Vegan Diet And Muscle Loss: What's The Truth?

There are conflicting opinions on whether a person will lose muscle mass on a vegan diet. Some sources suggest that a vegan diet can lead to a decrease in muscle mass and definition. However, others argue that a well-planned vegan diet that includes sufficient protein and calories can support muscle growth and maintenance. Plant-based proteins such as legumes, nuts, seeds, and soy foods can provide adequate protein for muscle metabolism, and plant foods are also loaded with antioxidants, which can reduce the intensive load that exercise puts on the body. Nevertheless, it is important to ensure a sufficient intake of calories and nutrients like protein, calcium, iron, and vitamins D and B12 to maintain muscle mass and overall health.

Vegan diets can be lower in calories

A study comparing omnivorous and vegan bodybuilders found that both groups exhibited a reduction in calorie intake during the cutting phase, with the vegan group consuming slightly fewer calories overall. This suggests that vegan diets may result in a lower calorie intake, particularly when trying to reduce body fat.

It is important to note that the type of calories consumed also matters. Plant-based proteins often contain fewer essential amino acids than their animal-based equivalents, and the digestibility of plant-based proteins is lower due to anti-nutritional factors. As a result, vegan diets may require careful planning to ensure sufficient protein intake, especially during periods of caloric restriction.

Additionally, the choice of protein sources within a vegan diet can impact calorie intake. For example, cereals, which are common in vegan diets, contribute to overall protein intake but may need to be reduced during a calorie deficit. Replacing them with protein-rich equivalents like pseudocereals (quinoa, amaranth, buckwheat) can help maintain protein intake while reducing calories.

In summary, vegan diets can be lower in calories, and this is an important consideration for maintaining muscle mass. However, it's not just about the number of calories but also the quality of those calories, particularly the type and digestibility of proteins. Careful dietary planning can help ensure that a vegan diet provides sufficient calories and protein to support muscle growth and maintenance.

Vegan protein powders are more expensive

It is a common misconception that a vegan diet leads to muscle loss. In reality, muscle is built and sustained through resistance exercise, which breaks down muscle fibres, allowing them to rebuild stronger. This process is supported by proper nutrition, particularly the consumption of adequate calories and protein. While animal products are often associated with protein and considered key to an athlete's diet, it is important to recognise that protein is also abundant in plant-based sources such as legumes, nuts, seeds, and plant-based foods like tofu and seitan. These plant-based sources not only meet the body's protein needs but also offer additional health benefits like phytonutrients, fibre, and antioxidants.

However, one challenge that vegans may face is the higher cost of vegan protein powders. Vegan protein powders tend to be more expensive than their animal-based counterparts, and this can be a significant consideration for those looking to supplement their protein intake. The reasons for the higher cost of vegan protein powders are multifaceted and worth exploring. Firstly, the production of vegan protein powders often involves more expensive ingredients and complex manufacturing processes. For example, plant-based proteins may require additional steps such as cooking, fermentation, or dehulling to improve their bioavailability and reduce anti-nutritional factors.

Additionally, the demand for vegan protein powders has been steadily increasing, driven by a growing number of consumers adopting vegan, vegetarian, or plant-based diets. This increased demand has led to a surge in the development and marketing of vegan protein powders, with companies investing in research and innovation to create appealing products. The costs associated with these efforts are often reflected in the final price of the product. Moreover, the production and sourcing of certain plant-based proteins can be more challenging and costly. For instance, pea protein, a popular choice for vegan protein powders, has a lower yield compared to other protein sources, which can drive up costs.

Furthermore, the taste and texture of vegan protein powders have historically been less appealing to consumers, often described as "tasting like shit". This has prompted companies to invest in flavour development and masking agents to improve the sensory experience, adding to the overall cost of the product. It is worth noting that some newer brands have managed to create better-tasting options, but they still tend to be pricier than their animal-based counterparts. The higher cost of vegan protein powders can also be attributed to the smaller-scale production of these products. While animal-based proteins have been dominant in the market for a long time, the rise of veganism is a relatively newer trend, and the infrastructure for large-scale production of vegan proteins is still developing.

Lastly, the higher cost of vegan protein powders may be influenced by the targeted consumer base. Vegan protein powders often cater to a specific niche market, including health-conscious individuals, those with dietary restrictions, and ethical consumers. This specialised market is generally willing to pay a premium for products that align with their values and health goals. Despite the higher cost, it is important to note that there are still affordable options available, and consumers can also opt for homemade alternatives or whole food sources of plant-based protein.

Vegans need to eat more calories than they burn

To build muscle, the body needs to be in a state of positive energy balance, with a protein requirement ranging from 1.6 to 2.2 g/kg of body mass. During the muscle-building phase, known as the bulking phase, athletes aim to increase muscle mass without adding unnecessary body fat. This is achieved through resistance training and maintaining a positive energy balance. In the cutting phase, bodybuilders aim to reduce body fat while maintaining muscle mass. During this phase, a high-protein, calorie-restricted diet is typically followed, along with aerobic exercise and resistance training.

