Vegan Diets: Sensible Or Nonsensical?

The concept of the vegan diet is based on the avoidance of all animal products and animal-derived foods. Vegans do not consume meat, fish, eggs, dairy, or honey, and also avoid wearing or using products made from animals, such as leather or wool. The vegan diet is often chosen for ethical, health, or environmental reasons. Ethical vegans believe that all creatures have a right to life and freedom, and oppose the killing of animals for food or the use of animal products. Health-conscious vegans opt for a plant-based diet because it is associated with lower cholesterol, improved blood glucose, and better blood pressure. Environmental vegans avoid animal products to reduce their ecological footprint, as animal agriculture contributes significantly to greenhouse gas emissions.

The health benefits of a vegan diet

A vegan diet is a plant-based diet that typically includes fruits, vegetables, beans, grains, nuts, and seeds. Vegans do not consume animal products, including meat, poultry, fish, eggs, and dairy.

Research suggests that a vegan diet can offer several health benefits, and some choose this diet specifically for these advantages. Here are some of the key health benefits associated with a vegan lifestyle:

Lower Risk of Certain Diseases

Vegan diets have been linked to a reduced risk of developing or dying prematurely from specific diseases. Research has shown that a plant-based diet can lower the risk of type 2 diabetes by 23%. Additionally, men following a vegan diet had a 35% lower risk of prostate cancer compared to those consuming animal products. Vegan diets have also been associated with a lower risk of cardiovascular disease.

Weight Management

Vegan diets tend to be rich in fiber, vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants, which offer protection against diseases. These diets are also typically lower in unhealthy saturated fats and cholesterol. As a result, a vegan diet may help maintain a healthy weight and lower the risk of obesity.

Improved Digestion

Plant-based diets are often higher in fiber, which can improve digestion and promote a healthy gut.

Reduced Side Effects from Antibiotics and Hormones

The antibiotics and hormones used in modern animal agriculture can have side effects. A vegan diet can help minimize these side effects, as it excludes animal products.

Lower Environmental Impact

In addition to health benefits, a vegan diet also has a reduced environmental impact. Animal agriculture is a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, and vegan diets produce about 53% fewer emissions than diets containing animal products.

Nutritional Considerations

While a vegan diet offers numerous health benefits, it is important to ensure adequate nutrient intake. Some nutrients to focus on include:

• Vitamin B12: Found mostly in animal products, vegans should opt for fortified foods or consider taking supplements.
• Calcium: While non-vegans get calcium from dairy, vegans can obtain it from leafy greens, fortified plant-based milk, sesame seeds, and bread.
• Iron: Iron is found in plant-based sources but is not as easily absorbed as iron from meat. Include iron-rich plant foods like wholemeal bread, spinach, and lentils in your diet.
• Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Plant sources like flaxseed, chia seeds, and walnuts provide omega-3s, but vegans may need to consider supplements for EPA and DHA, mainly found in animal sources.

The environmental impact of veganism

Veganism is widely regarded as being better for the planet than diets that include animal products. Research shows that meat and dairy products are fuelling the climate crisis, while plant-based diets focused on fruits, vegetables, grains, and beans help protect the planet.

According to the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, shifting diets from animal products to plant-based alternatives has the potential to significantly reduce carbon footprints and mitigate climate change. The report also states that other benefits include lowering the risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and reducing mortality from diet-related non-communicable diseases.

A report by the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) supports this, stating that animal products generally require more resources and cause higher emissions than plant-based alternatives. The World Health Organization (WHO) adds that reducing livestock herds would also reduce emissions of methane, the second-largest contributor to global warming after carbon dioxide.

Cattle produce methane as part of their normal digestive process, which is released into the atmosphere when they burp. Methane is also produced when animal manure is stored or managed in lagoons or holding tanks, according to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

New Zealand has recently proposed a tax on cow emissions, aiming to reduce the amount of methane released by livestock by up to 47% by 2050. Similarly, the Danish Climate Council has recommended imposing a 33% tax on beef and replacing two-thirds of meat intake with vegetables and plants.

A global shift to a plant-based diet could reduce mortality and greenhouse gases caused by food production by 10% and 70% respectively by 2050, according to the UNEP. Additionally, a study found that 57% of global greenhouse gas emissions from food production come from meat and dairy products, with beef contributing the most.

However, it's important to note that not all plant-based foods have a small environmental footprint. For example, delicate fruits like blueberries and strawberries are often imported by air to fill gaps when local fruits are out of season, resulting in higher greenhouse gas emissions. Similarly, avocadoes, mangoes, and plums require large amounts of water, putting pressure on water-stressed regions.

Therefore, while veganism generally has a positive environmental impact, it's crucial to consider the specific types of plant-based foods consumed and their sources to ensure the most sustainable choices are made.

The ethics of veganism

Veganism is a philosophy and way of living that seeks to exclude, as far as possible, all forms of animal exploitation and cruelty. It is a lifestyle that extends beyond dietary choices, encompassing clothing, cosmetics, and leisure activities. Vegans typically aim to exclude animal exploitation or cruelty in all aspects of their lives.

Opposition to Speciesism

Ethical vegans oppose speciesism, which is the assignment of value to individuals based solely on their species membership. They argue that all creatures, regardless of their species, have an inherent right to life, freedom, and the avoidance of suffering. This belief extends to the rejection of using animals for entertainment, such as in zoos or circuses.

Reducing Animal Suffering

Vegans believe that modern farming practices inflict psychological and physical stress on animals, such as cramped living conditions and inhumane slaughter methods. They advocate for minimizing animal suffering by rejecting animal-based products and commodities. This includes not only food but also clothing and cosmetics that may be derived from animal exploitation.

