Cats On Vegan Diets: Healthy Or Harmful?

Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they have unique dietary requirements for nutrients most commonly found in animal-based foods. However, recent studies have suggested that cats can live on plant-based diets, with some research indicating that cats on vegan diets may be healthier than those on meat-based diets.

Cats on vegan diets have been found to have fewer instances of certain health issues, including dental disease, skin disease, and hormonal diseases. One study found that cats on plant-based diets were reported to have more ideal body condition scores than those on meat-based diets. Another study found that cats on vegan diets were more frequently reported by their guardians to be in very good health.

However, it is important to note that cats on vegan diets may require supplements to ensure they are getting all the necessary nutrients, as some nutrients are not naturally occurring in plant-based foods. Additionally, there is limited research on the long-term effects of plant-based diets on cats, and some veterinary organizations do not recommend vegan or vegetarian diets for cats due to a lack of evidence for the bioavailability of plant-based proteins.

Cats on plant-based diets may be healthier than those on meat-based diets

Another study, published in BMC Veterinary Research in 2021, surveyed 1,325 cat owners and found that cats on plant-based diets had fewer gastrointestinal and hepatic disorders and were more likely to be reported as being in very good health by their owners.

It is important to note that cats are obligate carnivores and have specific nutritional requirements. However, these nutrients can be synthetically made or sourced from novel ingredients, as stated in the guidance published by Pet Food UK. The British Veterinary Association previously did not recommend vegan or vegetarian diets for cats due to a lack of evidence for the bioavailability of plant-based proteins. However, with advancing technology and research, it is now possible to formulate nutritionally sound plant-based diets for cats that meet their specific nutritional needs.

While the research suggests that cats on plant-based diets may be healthier, it is crucial to consult with a veterinarian before making any dietary changes for your cat to ensure their specific nutritional needs are met.

Cats on plant-based diets may have fewer health issues

Studies and Reports Suggesting Improved Health

Some studies and reports suggest that cats on plant-based diets may have improved health outcomes compared to those on meat-based diets. Here are some key findings:

• A 2023 study by Knight et al. surveyed 1,369 cat guardians and found that cats on vegan diets tended to have better health outcomes across seven general indicators of illness, including reduced veterinary visits, medication use, and progression to therapeutic diets. They also found that 15 out of 22 specific health disorders were more common in cats fed meat, while only seven were more common in vegan cats.
• A 2021 cross-sectional study by Dodd et al. surveyed 1,325 cat owners and found that cats on plant-based diets had fewer gastrointestinal and hepatic disorders and were more likely to be reported as having ideal body condition scores. Owner perception of the health and wellness of cats did not seem to be adversely affected by a plant-based diet.
• A 2014 study by Semp included a questionnaire and clinical examination of 15 vegan cats, and no abnormalities were detected that were associated with the vegan diet.
• A 2006 study by Wakefield et al. found no significant differences in perceived health status between cats on vegetarian and conventional diets, with most caregivers in both groups describing their cats as healthy or generally healthy.

Potential Risks and Considerations

While the studies suggest potential health benefits, it is important to consider the following:

• Sample Size and Statistical Significance: Some of the studies had small sample sizes for cats on vegan diets, which may limit the statistical significance of the findings. Larger studies with more cats on vegan diets are needed to confirm the results.
• Supplementation and Formulation: Cats have specific nutritional requirements, and it is crucial to ensure that their plant-based diets are properly formulated and supplemented to meet these needs. Taurine, for example, is an essential nutrient for cats that is typically found in animal-based foods. Incomplete or improperly formulated diets can lead to nutritional deficiencies and health issues over time.
• Long-Term Health: Some health issues may take time to develop, and long-term studies are needed to fully understand the potential impacts of plant-based diets on cats' health over their lifetimes.
• Individual Variations: Not all cats may respond the same way to plant-based diets, and individual variations should be considered. Some cats may have specific health conditions or nutritional needs that require a different approach.
• Veterinary Advice: It is always recommended to consult with a veterinarian before making significant changes to a cat's diet. A veterinarian can provide guidance and advice based on the cat's individual needs and health status.

Cats on plant-based diets may need supplements

Cats are obligate carnivores and have unique dietary requirements for nutrients most commonly found in animal-based food sources. As such, it has long been considered that cats require a diet that contains animal-derived ingredients to provide the essential nutrients they need.

However, recent studies have shown that cats can remain healthy on a plant-based diet. A growing body of evidence suggests that cats can thrive on well-planned plant-based diets. One study found that cats fed plant-based diets tended to be healthier than cats fed meat-based diets. The study surveyed the guardians of 1,369 cats, 1,178 of whom were fed conventional meat-based diets, 64 raw meat diets, and 127 vegan diets. Across seven general indicators of illness, including frequency of vet visits, medication taken, and progression onto specialised prescription diets, the vegan cats tended to fare better.

Another study found that cats fed plant-based diets were reported to have more ideal body condition scores than cats fed a meat-based diet. Fewer cats on plant-based diets were reported to have gastrointestinal and hepatic disorders.