Vegan bodybuilders may struggle to meet their protein needs during the cutting phase, as they tend to reduce their protein intake while maintaining a caloric deficit. This can put them at risk of losing the muscle mass they gained during the bulking phase. To prevent this, vegan athletes should ensure they are consuming enough calories and may benefit from the assistance of nutritional professionals to ensure they are getting enough protein to maintain muscle mass.

Overall, while it is possible to build and maintain muscle mass on a vegan diet, it is important for vegans to be mindful of their calorie and protein intake, especially during periods of caloric restriction. By consuming a variety of plant-based protein sources and potentially supplementing with isolated plant-based proteins, vegans can ensure they are getting enough calories and protein to support muscle growth and maintenance.

Vegans need to lift weights to gain muscle

It is a common misconception that vegans will lose muscle mass due to a lack of animal products in their diet. However, this is not the case, as muscle growth is dependent on resistance exercise and adequate nutrition. Removing animal products from your diet does not change how your body responds to physiologic processes.

Resistance Training

Placing strain on the muscle through resistance training allows the muscle to break down and rebuild stronger, leading to muscle growth and maintenance. This process is not dependent on the inclusion of animal products in your diet.

Adequate Nutrition

While proper nutrition supports the muscle rebuilding process, it is important to note that protein is not synonymous with animal products. There are plenty of plant-based sources of protein, including legumes (beans, lentils, peas, and soy foods), nuts, and seeds. These plant-based sources not only meet your body's protein needs but also provide additional health benefits such as phytonutrients and fiber.

Caloric Intake

In addition to ensuring sufficient protein intake, it is crucial to consume adequate calories to supply your body with the energy required for muscle growth and maintenance. A caloric deficit can lead to muscle loss, regardless of your dietary choices.

Weight Lifting

Engaging in weight lifting or strength training is essential for gaining and maintaining muscle mass. Cardio exercises are great for burning calories, but weight lifting creates muscle tone and sustains the calorie burn for longer, resulting in increased calorie burn and muscle creation.

In conclusion, vegans do not need to worry about losing muscle mass as long as they incorporate resistance training, ensure adequate protein and calorie intake, and include weight lifting in their fitness routines.

Plant-based proteins are often incomplete

It is a common misconception that a vegan diet leads to muscle loss due to inadequate protein intake. While it is true that animal products are synonymous with protein and are emphasised in an athlete's diet, there are plenty of plant-based proteins that meet the body's protein requirements. These include legumes (beans, lentils, peas, and soy foods), nuts, and seeds. However, it is important to note that plant-based proteins are often considered incomplete, meaning they typically contain fewer essential amino acids than their animal-based equivalents. This can be a concern for athletes, especially bodybuilders, who require sufficient protein to support muscle growth and maintenance.

The Role of Essential Amino Acids

Essential amino acids (EAAs) are crucial for various bodily functions, including muscle protein synthesis and repair. They are called "essential" because the body cannot produce them, and they must be obtained from the diet. Animal-based proteins, such as meat, dairy, and eggs, are considered complete proteins because they contain all the essential amino acids in sufficient amounts. In contrast, plant-based proteins may be lacking in certain essential amino acids, particularly leucine, which is crucial for muscle growth.

Combining Plant Proteins

To ensure a complete amino acid profile, it is important to combine different plant protein sources. For example, combining legumes with grains or nuts and seeds can help improve the overall quality of protein intake. Additionally, certain plant-based foods, such as quinoa, amaranth, and buckwheat (pseudocereals), have a higher protein quantity and quality, as they contain leucine as the most abundant essential amino acid. By incorporating these foods into their diets, vegan athletes can ensure they are meeting their protein needs.

Digestibility and Bioavailability

Another factor to consider with plant-based proteins is their digestibility and bioavailability. Anti-nutritional factors, such as phytic acid, trypsin inhibitors, oxalates, phenolic compounds, and tannins, can limit the absorption of nutrients from plant-based proteins. However, simple preparation methods, such as cooking, germination, fermentation, soaking, and dehulling, can help reduce these anti-nutritional factors and improve protein bioavailability. Additionally, supplementing with isolated plant-based proteins can help vegan athletes meet their protein requirements, especially during periods of caloric deficit when muscle mass may be at risk.

Research Findings

A study comparing omnivorous and vegan bodybuilders found that while both groups behaved similarly in terms of energy, carbohydrate, and fat intake, the vegan group had lower protein intake, especially during the cutting phase. This highlights the challenge vegan athletes may face in meeting their protein needs while maintaining a caloric deficit. However, with proper nutrition planning and supplementation, it is possible for vegans to build and maintain muscle mass effectively.

Frequently asked questions