Environmental Impact

Environmental vegans focus on the conservation and sustainability aspects of veganism. They argue that animal agriculture, particularly factory farming, has a detrimental impact on the environment. By reducing or eliminating animal products, vegans can significantly reduce their ecological footprint, including lower greenhouse gas emissions and reduced pressure on natural resources.

Health Benefits

Some people adopt veganism for its potential health benefits. Research suggests that vegan diets can lower the risk of certain diseases, improve blood glucose and blood pressure, and promote weight loss. However, it is important to note that a poorly planned vegan diet can lead to nutritional deficiencies, so proper planning and supplementation may be necessary.

Labor Rights

Intersectionality with Other Social Justice Issues

Veganism intersects with other social justice issues, such as racism and food access. For example, Black veganism in the United States connects the use of nonhuman animals with racial justice and the lasting effects of slavery on dietary patterns. Veganism, in this context, becomes a form of social and political philosophy that seeks to reclaim food sovereignty and promote dietary changes.

In conclusion, the ethics of veganism are multifaceted and encompass a range of values and beliefs. Vegans may be motivated by a combination of these ethical considerations, striving to minimize animal suffering, reduce their environmental impact, improve their health, and support labor rights and social justice.

The history of veganism

Ancient Societies and Religious Influences

Vegetarianism and veganism have been practised in various forms for thousands of years. In ancient Indian and eastern Mediterranean societies, influential figures such as Pythagoras, Siddhārtha Gautama (the Buddha), and followers of Hinduism, Jainism, and Buddhism advocated for vegetarianism or veganism. They promoted benevolence among all species and believed that humans should not inflict pain on animals.

In ancient Greece, strict vegetarianism was called "abstinence from beings with a soul." The Greek philosopher Pythagoras, who lived around 500 BCE, is known for his theorem about right triangles, but he also promoted the idea of benevolence among all species and followed a vegetarian diet. The Roman poet Ovid depicted Pythagoras as speaking out against the consumption of flesh, saying, "Alas, what wickedness to swallow flesh into our own flesh, to fatten our greedy bodies by cramming in other bodies, to have one living creature fed by the death of another!"

In addition, the concept of ahimsa, or non-violence, is central to Jainism, Hinduism, and Buddhism. Parshvanatha, a Jain who lived around 800 BCE, taught ahimsa and was known for rescuing a serpent from a burning log. The Japanese Emperor Tenmu also banned the consumption of meat from cows, horses, dogs, chickens, and monkeys, leading to a 12-century-long ban on eating meat in Japan.

Early Vegans and the Vegan Society

While the term "vegan" is relatively modern, there were individuals throughout history who embraced plant-based diets and lifestyles that align with modern veganism. Dr. William Lambe, a physician in the 1800s, adopted an exclusively plant-based diet due to health issues. He rejected the consumption of dairy products, making him one of the first "vegans" in the modern sense of the word.

In the 19th and early 20th centuries, several notable individuals promoted vegan or near-vegan lifestyles. Asenath Nicholson operated a vegan boarding house in New York City, and Louisa May Alcott, the author of "Little Women," was raised as a vegetarian and was an abolitionist and feminist. Caroline Earl White founded the first animal shelter in the USA and is known as the "mother of animal rights advocacy."

The modern vegan movement gained momentum with the founding of the Vegan Society in November 1944. Donald Watson, a British woodworker, called a meeting with five other non-dairy vegetarians, including Elsie Shrigley, to discuss their diets and lifestyles. They felt that a new term was needed to describe their approach, something more concise than "non-dairy vegetarians." They considered various labels before settling on "vegan," formed from the first three and last two letters of "vegetarian."

The Vegan Society provided a platform for individuals who wanted to distance themselves from the consumption of animal products and promoted the development of animal-free alternatives. Over time, the definition of veganism evolved to encompass not just diet but also the rejection of animal exploitation for clothing, toiletries, and other purposes.

Veganism in the 21st Century

In recent years, veganism has become increasingly mainstream, with more people adopting vegan lifestyles for ethical, environmental, and health reasons. The movement has been driven by concerns about animal welfare, the environmental impact of animal agriculture, and the perceived health benefits of plant-based diets.

The rise of veganism has led to the development of vegan alternatives, such as plant-based meat and dairy products, and the creation of vegan-friendly products in various industries. The future of veganism looks promising, with growing awareness and a diverse global community embracing this lifestyle.

The challenges of a vegan diet

A vegan diet can be challenging to follow, and there are a few key considerations to keep in mind. Firstly, vitamin B12 is essential for metabolism, heart, nerve, and muscle health, and it is mostly found in animal products. Vegans should opt for B12-fortified foods or supplements and monitor their levels with a healthcare provider, as deficiency can take years to manifest.

Secondly, calcium is crucial for bone and dental health, and while non-vegans get most of their calcium from dairy, vegans must rely on other sources such as leafy greens, fortified plant milk, tofu, and bread. A systematic review found that vegans had lower bone mineral density and higher fracture rates, so supplements may be necessary.

Iron is another vital nutrient, and while a vegan diet can be high in iron, plant-based iron is not as easily absorbed as iron from meat. Fortified whole grains, beans, spinach, and lentils are good plant-based sources of iron.

Finally, omega-3 fatty acids are important for heart health, and while plant sources like flaxseed, chia seeds, and walnuts contain alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), the other types, epicapentanoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), are mainly found in animal products. Vegan options for EPA and DHA include microalgae, seaweed, and supplements.

Overall, a well-planned vegan diet can provide all the necessary nutrients, but careful consideration and, in some cases, supplementation are required to avoid potential deficiencies.

Frequently asked questions