Cheat Days On Keto: Good Or Bad Idea?

The ketogenic diet is a strict, low-carb, high-fat diet that can be challenging to follow. As a result, some people on the keto diet may be tempted to have a cheat day, where they break the diet's rules and indulge in foods that are typically prohibited. While cheat days can be a welcomed break from the diet, they also come with several disadvantages and potential side effects. In this article, we will discuss the pros and cons of having a cheat day on the keto diet and provide tips for minimizing the negative impact on your progress.

The pros of a cheat day on keto

The keto diet is a highly restrictive diet that can be tough to follow. It is only natural that, at some point, you will be tempted to have a cheat day. A cheat day can be a welcomed break from the diet, but it is not without its drawbacks.

• Motivation and Reward: A cheat day can be a tasty reward for all your hard work and a great source of motivation to stay on the keto diet long-term. Knowing that you have a cheat day coming up can help you stay committed to your low-carb lifestyle between cheat days.
• Flexibility: Allowing yourself the flexibility to cheat occasionally may help you stick to the keto diet for a longer period. The keto diet is strict, and having a cheat day can provide a much-needed break from the rigid rules and food restrictions.
• Cravings: The keto diet restricts carbohydrates, which can lead to cravings for sugar, bread, rice, pasta, and other high-carb foods. A cheat day allows you to indulge in these foods without guilt and can be a welcome break from restrictive eating.
• Socialising: The highly restrictive nature of the keto diet can make socialising difficult, especially when it involves food. A cheat day can provide the flexibility to enjoy a meal with friends or family without the stress of sticking to your keto diet.

It is important to note that while cheat days can have benefits, they also have several potential drawbacks. These include disrupting your state of ketosis, increasing cravings, and negatively impacting your weight loss progress. The decision to include a cheat day in your keto diet plan should be made after considering both the pros and cons.

The cons of a cheat day on keto

Cheat days are common on diets, and the keto diet is a highly restrictive one, so it's understandable that people may want to take a break from it. However, there are several disadvantages to a cheat day on keto, and it's important to be aware of these before you decide whether to go for it.

Firstly, a cheat day can take you out of ketosis, which is the state your body goes into when it uses fat to create molecules called ketones. Ketosis is the whole point of the keto diet, so a cheat day can be detrimental to your progress. It can take a few days or even a week to get back into ketosis, which means a cheat day can set you back in your progress for up to seven days.

Secondly, a cheat day can cause a spike in blood sugar levels, which can be dangerous for diabetics and cause nausea in non-diabetics. It can also lead to a sugar crash, leaving you feeling tired and low on energy.

Thirdly, a cheat day can lead to weight gain, as your body will no longer be burning fat and will store any leftover carbs that haven't been burnt off through exercise or metabolism. This can be further exacerbated by binge eating, which is common on cheat days and can lead to weight gain and digestive issues.

Additionally, cheat days can lead to an increase in cravings, as carbohydrates and sugary foods are addictive. Giving in to cravings can make it harder to resist them in the future, and the keto diet is already difficult enough without adding more temptation.

Finally, exiting and re-entering ketosis can lead to symptoms of the keto flu, including mild headaches and severe fatigue. So, if you're thinking of having a cheat day on keto, be aware of the potential cons and make an informed decision.

How to recover from a cheat day on keto

Having a cheat day on the keto diet can be detrimental to your progress, as it can knock you out of ketosis and hinder weight loss. However, if you have had a cheat day, there are several ways to recover and get back on track. Here are some tips to help you recover from a cheat day on keto:

