Vegan Pet Diets: A Dangerous Trend To Avoid

The rise of veganism has sparked a debate about whether pet owners should feed their cats and dogs a vegan diet. While some people believe that a vegan diet is ethical and environmentally friendly, others argue that it may not meet the nutritional needs of these carnivorous animals, potentially compromising their health. Cats, in particular, are obligate carnivores, requiring certain amino acids and nutrients found primarily in animal tissues. Dogs, on the other hand, are omnivores and may have an easier time adapting to a well-planned vegan diet.

Cats are obligate carnivores and require certain amino acids to be healthy

Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they require a meat-based diet to survive. Their digestive systems are specifically designed to process animal tissue, and they lack the ability to produce certain amino acids that are essential to their health.

Cats have unique behavioural, anatomical, and nutritional characteristics that demonstrate their carnivorous nature. In the wild, domestic cats hunt and eat small prey frequently throughout the day, similar to their close relatives, the African wild cat. Their teeth are pointy to help them tear meat off the carcass, and they lack occlusal (chewing) surfaces, so they usually swallow pieces of meat whole.

Cats are unable to produce certain amino acids, such as taurine, which is important for the heart muscle and the retina of the eye. A deficiency in taurine can lead to dilated cardiomyopathy, a potentially fatal condition. They also require vitamin A, which they cannot biosynthesize from carotene, and arachidonic acid, another essential nutrient.

Cats' dietary requirements include a relatively large amount of protein, which they use for energy. They also have a constant rate of gluconeogenesis, which is the process of making glucose from non-carbohydrate sources, to maintain a relatively constant blood sugar level.

While some people may be interested in feeding their cats a vegan diet for ethical reasons, it is important to prioritize the specific nutritional needs of cats as obligate carnivores.

Dogs are omnivores but require amino acids L-carnitine and taurine

Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is a serious illness in which the heart becomes large and flabby and can no longer function. This illness generally strikes young or middle-aged dogs who are susceptible to L-carnitine or taurine deficiency because of breed, size, individual genetic makeup, or diet.

Nowadays, most commercial dog foods, both vegetarian and meat-based, contain them, and if you want to feed a homemade diet, you can purchase them in powder form online or at a health food store.

However, it is recommended that dogs on a vegan diet be supervised by a veterinary-trained nutritionist.

Cats have stricter nutritional requirements than dogs

Cats have a shortened digestive tract and altered liver enzyme capacity, which means they cannot produce certain proteins themselves, such as taurine, and must absorb it from their food. A deficiency in taurine can lead to a potentially fatal heart condition called dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM).

Cats also require arginine, a building block for protein, which is critical for their internal chemical factory functioning. They are sensitive to even one meal without arginine and require a lot of protein to aid in the elimination of protein waste products.

In addition, cats need to obtain pre-formed vitamin A from their diet, as they cannot convert plant carotenoids into active vitamin A like dogs can.

Because of these stricter nutritional requirements, it is generally advised that cats not be fed a vegan diet. While it is possible to develop a plant-based diet for cats with careful formulation and appropriate supplementation, there is limited evidence regarding the health impacts of such diets, and caution is advised.

Dogs, on the other hand, are considered omnivores and can derive nutrients from plant-based sources as well as animal-based sources. However, it is important to note that dogs also have specific nutritional requirements and may require supplementation on a vegan diet.

A vegan diet may be inconsistent with a cat's natural instincts

Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they are meat eaters by necessity. They cannot obtain all the nutrients they need from plants and bacteria. For example, cats cannot obtain vitamin A from plants because they lack the enzyme needed to split carotene, which is usually obtained from plants, into vitamin A. Cats obtain vitamin A from the liver of their prey, or meat their owners feed them. Cats also cannot synthesize essential very-long-chain, highly unsaturated fatty acids that other animals can make from shorter fatty acids found in plants.

Cats are hunters. Even domestic cats retain the instinct to kill and, left to their own devices, they will generally spend their time stalking prey. However, many owners attempt to wean them off hunting and change these behaviours for cuter, more “pet-like” behaviours such as purring and cuddles.

Cats' natural diet in the wild is high in protein and fat, which they derive from small prey such as rodents, birds, small reptiles and amphibians. Cats may eat grass or plants now and again, but biologists agree that this is done to obtain roughage that acts as a digestive aid, and there is little if any nutritional value obtained.

Cats' standard diet fed to them by their owners is far from natural. A large percentage of owners feed their cats kibble, a dry blend of animal products mixed with vegetable-based starches. Cats don't have the capacity to create kibble by themselves. Nature doesn't offer this option.

Cats' natural instincts are to hunt and kill prey, and their natural diet is meat-based. A vegan diet is inconsistent with these natural instincts and dietary requirements.

A vegan diet may be inconsistent with a dog's natural instincts

Dogs are omnivores, meaning they can eat both meat and plant products. However, their digestive systems have evolved to metabolise meat more efficiently. In the wild, dogs would naturally eat animal-based protein, and their digestive tracts are designed to tear muscle, crunch bones, and digest meat more readily than plants.

While it is theoretically possible for dogs to get all the essential nutrients from a vegan diet, it is much easier to get the balance of nutrients wrong than to get it right. Dogs require specific nutrients, such as amino acids like taurine and L-carnitine, and vitamins like B12, which are predominantly found in animal products.

Supplements can be added to a vegan diet to provide these essential nutrients, but there is limited scientific evidence to support the long-term safety of synthetic supplements for dogs. The bioavailability of these synthetic nutrients is also questionable, meaning that even with supplements, dogs may not be able to properly absorb and utilise these essential nutrients.

Overall, while a vegan diet may be inconsistent with a dog's natural instincts to eat meat, it is possible for dogs to survive on a vegan diet if it is carefully formulated and balanced, with the guidance of a veterinarian or animal nutritionist.

Frequently asked questions