Carb Cycling Vs Keto: Which Diet Is Superior?

Carb cycling and keto are both popular diets, but which is better? Carb cycling involves alternating between high- and low-carb days, and is often used by athletes and bodybuilders to enhance performance and build muscle mass. On the other hand, keto is a very low-carb, high-fat diet that puts the body into a state of ketosis, where fat is burned for energy instead of glucose. While keto can lead to rapid weight loss, it is not always sustainable or healthy in the long term. Carb cycling, on the other hand, offers more flexibility and can be easier to stick to. It may also help regulate hormones and prevent metabolic adaptation, a common cause of weight loss plateaus. However, there is limited research on the long-term effects of carb cycling. Ultimately, the best diet depends on individual needs and preferences.

Carb cycling can be more effective for sustained fat loss

Dr. Jim Stoppani, an author, exercise physiologist, and creator of JYM Supplement Science, recognises the value of keto diets for short-term fat loss. However, he does not recommend them as a long-term solution. He suggests that a gradual decrease in carbohydrate intake is a smarter plan, as it is more sustainable and manageable, and the same fat loss is attainable.

Carb cycling can also help to regulate hormones. Leptin, for example, is an appetite-suppressing, weight-regulating hormone. Carb cycling can improve leptin levels and decrease hunger. On the other hand, crash diets can mess with hormones such as leptin, cortisol, estrogen, and testosterone.

Carb cycling can also help with weight loss plateaus. When your metabolism slows down in response to consuming fewer calories, carb cycling can rev it up again and prevent metabolic adaptation.

Additionally, carb cycling can increase athletic performance. Eating carbs before high-intensity, short-duration exercise helps the body use glycogen as fuel. Exercise depletes glycogen stores, so eating carbs after training will help to refuel your glycogen stores and prevent muscle soreness.

However, it is important to note that carb cycling may not be suitable for everyone. It is not recommended for those who are pregnant or breastfeeding, or those with a history of eating disorders. Additionally, there may be an adjustment period when starting carb cycling, and some people may experience side effects similar to the "keto flu".

Keto is inflexible if/when a plateau is hit

Dr. Jim Stoppani recognizes the value of keto diets for short-term fat loss, but he does not recommend them as a long-term solution. He argues that keto is inflexible because once a plateau is hit, there is nowhere else to go with the diet. In other words, when someone hits a plateau, they have already cut out all their carbs, so there are no more left to cut out.

Dr. Stoppani suggests that a smarter plan would be to gradually decrease carbohydrate intake once body fat loss slows down. This way, the same fat loss is attainable, but the diet is more sustainable and manageable.

The problems with keto inflexibility

The inflexibility of keto can be a problem for several reasons. Firstly, it may not be sustainable for people who need to maintain a physique for an extended period, such as bodybuilders. Secondly, it can be hard to stick to in the long run, and it does not allow for much variety in the diet. Finally, it can be challenging to follow a keto diet because people are only allowed to eat very few foods containing carbohydrates.

How to make keto more flexible

Some people make keto more flexible by doing keto cycling, which involves having some days off when they eat more carbohydrates before returning to a complete keto plan. However, this approach has its drawbacks. There is no clear rule about how many days people should take off or how many carbs they should eat on those days, and it may lead to disordered eating and other nutritional issues.

Another way to make keto more flexible is to incorporate carb cycling, which alternates between high-carb and low-carb days. This approach can help prevent metabolic adaptation, which is when the metabolism slows down in response to consuming fewer calories. It can also support weight loss, improve athletic performance, and promote muscle growth.

The bottom line

While keto can be effective for short-term fat loss, it may not be flexible enough for some people's needs and goals. Incorporating keto cycling or carb cycling can make the diet more flexible and sustainable, but these approaches should be carefully planned and monitored to avoid potential drawbacks and health risks.

Carb cycling may be better for athletic performance

On high-carb days, eating more carbs increases insulin levels and promotes energy storage and muscle growth. Carb cycling can support weight loss, break up the monotony of dieting and fuel high-intensity workouts. Carbohydrates are the body's most preferred source of energy, and the body runs off glucose during workouts. Consuming carbs after training will also help refuel your glycogen stores, helping you get back into the gym sooner by preventing muscle soreness.