• Be kind to yourself: Don't beat yourself up mentally after a cheat day. It's important to be gentle with yourself and maintain a positive mindset. Guilt and self-criticism can be harmful to your mental health and demotivate you.
• Focus on other healthy behaviours: Remember that being healthy encompasses a range of behaviours beyond just diet. Reflect on other healthy practices you've been engaging in, such as exercise, hydration, meditation, or adequate sleep. Celebrating these achievements can help boost your motivation.
• Get back on track promptly: Don't let a cheat day turn into a cheat week or month. As soon as possible, re-establish your healthy keto routine. If you had an indulgent meal, compensate with a balanced, keto-friendly one soon after.
• Choose high-protein and vegetable meals: Opt for meals rich in protein and vegetables on the day following your cheat day. This helps balance your calorie intake and provides a low-calorie option after a day of indulgences.
• Increase your physical activity: Engage in physical activity after a cheat day, but avoid intense or excessive workouts. A moderate increase in activity can help burn off excess calories without causing undue stress on your body.
• Stay hydrated: Drink plenty of water after a cheat day to flush out excess salt, sugar, and toxins from your system. Aim for at least 2 litres of water the day after your cheat day.
• Practise mindful eating: Tune into your body's hunger and fullness cues. This skill will help you manage your portion sizes and avoid overeating, whether you're indulging in cheat meals or sticking to your keto diet.
• Avoid extended periods of cheating: While a cheat meal or day can be a planned part of your diet, try not to let it extend into a cheat week or month. The longer you stay off your keto diet, the harder it will be to resume it.
• Consider keto-friendly alternatives: Instead of completely cheating on your diet, opt for keto-friendly alternatives that satisfy your cravings without taking you too far off track. This way, you can still enjoy treats while staying within the boundaries of your diet.

Tips to avoid cheating on keto

The keto diet is a very low-carb, high-fat diet that is popular for its weight loss effects. It encourages ketosis, a metabolic state in which your body burns fat as its primary source of energy instead of carbohydrates.

• Practice mindfulness: Mindfulness involves paying attention to your body, which may help you resist cravings and emotional eating.
• Plan out your meals and snacks: A solid dietary plan makes it less likely that you’ll get hungry during the day and give in to cravings.
• Make your everyday diet enjoyable: Try incorporating different keto-friendly meals to vary up your diet and make it enjoyable. That way, you're less likely to feel the need to cheat.
• Keep tempting foods out of the house: Keeping treats and other tempting, high-carb foods out of sight can make cheating inconvenient.
• Have an accountability partner: A buddy or accountability partner can help you stay motivated to stick to your diet.
• Exercise: Physical activity depletes your body's stored form of carbohydrates, promoting ketosis.
• Try intermittent fasting: Combining intermittent fasting with the keto diet may help your body shift its fuel source from carbs to fat.
• Try a short-term fat fast: Fat fasts like egg fasts are very high-fat, low-carb diets meant to last only a brief period. They may help expedite ketosis.
• Try a medium-chain triglyceride (MCT) supplement: MCTs are a rapidly absorbed fatty acid that’s easily converted into ketones.

Remember, it's important to consult a healthcare professional before starting any new diet, and to seek guidance from a registered dietitian if you're struggling with a highly restrictive diet like keto.

Alternatives to a cheat day on keto

While cheat days on keto can be detrimental to your progress, there are some alternatives to help you stay on track.

Keto-Friendly Treats

Instead of a cheat day, opt for keto-friendly treats like keto brownies or keto cereal. These alternatives will satisfy your cravings without compromising ketosis.

Cyclical Ketogenic Diet

Consider a cyclical ketogenic diet, where you eat keto for five days and allow yourself a high-carb meal on the weekend. This approach may be more manageable than the classic keto diet.

Keto Comfort Foods

Rather than cheating, try making keto-friendly comfort foods like pizza, pasta, and desserts. These alternatives will allow you to indulge in your favourite flavours while staying true to your low-carb goals.

Portion Control

If you do decide to cheat, be mindful of portion control. Opt for a single cheat meal instead of a full day, as this will likely result in a lower carb intake.

Calorie Counting

Even on a cheat day, continue to count your calories and remain at a caloric deficit. This will help you stay on track with your weight loss goals, as weight loss is largely a numbers game.

Exercise

Exercise is a great way to get back into ketosis faster. Try adding 15-20 minutes of moderate to high-intensity exercise each day after a cheat day to deplete glycogen stores and promote ketosis.

Mindfulness and Planning

Practising mindfulness and planning your meals and snacks can help curb the urge to cheat. Having an accountability partner can also keep you motivated and committed to your keto diet.

While cheat days can be tempting, these alternatives will help you stay focused and achieve your keto goals without compromising your progress. Remember, a measured approach is usually better than going to extremes.

Frequently asked questions