Keto Weight Gain: What Went Wrong?

The ketogenic diet is a low-carbohydrate method of eating that involves drastically reducing your carbohydrate intake to improve your health and lose weight. While the keto diet can suppress appetite and make fat loss easier, it is not always the case. Some people end up not losing weight or even gaining weight on a keto diet.

There are several reasons why someone might gain weight after stopping the keto diet. Firstly, when you stop eating keto and reintroduce carbohydrates, you will experience an initial weight gain due to increased fluid retention as your body adjusts to your new way of eating. This is often referred to as water weight and can be significant, ranging from 5 to 10 pounds.

Secondly, keto is a restrictive diet that requires careful tracking of macronutrients and calories. When people stop keto, they may return to old eating habits and consume more calories than they burn, leading to weight gain over time. This is especially true if they go back to eating highly processed foods, sugary snacks, and unhealthy carbohydrates that were restricted on the keto diet.

Additionally, keto can reduce hunger and cravings, making it easier to control portions and avoid overeating. When people stop keto, they may find themselves snacking more frequently or consuming larger portions, which can contribute to weight gain.

It is important to note that not everyone will gain weight after stopping keto. Some people may be able to maintain their weight loss by adopting a more balanced and less restrictive diet, such as paleo or a modified version of keto that includes more carbohydrates. However, if someone returns to their previous eating habits and lifestyle that led to weight gain in the first place, they are likely to regain the weight.

You're no longer in ketosis

If you're no longer in ketosis, it could be because you're not actually out of ketosis. It's common for urine test strips to show a negative result even when you are still in ketosis. This is because urine strips only measure excess ketones, and as your body adjusts to the keto diet, it will produce fewer excess ketones.

If you want to accurately measure whether you're in ketosis, a blood ketone meter is the most reliable method. However, these can be expensive. Alternatively, you can learn to identify ketosis by how you feel. Some indicators that you are in ketosis include:

• Rapid weight loss
• Experiencing keto flu and recovering without increasing your carb intake
• Decreased appetite
• Less urgent hunger
• Fruity-smelling breath
• Better mental focus and clarity
• Decreased carb cravings
• Lower blood pressure
• Improved mood and reduced anxiety

If you're sure that you're no longer in ketosis, there are several potential reasons why. Firstly, you may be consuming too many carbs. Even keto-friendly foods can add up to too many carbs if you're not careful. Make sure you're keeping track of your carb intake and staying under 25 net grams per day.

Another reason you may be knocked out of ketosis is that you're eating too much protein. Try to keep your protein intake on the lower side, around 15% of your daily calories.

Finally, stress can also affect ketosis, as it raises insulin levels, which in turn lowers ketone production.

You're not counting calories

Counting calories is a pain, but it's a surefire way to keep track of your energy intake. If you're not counting calories, it's easy to slip into old habits and start eating more than you burn. This is especially true if you're coming off a restrictive diet like keto, where you may have been more mindful of what you were consuming.

When you're in a calorie deficit, your body burns fat for energy. But when you're in a calorie surplus, your body stores the excess calories as fat. So, if you're not counting calories, it's easy to tip the balance in the wrong direction and gain weight.

It's important to remember that not all calories are created equal. The type of calories you eat matters just as much as the number. For example, calories from sugar and refined carbs are more likely to lead to weight gain than calories from whole foods like fruits and vegetables. That's because different types of calories affect your body and metabolism differently.

When you're on the keto diet, you're already cutting out a lot of high-calorie, processed foods that are easy to overeat. So, when you go off keto, it's important to be mindful of your calorie intake and make sure you're not overeating. This is especially true if you're increasing your carb intake, as carbs can drive up your hunger and cravings.

To avoid gaining weight, make sure you're getting your calories from nutritious, whole foods and not just adding back a bunch of processed carbs and sugars. Track your calories and maintain a deficit or, at the very least, stay at maintenance level. This will help you avoid weight gain as you transition off the keto diet.

