Keto Vs Calorie Counting: Which Diet Burns More?

The ketogenic diet is a popular approach to weight loss that involves eating a very low amount of carbohydrates and a high amount of fat, with some contribution from protein. This diet is said to promote weight loss, support metabolic health, and may even reduce the risk of certain conditions such as type 2 diabetes and heart disease. One of the key questions surrounding the keto diet is whether or not it is necessary to count calories.

The general consensus is that strict calorie counting on keto is unnecessary because ketosis, which results from eating very few carbohydrates, teaches your body to burn fat at a greater rate. The keto diet is also thought to have a satiating effect that leads to decreased hunger. However, some sources argue that calories do matter on the keto diet, especially if one wishes to ensure significant weight loss. Counting calories can be a useful tool to ensure a caloric deficit, which is essential for weight loss.

So, does keto burn more calories than just counting calories? The answer may depend on individual goals and preferences. While keto may lead to quicker initial weight loss, a calorie-counting approach offers more flexibility and a balanced intake of all macronutrients. Ultimately, the best diet depends on one's lifestyle, health goals, and personal preferences.

Calorie counting vs intuitive eating

Calorie counting and intuitive eating are two contrasting approaches to dieting. Calorie counting involves meticulously tracking calories consumed and burned, aiming for a negative balance to promote weight loss. On the other hand, intuitive eating emphasises listening to your body's hunger and satiety cues, trusting that your body will naturally regulate its weight. While calorie counting can lead to quick initial weight loss, it can be time-consuming and prone to errors, and may not consider individual differences in calorie needs. Intuitive eating, on the other hand, helps build trust in the body's wisdom and ability to self-regulate, but may not work for everyone, especially those with entrenched routines or a history of disordered eating. Combining elements of both approaches can be beneficial, allowing for flexibility and a balanced approach to sustainable weight loss.

Calorie Counting

Calorie counting, often done in conjunction with a calorie-deficit diet, involves consuming fewer calories than your body burns, creating a negative energy balance that promotes weight loss. This approach requires tracking calories in the foods and beverages consumed, as well as estimating calories burned through physical activity. While it can be effective for weight loss, calorie counting has several drawbacks.

Firstly, it is time-consuming and prone to errors. Determining the exact calorie content of foods can be challenging due to variations in portion sizes, cooking methods, and individual differences in metabolism. Additionally, counting calories can become an obsession for some, leading to a restrictive and rigid mindset that may negatively impact social activities and overall quality of life. It is also important to note that not all calories are equal; the thermic effect of food (TEF) refers to the energy required to break down different macronutrients, with protein requiring more energy to digest than carbohydrates or fats.

Intuitive Eating

Intuitive eating, popularised by dietitians Evelyn Tribole and Elyse Resch, focuses on trusting the body's wisdom and ability to regulate itself without external rules or restrictions. It involves listening to and honouring your body's hunger and satiety cues, eating when you're hungry, and stopping when you're full. This approach aims to cultivate a positive and respectful relationship with food, rejecting deprivation and restriction. It also encourages individuals to find comfort and nurture outside of food, addressing stress eating and promoting a healthier relationship with food and exercise.

However, intuitive eating may not work for everyone. It does not account for the variability of satiety, as different foods can create a "satisfied" feeling in different ways. It also assumes that individuals can easily recognise and respond to their body's signals, which may not be the case for those with entrenched routines or disordered eating habits.

Combining Approaches

Combining elements of calorie counting and intuitive eating can be a beneficial strategy. Calorie counting can provide structure and portion control, while intuitive eating helps individuals tune into their body's signals and make food choices based on their unique needs. By using calorie counting as a tool rather than a rigid rule, individuals can develop a more flexible and sustainable approach to healthy eating and weight management.

In conclusion, both calorie counting and intuitive eating have their strengths and weaknesses. Calorie counting can lead to quick initial weight loss but may be restrictive and prone to errors. Intuitive eating promotes a positive relationship with food but may not work for everyone. Combining the two approaches in a way that suits individual needs and goals can be a successful strategy for sustainable weight loss and improved overall health.

The role of protein and fat in satiety

Protein and fat are key components of the keto diet. While the keto diet is primarily a fat-focused diet, with 70-80% of calories coming from fat, protein also plays a significant role in satiety, making up 20-30% of calories.

Protein is widely recognised as the most effective macronutrient for providing satiety. It increases the feeling of fullness and reduces appetite, which can lead to a reduction in energy consumption and promote weight loss. This is due to the thermic effect of protein, which uses more energy to be broken down by the body compared to carbohydrates.

On the keto diet, it is important not to consume too much protein, as this can interfere with the body's ability to stay in ketosis. However, the right amount of protein can enhance satiety and make it easier to stick to the diet.

Fat also plays a role in satiety on the keto diet. The high-fat content of the keto diet is what makes it effective for weight loss, as it keeps people feeling full and satisfied. This is one of the reasons why calorie counting is not typically necessary on the keto diet.

In summary, the combination of moderate protein and high-fat intake on the keto diet can lead to increased satiety, reduced hunger, and easier weight loss. This is one of the key advantages of the keto diet compared to other weight-loss methods.

The thermic effect of food

TEF is influenced by the type of macronutrients consumed. Protein has the highest thermic effect, followed by carbohydrates and then fats. This means that the body burns more calories digesting protein than it does for carbohydrates or fats. For example, about 25% of the calories in protein are used up in the process of digesting protein, while the TEF of carbohydrates is around 8%. This means that if you eat 100 calories of protein, you theoretically only yield a net of 75 calories, whereas you’d get 92 calories out of the carbohydrates.

