Vegan Diet And Fish: Friends Or Foes?

Fish is not allowed in a vegan diet. Veganism is a lifestyle that excludes all animal products, including meat, poultry, fish, and dairy. While some people may identify as plant-based, which allows for flexibility in terms of animal product consumption, vegans do not consume anything that comes from animals. This is because vegans aim to eliminate the use and harm of living beings, and many animals suffer due to speciesist thinking. Fish feel pain and fear, and most commercially caught fish die from suffocation. Additionally, the fishing industry wreaks havoc on ocean ecosystems, with trawlers stripping the oceans of sea life and endangering other species such as turtles, sea birds, and dolphins.

Fish is not vegan-friendly because it is an animal product

Fish is an animal product and, therefore, not part of a vegan diet. While some people may choose to include fish in their diets for health reasons, there are vegan alternatives that can provide the same nutritional benefits without the harm and risk associated with consuming fish. For example, chia seeds, flax seeds, and walnuts are all rich sources of omega-3s and can be easily incorporated into a daily diet.

In addition to the ethical considerations of harming and killing animals for food, the fishing industry also wreaks havoc on ocean ecosystems. Massive trawlers strip the oceans of sea life, and most methods of catching fish are incredibly cruel. Fish caught in deep waters, for instance, suffer from depressurization when pulled to the surface, which can cause their eyes to pop out or their internal organs to burst.

The fishing industry also has a long history of human rights abuses, including human trafficking and slave labor. By choosing to exclude fish and other animal products from their diets, vegans are taking a stand against these harmful practices and advocating for the ethical treatment of all living beings.

Veganism is about more than just the food we eat; it is a commitment to compassion and reducing harm wherever possible. By excluding fish and other animal products, vegans are making a positive impact on the environment, their own health, and the lives of animals.

Fish feel pain and fear, and most commercially-caught fish die from suffocation

Fish are not part of a vegan diet. A vegan diet focuses on plant-based foods and beverages and excludes all animal products. The goal is to eliminate the use and harm of living beings. This means meat, poultry, fish, and dairy are taken off the plate and replaced with veggies, fruits, beans, nuts, and grains.

Fish feel pain and fear. While fish do not feel pain in the same way humans do, they do have neurons known as nociceptors, which detect potential harm, such as high temperatures, intense pressure, and caustic chemicals. They also produce opioids, the body's innate painkillers. Their brain activity during injury is similar to that of terrestrial vertebrates.

Most commercially-caught fish die from suffocation or a combination of suffocation and evisceration (gutting). These methods can take from minutes to hours to induce insensibility and are not regarded as humane.

The fishing industry wreaks havoc on ocean ecosystems

The fishing industry has a detrimental impact on ocean ecosystems, and this is primarily due to overfishing. Overfishing occurs when vessels catch fish at a rate that is faster than stocks can replenish. The number of overfished stocks globally has tripled in half a century, and one-third of the world's assessed fisheries are currently pushed beyond their biological limits. This has severe consequences for marine life, with one-third of sharks, rays, and chimaeras now at risk of extinction.

Overfishing is closely tied to bycatch, which is the unintentional capture of unwanted sea life. This results in the needless loss of billions of fish, as well as hundreds of thousands of sea turtles and cetaceans. The impact of overfishing extends beyond the marine environment as billions of people rely on fish for protein, and fishing is the principal livelihood for millions.

Another issue caused by the fishing industry is the abandonment of fishing gear, which continues to ensnare marine life, causing them to drown or starve. This "ghost gear" can include nets, lines, or pots and can remain in the ocean for up to 600 years in the case of plastic-based nets. It is estimated that 640,000 tons of abandoned, lost, or discarded fishing gear is spread across the world's oceans, making up about 10% of global oceanic litter.

Ocean noise pollution is another way in which marine ecosystems are disrupted. Most of this noise pollution comes from ship traffic and severely impacts whales, which communicate and orient themselves through sound. Noise pollution can tear apart the social networks of whales, adversely affecting their survival and reproductive success.

The fishing industry also contributes to ocean pollution through the use of fishing subsidies, which can lead to an excess of fishing vessels and the continuation of fishing operations that would otherwise not be economically viable.

