Seafood And Vegans: What's The Deal?

Vegans typically avoid eating meat, poultry, and animal products, including seafood. However, there are some grey areas and exceptions. For instance, some people on plant-based diets might eat molluscs, as their lack of a central nervous system means they can't feel pain in the same way as other animals. This is a highly controversial topic, as some research suggests that molluscs may have more complex nervous systems and could experience pain. The 'seagan' diet is another exception, which is entirely plant-based with the addition of seafood.

Vegans don't eat fish or seafood

Some people on plant-based or vegan diets might choose to eat molluscs, as their lack of a central nervous system means they are unable to feel pain in the same way as other animals. However, this is not the majority view, and most consider oysters, clams and scallops to be non-vegan.

Fish and other marine animals are sentient beings, and vegans believe that all animals, including fish, deserve to live a complete and natural life, undisturbed by humans. There is also data to suggest that fish do feel pain. They have a central nervous system, made up of a spinal cord and brain, and they are able to detect and avoid harmful events and react to nociception.

In addition, there are environmental reasons for not eating fish and seafood. Research indicates that if current overfishing trends continue, nearly all seafood and fish stocks could collapse by 2050. Over 300,000 cetaceans, 100 million sharks, 250,000 turtles, and 300,000 seabirds die from entanglement in fishing nets each year.

Some people on plant-based diets eat molluscs

Veganism is a lifestyle and dietary practice that revolves around abstaining from the use and consumption of animal products. This includes fish and seafood. However, some people on plant-based or vegan diets might choose to eat molluscs, such as oysters, clams, and scallops. This is because, as they lack a central nervous system, they are believed to be incapable of feeling pain in the same way as mammals.

Molluscs are a diverse group of marine, freshwater, and terrestrial species that are widely consumed as food around the world. They include bivalves, such as oysters, clams, mussels, and scallops, as well as cephalopods like octopuses and squid. While some molluscs are carnivorous, others are plant-eaters or omnivores. Bivalves, for example, are filter feeders that use their shells to trap small organisms from the water. On the other hand, cephalopods are active hunters, using their tentacles to catch prey.

The question of whether molluscs are sentient is a highly debated topic. Some argue that bivalves, such as oysters and mussels, are no longer sentient and, therefore, consuming them does not contradict vegan principles. However, others assert that all molluscs are sentient beings that have the ability to perceive and react to their environment, and thus, they should not be consumed by vegans.

The argument for the sentience of bivalves is supported by anatomical evidence. Bivalves possess mechanoreceptors (touch) and chemoreceptors (taste), as well as light-sensitive cells that can detect shadows. Some bivalves, such as scallops, even have complex eyes. Additionally, all bivalves have a nervous system, albeit not a central one. This nervous system consists of a nerve network and three paired ganglia that innervate different parts of their bodies. There is also evidence that these nervous systems enable bivalves to feel pain. For instance, exposure to cold temperatures has been found to alter the ganglionic opiate processes in blue mussels, indicating the presence of a pain response.

In conclusion, while the majority of vegans consider molluscs to be non-vegan, a small number of individuals on plant-based diets do choose to include them. This decision is often based on the belief that molluscs lack the capacity to feel pain and are, therefore, exempt from the ethical considerations that apply to other animal products. However, the question of mollusc sentience remains a subject of ongoing debate and investigation.

Pescatarians eat fish and seafood, but not meat

Pescatarians eat fish and seafood but not meat. This means their diet includes freshwater fish such as trout and perch, saltwater fish like salmon and tuna, and shellfish including shrimp, oysters, clams, and more.

The term "pescatarian" was coined in the early 1990s and is a combination of the Italian word for fish, "pesce," and the word "vegetarian." It is also sometimes spelled "pescetarian." In scientific literature, this diet is often described as "pesco-vegetarian" and is considered a type of vegetarianism.

Pescatarians may also eat eggs and dairy products, in which case they are specifically called "lacto-ovo-pescatarians." However, there are no strict guidelines for the pescatarian diet beyond eating seafood. There are no rules about how often one must eat fish to be considered a pescatarian.

Some people choose a pescatarian diet for health reasons. A plant-based diet with fish included provides many health benefits, including a lower risk of obesity and chronic diseases like heart disease and diabetes. Fish is a source of omega-3 fatty acids, which have additional health benefits for the heart, brain function, and mood.

Environmental concerns are another reason for choosing a pescatarian diet. Raising livestock has a high environmental cost, contributing to about 15% of all human-made carbon emissions. In contrast, producing fish and seafood has a lower carbon footprint than producing any type of animal meat or cheese.

Ethical reasons also play a role in the decision to become a pescatarian. Some people who oppose slaughter or inhumane factory farming practices choose to eliminate land animals from their diet. However, it is important to note that aquaculture and overfishing can also be problematic.

While pescatarians do not eat meat, they may still experience cognitive dissonance due to the conflicting beliefs of caring about animal welfare and consuming fish. This is known as the "pescatarian's paradox."

The seagan diet is plant-based with seafood

The seagan diet is a plant-based diet with one exception: seafood. This diet is for those who want to eat vegan food but are unable to cut out seafood completely.

The co-authors of the book 'Seagan Eating', chef Amy Cramer and author Lisa McComsey, are proponents of this diet. They suggest that it is a healthier option than a vegan diet because of the inclusion of seafood, which is a source of omega-3 fatty acids. They also argue that it is a more realistic goal for those who want to improve their diet but are unable to go "whole-hog" vegan.

However, they acknowledge that their stance on seafood may be difficult for some to accept, especially ethical vegans. Cramer and McComsey emphasize the importance of choosing seafood that is sustainably sourced and low in mercury. They provide guidelines for identifying "good" and "bad" catches, as well as tips for cooking and preparing seafood.

The seagan diet is primarily plant-based, including fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, seeds, and grains. It excludes red meat, pork, poultry, eggs, and dairy. Seagans also strive to limit their intake of sugar, oils, fried foods, artificial chemicals, and processed foods. This diet aims to maximize nutrient intake while providing more flexibility and variety in meal options.

The ostrovegan diet includes bivalve molluscs

Veganism is a lifestyle and dietary practice that revolves around abstaining from the use and consumption of animal products and by-products. Vegans do not eat fish or seafood. However, some people on plant-based or vegan diets might choose to eat bivalve molluscs such as oysters, clams, and scallops due to their lack of a central nervous system and, by extension, their inability to feel pain. This subset of vegans is referred to as ostrovegans.

Ostrovegans are people who follow a vegan lifestyle and diet but consume certain bivalves under specific conditions. The term "ostrovegan" was coined to distinguish this subset of vegans who morally align with the ethical vegan diet and lifestyle but choose to include bivalves in their diet. The rationale behind this exception is that bivalves, like plants, lack a brain and central nervous system and, therefore, the ability to experience sentience or suffering.

Some people who follow the ostrovegan diet may choose to consume bivalves for their nutritional benefits. Bivalves are a good source of bioavailable B12, which can be difficult to obtain on a standard vegan diet. They also contain high levels of omega-3 fatty acids, which are important for human health.

However, it is important to note that not all vegans agree with the ostrovegan approach. Some argue that bivalves are still animals and, therefore, consuming them goes against the core principles of veganism, which seek to exclude the exploitation of and cruelty to animals. Additionally, there are concerns about the environmental impact of bivalve farming, particularly the use of hydraulic dredges, which can have negative consequences for the ecosystem.

Frequently asked questions