Consuming foods with a high thermic effect can help increase your metabolic rate and burn more calories. These include protein-rich foods such as lean meats, fish, eggs, and dairy products, as well as fibrous vegetables like broccoli, spinach, and kale, and whole grains like brown rice, quinoa, and oats.

It is important to note that the thermic effect of food is just one aspect of a healthy diet and should not be the sole focus of your food choices. Eating a well-balanced diet, engaging in regular physical activity, and getting enough rest are crucial for achieving and maintaining a healthy weight and overall health.

The metabolic advantage of ketogenic diets

The ketogenic diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that offers many health benefits. It involves drastically reducing carbohydrate intake and replacing it with fat. This reduction in carbs puts your body into a metabolic state called ketosis, where fat becomes the primary fuel source.

Ketosis

Ketosis is a metabolic state in which your body uses fat for fuel instead of carbs. When this happens, your body becomes incredibly efficient at burning fat for energy. It also turns fat into ketones in the liver, which can supply energy for the brain.

Weight Loss

A ketogenic diet is an effective way to lose weight and lower risk factors for disease. Research shows that the ketogenic diet may be as effective for weight loss as a low-fat diet. The diet is so filling that you can lose weight without counting calories or tracking your food intake.

Diabetes

The ketogenic diet can help you lose excess fat, which is closely linked to type 2 diabetes, prediabetes, and metabolic syndrome. One older study found that the ketogenic diet improved insulin sensitivity by a whopping 75%. A small study in women with type 2 diabetes also found that following a ketogenic diet for 90 days significantly reduced levels of hemoglobin A1C, which is a measure of long-term blood sugar management.

Heart Disease

The ketogenic diet can help improve risk factors like body fat, HDL (good) cholesterol levels, blood pressure, and blood sugar. Research suggests that a ketogenic diet can reduce the risk of heart disease. A systematic review published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition in 2019 found that a ketogenic diet can lower markers of inflammation, which is associated with a decreased risk of heart disease.

Cancer

The diet is currently being explored as an additional treatment for cancer, because it may help slow tumor growth.

Alzheimer’s Disease

The keto diet may help reduce symptoms of Alzheimer’s disease and slow its progression.

Epilepsy

Research has shown that the ketogenic diet can cause significant reductions in seizures in epileptic children.

Parkinson’s Disease

Although more research is needed, one study found that the diet helped improve symptoms of Parkinson’s disease.

Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome

The ketogenic diet can help reduce insulin levels, which may play a key role in polycystic ovarian syndrome.

Brain Injuries

Some research suggests that the diet could improve outcomes of traumatic brain injuries.

Other Benefits

The ketogenic diet may provide many health benefits, especially with metabolic, neurological, or insulin-related diseases.

Risks and Side Effects

While the keto diet has its benefits, staying on it in the long term may have some negative effects, including risks of low protein in the blood, extra fat in the liver, and micronutrient deficiencies.

There may also be some initial side effects while your body adapts, such as diarrhea, constipation, and vomiting. These symptoms usually resolve in a few days to weeks.

Tips for Following a Ketogenic Diet

• It’s important to moderate your protein consumption. This is because protein can be converted into glucose if consumed in high amounts, which may slow your transition into ketosis.
• Practicing intermittent fasting could also help you enter ketosis faster.
• Reading food labels, planning your meals ahead, and bringing your own foods when visiting family and friends can make it much easier to stick to the ketogenic diet.
• When eating out, select a meat-, fish-, or egg-based dish. Order extra veggies instead of carbs or starches, and have cheese for dessert.

The impact of insulin on fat storage

Insulin is a hormone that regulates blood sugar levels, promotes fat storage, and helps break down fats and protein. It is produced and released into the blood by the pancreas. When we eat food, it gets broken down into basic nutrients, which make their way into the bloodstream. Insulin then helps shuttle these nutrients into cells by "telling" the cells to open up and absorb them.

Insulin plays a vital role in fat storage. It inhibits the breakdown of fat cells and stimulates the creation of body fat. This means that insulin tells the body to stop burning its fat stores and instead absorb fatty acids and glucose and turn them into more body fat. This is why insulin is often blamed for weight gain. The logic goes: the more insulin in the body, the less fat burned and the more stored, leading to weight gain.

However, this is an oversimplification and not entirely accurate. While it is true that insulin triggers fat cells to absorb fatty acids and glucose, leading to their expansion, this is not what causes weight gain over time. Overeating and a positive energy balance are the primary drivers of weight gain. In other words, weight gain occurs when we give our body more energy than it burns, and this excess energy is stored as body fat.

Insulin therapy can lead to weight gain in people with diabetes. This is because their bodies start absorbing glucose again and converting any excess into fat. Additionally, people with diabetes may eat more due to concerns about developing hypoglycemia, or low blood sugar, which can also contribute to weight gain.

It is important to note that weight gain is not always equivalent to fat gain. In the context of diabetes, weight gain can be due to increased glucose storage, as glucose is stored with water.

While insulin does play a role in fat storage, ultimately, weight gain or loss depends on energy balance. This refers to the amount of energy we burn compared to the amount we consume through food. A positive energy balance, where we consume more energy than we burn, will lead to weight gain, while a negative energy balance will result in weight loss.

In summary, while insulin does impact fat storage, it is not the sole determinant of weight gain or loss. Energy balance, which takes into account overall calorie consumption and expenditure, is a more critical factor in weight management.

Frequently asked questions