The issues caused by the fishing industry have far-reaching consequences, impacting entire ecosystems and threatening the livelihoods of those who depend on the fishing industry for their income and food source.

Seafood is often contaminated with heavy metals and other harmful substances

Seafood is an important source of nutrients for humans, providing all the required amino acids, as well as vitamins and minerals. However, it is also a source of exposure to heavy metals and other harmful substances, which can pose a risk to human health. Heavy metals are released into the marine environment through natural processes such as weather and rock erosion, as well as human activities like industrial waste and sewage discharge. These metals accumulate in seafood through a process called bioaccumulation, where they are absorbed and stored in the tissues of fish and other marine organisms.

The specific heavy metals found in seafood include mercury, lead, chromium, cadmium, copper, and zinc. These metals can have toxic effects on human health, even leading to neurological disorders, kidney damage, circulatory system problems, and an increased risk of cancer. For example, inorganic mercury, which is converted into methylmercury by aquatic organisms, has been linked to devastating effects on children whose mothers consumed seafood with high levels of this contaminant.

The good news is that recent studies have shown a downward trend in the levels of pollutants in seafood over the past 30 years. This could be due to international efforts to ban or eliminate certain pollutants, as well as dietary changes in marine life. Additionally, selenium, found in ocean-caught fish, can bind to methylmercury and eliminate the risk to our bodies.

To minimize the risk of consuming contaminated seafood, it is recommended to opt for wild-caught fish, particularly those with shorter life spans and lower on the food chain, such as sardines, wild-caught Pacific or Alaskan salmon, and cod. It is also advisable to avoid imported fish, especially from Southeast Asia, and certain species like Chilean sea bass and orange roughy, which are known to have high levels of bioaccumulated contaminants.

There are vegan alternatives to fish and seafood

Fish and seafood are not part of a vegan diet. However, there are plenty of vegan alternatives that can be used to replace them.

Seaweed, Nori, and Wakame

Algae, including seaweed, nori, and wakame, are great alternatives to fish and seafood. They can be used in soups, salads, and rice dishes, as well as plant-based fish fingers and burgers. Algae has a savoury and salty flavour reminiscent of the sea, and it also offers health benefits such as valuable minerals, vitamins, antioxidants, and omega-3 fatty acids.

Tofu

Tofu is a classic vegetarian protein source that can be used as a fish alternative. It is made from condensed soy milk that is pressed into solid white blocks. Tofu has a chewy and hearty texture, and it absorbs flavours well. It can be used as a substitute for cubed fish, breaded fish, and fish fillets.

Seitan

Seitan is made from gluten harvested from wheat, spelt, and other cereals. It has a neutral taste and can be seasoned and marinated in various ways, making it a good base for plant-based fish fillets and fish burgers.

Jackfruit

Jackfruit has a stringy texture similar to fish, making it a popular whole food vegan fish substitute. It has a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture and works best in recipes that use fish pieces or shredded fish. Jackfruit also has a minor fruity zest, so it pairs well with sauces or strong flavours.

Heart of Palm

Heart of palm has a similar texture to jackfruit, and it can be used in recipes that call for small fish pieces such as crab dip, crab cakes, or lobster rolls. It has a neutral flavour and works well with sauces or strong flavours.

Cauliflower

Cauliflower is a popular vegan alternative to fish. It absorbs any flavour and has a crispy battered skin with a melt-in-your-mouth buttery inside. Cauliflower is often used in fish tacos, fillets, or fingers.

Canned Artichoke Hearts

Canned artichoke hearts have a similar texture to jackfruit and heart of palm, and they can be used as a substitute for small fish pieces in dips and crab cakes. They can also be blended with spices and formed into patties for fish sandwiches and crab cakes.

Store-Bought Vegan Fish

There are also many store-bought vegan fish alternatives available, including fish fillets, fish fingers, prawns, and shrimp. These can be found in the freezer section of most grocery stores, alongside other meat-free alternatives.

With so many vegan alternatives available, it's easier than ever to enjoy the tastes and textures of fish and seafood without compromising on animal welfare or environmental sustainability.

Frequently asked questions