Veganism And Christianity: A Sinful Diet?

The question of whether a vegan diet is unchristian has divided Christians, with some arguing that it is inconsistent with their faith and others adopting veganism for religious reasons. Some Christians believe that God's original plan for humans was a vegan diet, citing the creation narrative in the Book of Genesis, where God prescribes a plant-based diet for all creatures. They also point to the vision of the Peaceable Kingdom in the Book of Isaiah, which describes a world without violence towards animals. On the other hand, some Christians argue that eating meat is part of God's design, citing instances in the Bible where God provides meat for humans, such as when God provides quail for the Israelites in the wilderness and when Jesus eats fish after his resurrection.

While the Bible contains passages that can be interpreted as supporting both veganism and meat-eating, the New Testament emphasizes Christian liberty and individual conscience in dietary choices. Paul's writings in Romans 14 encourage Christians not to judge or despise one another based on their dietary choices, as these are secondary to the main issue of saving faith in Jesus Christ.

The Bible's Old Testament and New Testament teachings on diet

The Bible contains teachings that can be interpreted as supporting veganism, as well as teachings that can be interpreted as supporting the consumption of meat.

The Old Testament

The Old Testament contains passages that can be interpreted as supporting a vegan diet. In the Book of Genesis, God prescribes a plant-based diet for all land-based non-human animals, and declares this creation "very good". This has been interpreted as suggesting that God intended for all his creatures to eat plants. This interpretation is supported by the vision of the Peaceable Kingdom in the Book of Isaiah, which describes a world where animals live together without harming each other, and "the lion shall eat straw like the ox".

However, the Old Testament also contains passages that suggest the consumption of meat is morally permissible. After the flood, God tells Noah and his family that animals will now be their food. Later, God gives the Israelites rules about what types of meat may be eaten, implying that certain meats are acceptable. During the Exodus, God commands the Israelites to slaughter a lamb and eat it, and institutes the Passover as a lasting tradition.

The New Testament

The New Testament also contains passages that can be interpreted as supporting both veganism and meat-eating. Jesus is recorded as eating fish and offering fish to others, but he is not recorded as eating mammals or poultry. In the book of Acts, the Apostle Peter has a vision in which he is shown a sheet containing all kinds of clean and unclean animals, and is told, "What God has made clean, do not call common". This has been interpreted as a message about who the Gospel is for, rather than a message about eating animals.

In the New Testament, Jesus declares all foods clean, which has been interpreted as demonstrating that dietary choices are a matter of "Christian liberty". However, Paul writes in Romans that people should not judge others for their dietary choices, and that people should make decisions about what to eat that are consistent with what they believe God wants them to do.

The environmental impact of meat consumption

The industrial meat system requires a huge amount of land to sustain itself and is the single biggest cause of deforestation globally. In Brazil, farmers are setting forest fires to clear space for cattle ranching and to grow animal feed. These fires release billions of tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, accelerating global warming. Furthermore, the fallen trees are left to rot or are burned, creating further emissions. Trees are essential for absorbing carbon, and their destruction reduces their ability to combat climate change.

The Amazon rainforest is also being pushed closer to a tipping point by meat production. The trees in the Amazon produce their own rainfall, keeping the forest alive. Deforestation for meat production could lead the Amazon to reach a 'tipping point', where it can no longer sustain itself. This would have devastating consequences for the people and animals that depend on it and could lead to reduced rainfall and changes to climate patterns in other parts of the world.

In addition to its climate impact, industrial meat production is linked to human rights abuses and land-grabbing. Indigenous Peoples and traditional communities are at the forefront of the fight to protect forests, but they face harassment, detention, and violence from security forces and illegal loggers, miners, and farmers.

The industrial meat industry also contributes to the extinction of thousands of species by clearing forests, destroying habitats, and using toxic pesticides. This rapid loss of biodiversity, largely driven by industrial farming, could pose as significant a threat to our existence as climate change.

Finally, industrial meat production increases the risk of future pandemics like COVID-19. Destroying forests and wild areas for animal agriculture is a significant cause of new infectious diseases, as it brings wildlife into closer contact with humans. Factory farms can also increase the spread of disease, as large numbers of animals are kept in close quarters, and their weakened immune systems allow viruses to develop more rapidly.

Some Christians may consider a vegan diet to be at odds with their faith. However, there are strong faith-based reasons for Christians to reduce or eliminate animal products from their diet. Firstly, Christians believe that everything in the universe owes its existence to God and that God made a world in which every creature has its own place. This means that Christians have a responsibility to care for God's creation and enable fellow creatures to flourish.

The current expansion of livestock farming is causing significant environmental damage and contributing to climate change, which will have devastating consequences for humans and animals. Industrial animal agriculture also inflicts unnecessary suffering on animals, with most farmed animals raised in systems that prevent them from thriving.

Furthermore, the livestock industry threatens human food and water security, with over a third of global cereal output going to farmed animals. Animal agriculture is also a significant consumer of global water supplies, and the current human population would benefit from transitioning to plant-based foods wherever possible.

In addition, intensive farming practices contribute to the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains and the risk of pandemics from zoonotic diseases. A vegan diet can help to address these concerns and improve human health.

Finally, a vegan diet aligns with long Christian traditions of fasting from meat and other animal products during Lent and on Fridays. These traditions remind Christians of the limits that come with recognizing God as the creator and that animals belong to God and must be treated with respect.

Animal welfare and the ethics of meat production

The ethics of meat production and animal welfare are complex issues that have sparked debate among Christians. While some argue that a vegan diet aligns with Christian values, others believe that meat consumption is a matter of personal choice. This discussion explores the biblical teachings and principles relevant to this topic.

