Keto Vs. Macro: Which Diet Approach Delivers Better Results?

The ketogenic (keto) and macro diets are two popular methods of eating that have gained traction in recent years. While the keto diet involves following a high-fat, low-carbohydrate diet, the macro diet requires counting macronutrients (protein, carbohydrates, and fat) and is essentially a more complex way of counting calories. Both diets have their pros and cons, and the best diet for an individual depends on their personal preferences, needs, and ability to adhere to it.

Counting macros is based on scientific principles

Counting macros is one of the few diets backed by very robust science, as calories control our body weight. This diet is based on the principle of weight management, which states that calories control body weight. This is in contrast to other diets that may be ineffective due to their restrictive nature.

The macro diet involves counting your macronutrients (protein, carbohydrates, and fat). This is a more precise way of counting calories, which is essential for fat loss. By counting macros, you can ensure you are eating within your daily calorie goal and consuming the optimal amount of macronutrients, which offers further support for your health and performance.

The macro diet is based on scientific principles and has been shown to provide excellent results when followed correctly. It allows for some flexibility and does not require cutting out or demonizing any food groups. However, it can be a lot of work to count calories and macros, and it may be difficult and time-consuming.

Keto is a major lifestyle commitment

The keto diet involves following a high-fat and low-carbohydrate diet. Carbohydrates will typically make up only 5% to 15% of your total daily calories, with protein being around 20-30%, and fat making up the rest. This is a significant shift in the way you eat and requires a lot of planning and preparation.

To achieve ketosis, you need to drastically reduce your carbohydrate intake. This means cutting out or severely limiting grains, baked goods, starches, sugary treats, alcohol, and most fruits. It also means increasing your consumption of fatty foods such as red meat, ham, bacon, eggs, cheese, and vegetables. This can be a challenging adjustment, especially if you are used to eating a more balanced or carbohydrate-rich diet.

The transition to keto can be uncomfortable and even unbearable for some. Many people experience ""keto flu"" when they first start the diet, which includes symptoms such as lethargy, headaches, brain fog, trouble sleeping, and nausea. This is caused by your body adjusting to using fat instead of glucose as its primary source of energy.

Sticking to the keto diet requires discipline and dedication. Any deviation from the diet, such as a "cheat meal", can knock you out of ketosis. This can be challenging for those who enjoy eating out, socializing, or indulging in treats occasionally. It is also important to note that the keto diet may not be suitable for everyone, especially athletes or those with a history of disordered eating.

Overall, while keto can be an effective way to lose weight and improve certain health conditions, it is a significant lifestyle commitment that requires strict adherence to the diet and a willingness to make long-term changes to your eating habits.

Counting macros is more flexible than keto

Counting your macronutrients (macros) is a more flexible approach to dieting than the ketogenic (keto) diet. While keto has worked well for many people, it hasn't been the best dietary choice for many others. Counting macros is a more complex way of counting calories, which is the principle of fat loss.

The keto diet is a major lifestyle commitment that requires a high-fat and low-carbohydrate intake. Carbohydrates typically make up only 10-15% of your total daily calories, with protein at around 20-25%, and fat making up the rest. This diet is very restrictive and may be challenging to follow for long periods. It can lead to nutrient deficiencies, and it can be difficult to find keto-friendly sources of essential nutrients.

On the other hand, counting macros allows for some flexibility as long as you're hitting your target macros each day. It is based on the principle that calories determine body weight, and it doesn't require you to cut out or demonise any food groups. This approach may be preferable for those who want to have fun with what they eat and not be restricted to specific food groups.

Counting macros can be a lot of work, and it may be difficult and time-consuming. It may also allow too much flexibility, as there is no requirement to track or measure micronutrient intake. Additionally, it can be challenging to make adjustments without the help of a nutritionist or coach.

Overall, counting macros is a more flexible approach than keto, as it doesn't restrict you to specific food groups and allows you to eat anything as long as you stick to your calculated caloric intake.

Keto may be unsuitable for athletes

The keto diet is a high-fat, low-carb, and moderate-protein diet. It involves getting 70-80% of your calories from fat, 5% or fewer from carbohydrates, and 20-30% from protein. This diet is restrictive and may be challenging for athletes to follow for several reasons.

Firstly, the keto diet can lead to short-term side effects such as "keto flu," which includes symptoms like headaches, nausea, and fatigue. These side effects can impact an athlete's performance and ability to train effectively.

Secondly, the keto diet may not provide enough energy for athletes. Carbohydrates are a crucial source of energy for the body, especially during intense exercise. Restricting carbohydrate intake to 5% or less can result in reduced energy levels and fatigue.

Thirdly, the keto diet may not support optimal muscle recovery and growth for athletes. While protein intake is moderate on the keto diet, it may not be sufficient for athletes who require higher protein levels to support muscle repair and growth.

Additionally, the keto diet can be difficult to sustain long-term due to its restrictiveness. Athletes who require a high-calorie intake to fuel their training may find it challenging to adhere to the strict guidelines of the keto diet.

Finally, the keto diet can impact an athlete's overall health and well-being. Restricting carbohydrates and increasing fat intake can affect heart health and increase the risk of heart disease.

In conclusion, while the keto diet may offer weight loss and health benefits to some individuals, it may not be the best dietary approach for athletes. Athletes have unique nutritional needs and energy demands, and the restrictive nature of the keto diet may hinder their performance and overall health. It is important for athletes to consult with a registered dietitian or sports nutritionist to determine the best dietary approach for their specific needs and goals.

Calories control body weight

However, managing macronutrients (macros) can supercharge weight loss results. Macros are the three major sources of calories in our diet: fat, protein, and carbohydrates. Each of these is used differently by our bodies, and managing our intake of them can cause our bodies to activate unique metabolic pathways (such as ketosis) that help us achieve our fitness goals.

For example, the keto diet involves getting 75% of calories from fats, 20% from proteins, and 5% from carbohydrates. This is a very regimented diet that changes the way our bodies use energy, encouraging them to use byproducts of fat metabolism (ketones) for fuel instead of glycogen. This causes our bodies to enter a fat-burning state called ketosis, which suppresses our appetites and may make it easier to eat less.

However, keto is not suitable for everyone. It can be challenging to achieve ketosis, and the keto diet can be restrictive and hard to follow for long periods. It may also not be safe for people with type 1 diabetes or pregnant people.

Ultimately, there is no one-size-fits-all diet. The best diet is one that includes foods you enjoy and can be followed during tough times, allowing you to perform at your best physically and mentally.

Frequently asked questions