However, it is important to note that cats on plant-based diets may need supplements to ensure they are getting all the nutrients they need. Cats need nutrients like taurine, vitamin A, and arachidonic acid, which are predominantly or exclusively found in animal-based food sources. While it is possible to supplement these nutrients into vegan cat food, it requires a certain level of knowledge about cat nutrition or sound advice from an animal health professional.

Overall, while cats can remain healthy on a plant-based diet, it is important to ensure that they are getting all the necessary nutrients, either through their food or through supplements.

Cats on plant-based diets may have a lower environmental impact

Cats are obligate carnivores, and their diet has traditionally been meat-based. However, there is a growing trend of cat owners who are vegan or vegetarian themselves, choosing to feed their cats plant-based diets. This has sparked a debate about the health and environmental implications of such diets for cats.

Environmental Impact of Meat-Based Cat Food

Pet food production has a significant environmental impact. In the US, it accounts for 25-30% of the emissions from animal products consumed by Americans. The agricultural land used annually to produce dry food for cats and dogs is around 49 million hectares, roughly twice the size of the UK.

Health Concerns of Meat-Based Cat Food

There are also concerns about the health implications of meat-based cat food. Commercial pet food often contains meat industry offcuts like connective tissue and offal, artificial preservatives, and grains, which are considered unhealthy for cats. Meat-based cat food has been linked to an increased likelihood of bacterial infections, malnutrition, and parasites.

Plant-Based Diets for Cats

Plant-based cat food is a relatively new concept, and there is limited research on its health and environmental impacts. However, some studies suggest that cats on plant-based diets may be healthier than those on meat-based diets, with lower instances of dental disease, skin disease, and hormonal diseases.

Environmental Impact of Plant-Based Cat Food

Plant-based cat food has the potential to reduce the environmental impact of pet food production. If all the world's cats and dogs went vegan, greenhouse gas emissions could be reduced by more than the combined emissions of the UK and New Zealand.

Challenges and Considerations

One of the main challenges of plant-based cat food is ensuring that it meets the nutritional needs of cats, who require certain nutrients like taurine, which are not naturally found in plant-based foods. However, these nutrients can be supplemented, and some studies have shown that cats are actually more able to digest plant proteins than dog proteins.

While more research is needed, initial studies suggest that cats on plant-based diets may have better health outcomes and a lower environmental impact than those on meat-based diets. This could be a promising development, given the significant environmental footprint of the pet food industry. However, cat owners should consult with veterinarians to ensure that their cats' nutritional needs are met, especially if they are considering a plant-based diet.

Cats on plant-based diets may be more ethical

Cats are carnivores, and as such, it has long been considered that they require a diet containing animal-derived ingredients to provide the essential nutrients they need. However, this assumption has been challenged in recent years, with a growing body of research suggesting that cats can not only survive but thrive on well-planned plant-based diets. This has implications not only for the health of cats but also for the environmental impact of pet food production and the ethical concerns around the use of animal products.

The health argument for plant-based cat diets

Several studies have found that cats fed plant-based diets had better health outcomes than those fed meat-based diets. A 2021 cross-sectional study of owner-reported health in Canadian and American cats found that fewer cats on plant-based diets had gastrointestinal and hepatic disorders and that owners of cats on plant-based diets were more likely to report their cats as being in very good health. Another study, published in PLOS One, surveyed the guardians of 1,369 cats and found that, across seven general indicators of illness, the vegan cats tended to fare better. The researchers controlled for differences in age, sex, neutering status, and primary location, and found that cats on plant-based diets had fewer veterinary visits, less use of medication, and fewer instances of owners thinking their cats were in poor health.

It is worth noting that the majority of these studies relied on owner-reported data, which may be subject to bias, and that the number of cats on plant-based diets in the studies was relatively small. However, the existing evidence suggests that, contrary to long-held beliefs, it may be possible for cats to maintain good health on a plant-based diet.

The environmental argument for plant-based cat diets

The pet food industry has a significant environmental impact, with pet food production in the US alone accounting for between 25 and 30 percent of the country's emissions from animal products. If the world's cats and dogs went vegan, it could save more greenhouse gas emissions than all the emissions from the UK and New Zealand combined. This reduction in environmental impact is not only beneficial for the planet but also for human health, as the meat industry is a major contributor to climate change.

The ethical argument for plant-based cat diets

The immense suffering caused to animals in factory farming systems is considered a serious ethical problem, particularly for guardians who are vegan themselves. While some people argue that it is unnatural and therefore unethical to feed cats or dogs a diet they would not choose for themselves, others counter that vegan cat food can be supplemented with the necessary nutrients, such as taurine, to ensure it meets their nutritional needs.

In conclusion, while there may be initial skepticism about the suitability of plant-based diets for cats, the existing research suggests that they may not only be safe but also offer health and environmental benefits. As the body of evidence grows, it is becoming increasingly clear that transitioning cats to nutritionally sound plant-based diets could be a positive step for both their health and the planet.

Frequently asked questions