism that includes eggs and milk can also have substantial benefits for the environment compared to omnivorous diets. The key lies in reducing meat consumption and adopting more sustainable practices in the production and consumption of animal-based products.

Animal welfare concerns

Animal welfare is a key concern for many vegans, who reject the use of animals for food, clothing, or any other purpose. This ethical stance extends to the avoidance of eggs and dairy products, as the commercial production of these foods often involves practices that are harmful and cruel to animals.

Commercial egg-producing poultry farms, for instance, typically house hens in small, indoor cages, clip their beaks, and induce molting to increase egg production. These practices can cause pain, distress, and long-term harm to the birds. In addition, male chicks are routinely culled, as they do not lay eggs and are not the type of chicken bred for meat production. The short lifespans of even free-range hens, who are often slaughtered when their egg production declines, also raises ethical concerns.

The dairy industry similarly raises welfare concerns, as female cows are continuously impregnated and separated from their calves to ensure uninterrupted milk production. Male calves, considered useless for milk production, often face early slaughter or are sent to be raised for beef.

Some vegans may be open to including eggs in their diet if they are certain that the eggs come from hens raised in an ethical manner, such as free-range or backyard farms. However, critics argue that consuming any eggs undermines the vegan movement's collective work against the powerful egg industry, dilutes the vegan philosophy, and harms the ultimate goal of building a vegan world.

In addition to animal welfare, health and environmental concerns also motivate people to adopt a vegan diet. Research has shown that a plant-based diet can lower the risk of certain diseases, including heart disease, diabetes, kidney disease, and cancer. A vegan diet is also more environmentally friendly, as animal agriculture is a leading emitter of greenhouse gases and a major polluter of land and water.

The nutritional benefits of a vegan diet

A vegan diet can be very nutritious and has been linked to a range of health benefits, including a reduced risk of certain diseases. Research has shown that a plant-based diet can lower the risk of type 2 diabetes, with one study finding a 23% reduced risk for those eating primarily plant-based foods. Another study found that men who followed a vegan diet had a 35% lower risk of prostate cancer.

Vegan diets are often higher in fibre, vitamins, minerals and antioxidants, which can help protect against disease. They also tend to be lower in unhealthy saturated fats and cholesterol.

Calcium

Calcium is important for maintaining healthy bones and teeth. Vegans can get calcium from green, leafy vegetables like broccoli, cabbage and okra, as well as dried fruit such as raisins, prunes, figs and apricots. Fortified foods such as unsweetened soya, pea and oat drinks, as well as some types of bread, are also good sources of calcium for vegans.

Vitamin D

Vitamin D helps regulate the amount of calcium and phosphate in the body, keeping bones, teeth and muscles healthy. For vegans, good sources of vitamin D include exposure to sunlight, fortified foods such as breakfast cereals and unsweetened soya drinks, and supplements.

Iron

Iron is essential for the production of red blood cells. A vegan diet can be high in iron, although it is absorbed less efficiently than iron from meat. Good vegan sources of iron include wholemeal bread, fortified breakfast cereals, dark, leafy greens, dried fruit and beans.

Vitamin B12

Vitamin B12 is needed for healthy blood and a healthy nervous system. It is mostly found in animal foods, so vegans may need to include fortified foods in their diet, such as breakfast cereals, unsweetened soya drinks, yeast extract and nutritional yeast flakes.

Omega-3 Fatty Acids

Omega-3 fatty acids are important for maintaining a healthy heart and can be found in plant sources such as ground linseed (flaxseed) oil and rapeseed oil.

Supplements

In certain situations, vegans may benefit from taking supplements. For example, if you are unable to get enough vitamin B12 from fortified foods, a supplement may be helpful. Highly active people may also benefit from a plant-based protein supplement. It is best to consult your doctor before taking any supplements, as they can advise on whether you are deficient in any nutrients.

The ethics of consuming animal products

The Vegan Perspective on Milk and Eggs

At the core of veganism lies a commitment to abstaining from the use and consumption of all animal products. This stems from a deep respect for animal welfare and a belief in minimizing harm to all sentient beings. Vegans advocate for the inherent value of non-human animals and their right to be free from exploitation and cruelty. This fundamental principle extends beyond dietary choices to encompass various aspects of daily life, including clothing, cosmetics, and other products.

When it comes to milk and eggs, vegans generally reject their inclusion in their diet for several compelling reasons. Firstly, the production of these animal-derived foods often involves practices that are detrimental to the well-being of the animals involved. Dairy farms typically separate calves from their mothers and subject the cows to continuous milk production, which can be stressful and harmful to their health. Similarly, in the egg industry, hens are often kept in cramped and inhumane conditions, with their beaks clipped to prevent pecking, and they may undergo forced molting to increase egg production. These intensive farming methods cause immense suffering and are considered a violation of animal rights by vegans.

The Health Argument

In addition to ethical concerns, health considerations also play a role in the vegan rejection of milk and eggs. Both foods have been associated with adverse health effects, particularly when consumed in excess. Milk, for example, contains lactose, a sugar that many people struggle to digest due to lactose intolerance or sensitivity. Eggs, on the other hand, are high in cholesterol and saturated fat, which have been linked to an increased risk of cardiovascular disease. By excluding these animal products, vegans often believe they are making a healthier choice, reducing their risk of chronic diseases, and promoting overall well-being.

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of the dairy and egg industries is another critical factor in the vegan argument against consuming milk and eggs. Animal agriculture, including dairy and egg production, is a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, water usage, and land degradation. The intensive farming of cows and hens requires vast amounts of resources, contributing to climate change and environmental degradation. Vegans, who are often motivated by a desire to protect the planet, view the exclusion of these animal products as a way to reduce their carbon footprint and promote a more sustainable food system.

The Sentient Life Argument

From a spiritual perspective, some vegans also refrain from consuming milk and eggs due to the belief that these foods are linked to the exploitation of sentient beings. In the case of milk, the dairy industry primarily values female animals for their milk production, leading to the continuous impregnation and separation of mothers from their calves. This practice is seen as a form of female exploitation, mirroring the oppression of marginalized human groups. Similarly, the egg industry relies on the reproductive capacity of female chickens, with their eggs symbolizing the beginning of sentient life. Vegans who embrace spiritual or social justice gateways often align themselves with these sentiments, further reinforcing their decision to exclude milk and eggs from their diet.

In conclusion, the ethics of consuming animal products, specifically milk and eggs, is a multifaceted issue that encompasses animal welfare, health, environmental, and spiritual considerations. Vegans, guided by their commitment to minimizing harm and respecting animal rights, generally exclude these foods from their diet. However, it is important to recognize that there are varying degrees of veganism, and some individuals may adopt a more flexible approach, such as the inclusion of eggs from ethically raised hens. Ultimately, the decision to consume or avoid animal products is a personal choice that requires careful consideration of one's values and beliefs.

Frequently asked questions