Keto Diet: Water Weight And Why It Fails

The keto diet is a popular choice for people looking to lose weight. It involves drastically reducing carbohydrate intake, which puts the body into a metabolic state called ketosis, where it burns fat for energy instead of glucose. While the keto diet can lead to weight loss, it is important to understand that much of the initial weight loss is due to water weight loss rather than fat loss. This is because when you restrict carbs, your body burns through glycogen, which is bound with water, and this water is then excreted through urine or sweat. As a result, you may notice increased urination and thirst. While the keto diet can be beneficial for weight loss, it is not a quick fix, and a healthy approach is needed for lasting results.

The keto diet and water weight loss

The keto diet is a popular choice for people looking to lose weight. It involves significantly restricting carbohydrate intake, which means the body goes into a stage called ketosis, where it becomes very efficient at burning fat and using it for energy instead of glucose.

When you start the keto diet, you will likely experience rapid weight loss in the first few days. However, this early weight loss is mostly water weight rather than fat loss. This is because the body uses glycogen for energy, which is bound to water, and when the body uses glycogen, the water is released and excreted in urine or sweat.

After the initial water weight loss, your weight loss will probably slow down, but once you are fully in ketosis, it will be more fat than water that is being lost.

How to maximise weight loss on the keto diet

To maximise weight loss on the keto diet, it is recommended to:

• Get adequate sleep
• Reduce stress
• Be more physically active
• Consume whole, nutritious, low-carb foods
• Drink plenty of water
• Plan meals
• Keep a food journal

Ketosis and weight loss

The keto diet is a popular choice for people trying to lose weight. It involves significantly restricting carbohydrate intake, which means the body goes into a state called ketosis, where it becomes very efficient at burning fat for energy instead of glucose.

When the body is in ketosis, it uses ketones, broken down from dietary fat or stored body fat, as its primary source of fuel. This metabolic state is achieved by drastically reducing carbohydrate intake, typically to around 30-50 grams per day, or 5-10% of total calories.

Weight Loss and Ketosis

Weight loss on the keto diet is often attributed to the body's ability to utilise stored fat for energy once in ketosis. However, initial weight loss is often due to water weight loss. This is because the glycogen stored in muscles and the liver, which is bound with water, is rapidly burned through and excreted in urine or sweat. This can result in dramatic weight loss during the transition period, but it is not indicative of long-term fat loss.

Factors Affecting Weight Loss on Keto

While the keto diet can be effective for weight loss, there are several factors that can hinder results. These include:

• Consuming too many carbs, preventing the body from reaching and maintaining ketosis
• Eating too many calories, creating an energy surplus
• Lack of physical activity, reducing calorie expenditure
• Chronic stress and lack of sleep, impacting hormones that regulate appetite and weight gain
• Snacking on high-calorie foods, increasing overall calorie intake
• Eating processed and nutrient-poor foods, which are high in calories but low in nutritional value
• Unrealistic weight loss expectations, as weight loss varies from person to person

Healthy Weight Loss Tips

To achieve healthy and consistent weight loss, it is important to adopt a realistic approach. This includes aiming for a loss of 1-2 pounds per week, focusing on whole, nutritious foods, and incorporating physical activity into your routine. Additionally, staying hydrated, getting enough sleep, and managing stress can also support your weight loss journey.

The whoosh effect myth

The "whoosh effect" is a term that has been coined by some people following a ketogenic, or keto, diet to describe the seemingly sudden weight loss that occurs. The idea is that when a person burns fat, the fat cells lose fat but fill up with water, making the body feel loose or wobbly to touch. People then claim that after losing enough fat, the cells will gradually increase their water-to-fat ratio until they are all water, and then the body will release the water from the cells through urine or diarrhea, resulting in noticeable weight loss.

However, this concept is false and has no scientific backing. When the body burns fat, fat cells, or adipose tissue, store excess energy. When the body burns more calories than it takes in, the body expels excess fat and the fat cells shrink. In fact, when a person loses weight, the body converts most of the fat into carbon dioxide, which is exhaled. Although the body does convert a much smaller percentage into water, there is no evidence to suggest that the cells begin "filling with water" and suddenly disappear when they no longer contain any fat.

The whoosh effect that people claim to experience is likely due to losing "water weight." When the body becomes dehydrated, it starts to store water, which can make people feel more bloated or heavier than usual. Once a person drinks enough water, they will lose the excess water weight, which can appear as a noticeable loss of weight. This is not the same as sustainable weight loss and is not a healthy approach to weight loss.

While the keto diet can be beneficial for some people, it needs to be approached healthily to achieve long-term results.

Glycogen and water weight

Glycogen is a stored form of glucose that the body holds in the liver and muscle cells as a quick fuel source. Each glycogen molecule is made up of a protein core, surrounded by glucose subunits. Each gram of glycogen stored in the body is bound to three or four grams of water.

Glycogen is the main culprit behind sudden bouts of weight loss and weight gain, especially during a diet. When a person starts a diet, particularly a low-carb one, they burn through their body's glycogen stores and don't replenish them. This is why people can lose a lot of weight in the first week of a diet. Conversely, when someone eats a lot of carbohydrates, they fill their body's glycogen reserves, which can lead to weight gain.

Glycogen is stored in the body in a hydrated form, with three to four parts water. When the body uses glycogen for energy, the stored water gets released, and the body expels it in sweat and urine. This release of water can result in rapid weight loss, especially during the first few days of a very low-carb diet. However, it is important to note that this early weight loss is water weight, not fat loss.

In summary, glycogen and water weight are closely linked. Glycogen is stored in the body with water, and when glycogen is broken down for energy, the water is released and expelled from the body. This can lead to fluctuations in weight, especially when starting a new diet or significantly changing carbohydrate intake.

Keto diet weight loss expectations

The keto diet is a popular choice for people looking to lose weight. It involves significantly restricting your carbohydrate intake, which puts your body into a metabolic state called ketosis, where it becomes very efficient at burning fat for energy instead of glucose.

When you first start the keto diet, you will likely experience rapid weight loss, which is mostly due to the loss of water weight. This is because the body burns through the glycogen (carb stores) in your liver and muscles, which is bound to water. As you burn through these stored carbs, your body releases this water in your urine or sweat.

After this initial period of water weight loss, your weight loss will probably slow down, but it will be more fat than water. While the keto diet can be beneficial for weight loss, it is important to approach it with a healthy mindset and realistic expectations. Here are some things to keep in mind:

• Be mindful of your calorie intake: Even if you are in ketosis, you may still gain weight if you are consuming more calories than you burn. Many keto-friendly foods are high in calories, so be mindful of portion sizes and snacking.
• Exercise regularly: Exercise is an important part of staying healthy and can help you reach your desired weight. It stimulates your body's metabolism and burns calories.
• Manage stress and get enough sleep: Research shows that chronic stress and lack of sleep can negatively impact weight loss. When your body is stressed, it produces a hormone called cortisol, which can encourage your body to store fat. Lack of sleep can also increase your appetite.
• Be consistent: Weight loss takes time and consistency. Focus on making sustainable dietary changes and incorporating exercise into your daily routine.
• Have realistic expectations: Weight loss can vary from person to person, and it may not be rapid. Most experts recommend losing 1-3 pounds (0.5-1 kg) per week. If you are also weight training, you may gain muscle while losing fat, which can lead to slower weight loss on the scale but has many health benefits.

Frequently asked questions