Carb cycling is popular among endurance athletes and bodybuilders. Glucose can provide quicker bursts of energy that help power muscles through long exercise events like marathons or triathlons and help build muscle mass. Carb cycling may also be better for athletic performance as it can be adjusted to fit your needs. A typical carb cycling plan may look like five or six "low-carb" days and one to two "high-carb" days. Many athletes and bodybuilders align high-carb days with high-intensity workouts.

Carb cycling may also be better for athletic performance as it can help prevent some of the common side effects of a full-on keto diet. These include fatigue, nausea, diarrhea, and other "keto flu" symptoms, which may be lessened if people aren't in ketosis for so many days at once. There's also some concern that carbohydrate restriction over a long period may negatively affect hormones, cholesterol levels, or even people's moods. Carb cycling may also be better for athletic performance as it can help with long-term compliance with a healthier diet.

Carb cycling may be better for long-term compliance

Carb cycling involves alternating between high-carb and low-carb days, rather than maintaining a constant carbohydrate intake. This approach can be beneficial for several reasons. Firstly, it can help improve metabolic flexibility, which is the ability of the body to shift between using carbs or fats for fuel. By manipulating insulin responses and tweaking metabolism cyclically, carb cycling can position the body favourably for fat reduction and muscle retention. Additionally, carb cycling can help regulate hormones such as leptin, which is an appetite suppressant and weight-regulating hormone. On high-carb days, increased carbohydrate intake improves leptin function and decreases hunger. This can make carb cycling mentally easier to stick to in the long run and provide more variety in the diet, which most health experts agree is beneficial for physical health.

Another advantage of carb cycling is that it can be tailored to individual needs and activity levels. For example, athletes and bodybuilders often align their high-carb days with high-intensity workouts. This is because the body uses glucose as fuel during these workouts, and consuming carbs helps to refuel glycogen stores and prevent muscle soreness. On low-activity and low-carb days, increasing protein and healthy fat intake can aid in muscle recovery. Carb cycling can also be beneficial for breaking through weight loss plateaus. Alternating between high-fat, low-carb days can help put the body in a fat-burning state and rev up the metabolism, preventing metabolic adaptation.

Furthermore, carb cycling may be preferable to keto for long-term compliance because keto can be challenging to follow over a prolonged period. Restrictive diets like keto may lead to medical problems such as disordered eating, cardiovascular disease, or nutritional deficits. They may also promote unhealthy relationships with food and cause weight fluctuations. In contrast, carb cycling can provide a more sustainable approach to weight management and overall health.

However, it is important to note that carb cycling may not be suitable for everyone. Some individuals may find it challenging to moderate their carb intake and may experience intense carbohydrate cravings or difficulty controlling their cravings. Additionally, reintroducing carbs can trigger physical side effects such as hunger, mental fog, low energy, and bloating in some people. Therefore, it is essential to assess individual needs and goals before deciding between keto and carb cycling.

Carb cycling may be easier to stick to mentally

Carb cycling is a dietary approach that involves alternating between high-carb and low-carb days, rather than maintaining a constant carbohydrate intake. This approach can be easier to stick to mentally for several reasons.

Firstly, carb cycling provides a more flexible and varied diet. On high-carb days, individuals can enjoy a wider range of foods, including whole grains, fruits, starchy vegetables, and legumes. This can help prevent diet boredom and make it easier to stick to the plan long-term.

Secondly, carb cycling may be more sustainable than keto diets, which are often restrictive and challenging to follow long-term. By allowing for occasional high-carb days, carb cycling may reduce the risk of binge eating or "cheat days", which are common when following highly restrictive diets.

Additionally, carb cycling can help prevent some of the side effects associated with keto diets, such as fatigue, nausea, and diarrhea. By regularly replenishing carbohydrate stores, individuals may experience improved energy levels and reduced gastrointestinal issues.

Carb cycling can also help regulate hormones, including leptin, which plays a crucial role in appetite suppression and weight regulation. By improving leptin levels, carb cycling may reduce hunger and cravings, making it easier to stick to the diet mentally.

Furthermore, carb cycling may be particularly beneficial for athletes and bodybuilders. By aligning high-carb days with high-intensity workouts, individuals can ensure their bodies have the necessary glucose to fuel intense exercise and promote muscle growth. This can lead to improved athletic performance and faster recovery, making it easier to stay motivated and committed to the diet.

Overall, carb cycling can be a more mentally manageable approach than strict keto diets due to its flexibility, potential for improved energy levels, and ability to support athletic performance and hormone regulation.

Frequently asked questions