You're eating too much protein

Eating too much protein can kick your body out of ketosis, which is the metabolic state that occurs when the body uses fat to fuel its functions. Ketosis is the hallmark of the ketogenic diet. When you're in ketosis, your body releases ketones, which can be measured in the blood and urine.

Protein should only make up about 20% of your daily intake. Calculate your protein needs and be sure to stay within that limit.

If you're not sure what range is right for you, find a registered dietitian in your area who will be able to help you meet your personal goals.

You're eating too many carbs

If you've gained weight after stopping keto, it could be because you're eating too many carbs. The keto diet is a low-carbohydrate method of eating that puts your body into a metabolic state called ketosis, where it burns stored fat for energy instead of carbohydrates. When you stop keto and reintroduce carbs, your body will retain more water weight as it rebuilds its glycogen stores, which bind to water. This can lead to initial weight gain even if you're still eating the same number of calories.

Additionally, carbs can drive hunger and cravings, which can lead to increased caloric intake and weight gain. This is especially true if you have a history of binge eating or struggle with portion control. The keto diet can help manage out-of-control food cravings and binging, so stopping keto may result in a loss of that control and a return to previous eating habits that contributed to weight gain.

To avoid this, you can try slowly reintroducing carbs and monitoring your weight. Start by estimating your daily carb intake on keto and increasing that by 25% each week until you reach your desired carb intake. If you start gaining weight, ease up on the carbs and reassess. This gradual approach will help your body adjust to using carbs for energy again and may minimize weight gain.

It's also important to make healthy choices when it comes to carbs. Opt for unprocessed whole foods, vegetables, and small amounts of berries instead of sugary snacks, desserts, and baked goods. Prioritize lean proteins, vegetables, and wholesome carbohydrates like fresh fruits, whole grains, and beans.

Remember that weight gain after stopping keto is not just about the number of carbs but also your body's response to them. You may experience carbohydrate intolerance or temporary insulin resistance, leading to higher-than-normal glucose spikes and weight gain even with a small number of carbs. This is a normal response as your body readjusts to using carbs for energy.

To summarize, if you've gained weight after stopping keto, it could be due to eating too many carbs, especially if you're not mindful of your intake and portion sizes. Slowly reintroducing carbs and making healthy choices can help minimize weight gain. Additionally, your body's response to carbs may contribute to weight gain as it readjusts to using them for energy.

You're eating too much fat

The keto diet is a high-fat, low-carb diet. While on keto, the bulk of your calories come from fat, so when you transition off keto, you'll need to reduce your fat intake to make room for more carbohydrates.

How to Cut Down on Fat

• Gradually decrease your fat intake while increasing your consumption of lean proteins, vegetables, and healthy carbohydrates like fresh fruits, whole grains, and beans.
• Continue to eat healthy fats like avocado and olive oil, but in moderation.
• Be mindful of your calorie intake. Fats are the most calorically dense macronutrient, so even if you're eating keto-friendly foods, you can still exceed your calorie needs and gain weight.
• Monitor your weight and how you feel as you adjust your diet.
• Consider tracking your food intake to ensure you're not consuming too much fat or too many calories overall.

Other Tips for Transitioning Off Keto

• Gradually increase your carbohydrate intake by adding an additional 10 grams of carbohydrates per day from healthy sources like whole grains, beans, fruits, and starchy vegetables.
• Find your desired carb range by aiming for a number of carbohydrates that allows you to eat a varied diet without feeling restricted while maintaining your weight.
• Increase your protein intake to take advantage of the thermic effect of food, which is higher for protein than for carbohydrates.
• Continue to avoid highly processed foods, sugary desserts, sugar-sweetened beverages, and processed meats, as these are high in calories, sodium, sugar, and/or saturated fat.

Remember, the key to maintaining your weight after keto is to adopt some of the healthy behaviours you developed while on the diet, such as mindful eating and choosing nutritious foods.

Frequently asked questions