Biblical Teachings on Animal Welfare

The Bible contains several passages that emphasise God's care and love for all His creations, including animals. In Genesis 1:29-30, God provides plants as food for both humans and animals, suggesting a plant-based diet was part of God's original plan. This idea is further supported by Isaiah 11:6-9, which envisions a world without violence where "the wolf shall live with the lamb". These passages indicate that God values animal welfare and intends for all creatures to live peacefully.

Christian Perspectives on Meat Consumption

Christians hold diverse opinions on meat consumption. Some interpret the Bible's teachings as supporting vegetarianism or veganism, believing it aligns with God's original plan and promotes animal welfare. They argue that industrial animal agriculture causes unnecessary suffering and damages the environment. Additionally, they highlight the health benefits of plant-based diets.

On the other hand, some Christians view meat consumption as a matter of personal choice and liberty. They point to biblical passages where God permits humans to eat animals after the Flood (Genesis 9:3) and where Jesus ate fish (Luke 24). They emphasise that Jesus and the apostles did not advocate for a specific dietary pattern, and that meat consumption is not inherently sinful.

Christian Responses to Veganism

While veganism may not be a widespread practice among Christians, some Christian leaders and organisations support reducing meat consumption or adopting plant-based diets. They recognise the environmental, ethical, and health impacts of industrial animal agriculture and encourage Christians to care for God's creation and treat animals with respect. However, they emphasise that individual conscience and liberty should be respected, and that causing division over dietary choices is not in line with Christian values.

In conclusion, the discussion surrounding animal welfare and the ethics of meat production within Christianity is nuanced. While some Christians are drawn to veganism or vegetarianism for ethical and religious reasons, others view meat consumption as a matter of personal choice. Ultimately, Christians are called to make decisions that align with their understanding of God's will and to respect the opinions of those who may disagree.

The health benefits of veganism

Veganism is associated with a range of health benefits, which are outlined below.

Lower Risk of Heart Disease, Cancer, Type 2 Diabetes, and Strokes

Unprocessed plant-based foods are typically high in important nutrients, including vitamins, fibre, and phytonutrients. They are also usually lower in calories and fat. The fats found in a vegan diet are often monounsaturated fats, which can lower LDL ("bad" cholesterol) and may raise HDL ("good" cholesterol).

Lower Risk of Antibiotic-Resistant Bacterial Infections and Zoonotic Diseases

Intensive farming practices, such as those used in the meat industry, contribute to the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains and the risk of pandemics from zoonotic diseases such as swine and bird flu.

Lower Risk of Foodborne Illness

According to the UN Food and Agricultural Organization, in 2006, global meat-producing factories contributed more greenhouse gases into the Earth's atmosphere than all emissions from trucks, airlines, cars, and other transportation combined. Animal rearing and agriculture are also significant factors in water pollution and deforestation.

Longevity

Research has shown that people who are vegans or vegetarians usually lead longer and healthier lives.

Environmental Benefits

A shift towards veganism can help to reduce the devastating impact of climate change, which will affect both humans and other animals. It can also help to reduce local environmental problems, such as the noxious gases emitted by intensive pig farms, which are often located near poor communities.

Aligned with Christian Values

Veganism can be seen as an extension of Christian values, such as compassion, love, and mercy. It can also be viewed as a form of fasting or self-denial, which is encouraged in the Bible.

Supporting Human Welfare

The livestock industry threatens human food and water security, and those already suffering from deprivation are at the greatest risk. A vegan diet can help to ensure that more food and water are available to those who need them.

Supporting Animal Welfare

Most farmed animals are raised in industrial systems that subject them to unnecessary suffering and impoverished lives. A vegan diet can help to reduce this suffering and allow animals to flourish and praise God in their particular way.

The role of Christian liberty and individual conscience

The Bible provides support for both vegetarian and non-vegetarian perspectives. The New Testament underscores the importance of Christian liberty and individual conscience.

In the New Testament, Jesus declares all foods clean (Mark 7:18-19). God delivers a similar message to Peter in the book of Acts. While the apostle was on the roof of Simon’s house in Joppa, he had a vision involving clean and unclean animals, and was told, “What God has made clean, do not call common” (Acts 10:9-16, ESV).

In Romans 14:2-6, Paul writes:

> One person believes he may eat anything, while the weak person eats only vegetables. Let not the one who eats despise the one who abstains, and let not the one who abstains pass judgment on the one who eats, for God has welcomed him. … The one who eats, eats in honour of the Lord, since he gives thanks to God, while the one who abstains, abstains in honour of the Lord and gives thanks to God. (ESV)

Paul's main concern in dealing with the eating of meat was to prevent it from becoming an issue that divides Christians. He emphasised that meat eaters should not despise vegetarians, and vegetarians should not pass judgment on meat eaters. He wrote that each Christian stands before the Lord to give their own account and that no one should become a lord, judging each other on this issue.

Paul continued:

> I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean in itself, but it is unclean for anyone who thinks it unclean. For if your brother is grieved by what you eat, you are no longer walking in love. By what you eat, do not destroy the one for whom Christ died. (Romans 14:14–16, ESV)

He also wrote:

> Do not, for the sake of food, destroy the work of God. Everything is indeed clean, but it is wrong for anyone to make another stumble by what he eats. It is good not to eat meat or drink wine or do anything that causes your brother to stumble. (Romans 14:20–21, ESV)

Paul's message was that Christians should not cause a brother to stumble into sin and destruction by what they eat. In his mind, the issue of vegetarian versus meat eater was not an issue of health, but an issue of love.

Frequently asked questions