Cheat Meals: Necessary Body Shock For Keto Diets?

The keto diet is a low-carb, high-fat eating plan that aims to achieve ketosis—a metabolic state in which the body burns fat instead of carbohydrates for energy. While the keto diet can be effective for weight loss, it is very restrictive, and it's natural to crave forbidden, carby foods. The concept of cheat meals or cheat days has emerged as a way to indulge in these cravings while still adhering to the keto diet. A cheat meal typically involves consuming a single high-carb meal, while a cheat day allows for breaking the diet's rules throughout the day.

The main concern with cheat meals or days on the keto diet is that they can disrupt ketosis. Eating more than 50 grams of carbohydrates can kick the body out of ketosis, and it may take several days to a week to get back into it. Additionally, cheat meals or days can promote unhealthy eating habits and cause blood sugar spikes, temporary water weight gain, and increased cravings. However, some experts argue that allowing yourself the flexibility to cheat occasionally can help you stay motivated and committed to the keto diet in the long run.

To minimize the negative impacts of cheat meals or days on the keto diet, it is recommended to opt for keto-approved cheat meals, have cheat meals instead of cheat days, and space them out generously. It is also important to track your daily food intake, maintain an overall calorie deficit, and resume your low-carb keto lifestyle as soon as possible after a cheat meal or day.

Cheat meals can cause blood sugar spikes, which can lead to an intense sugar crash

When you consume a carb-heavy meal, your blood sugar levels spike, providing an abundance of quick energy. This causes your body to switch back to burning glucose for fuel instead of fat. As a result, ketone production stops, and you may experience a temporary gain in water weight.

The sudden increase in blood sugar can be particularly pronounced on the keto diet, as your body's glucose tolerance has likely decreased. This means you are more sensitive to the effects of sugar and may experience a more intense sugar hit.

Additionally, cheating on the keto diet can lead to cravings for carbs and sugar. By veering away from your keto meal plan and removing your body from a ketogenic state, you may find yourself craving these foods more than before.

It is important to note that the impact of cheat meals on blood sugar spikes and sugar crashes can vary from person to person. Some individuals may be more sensitive to the effects of sugar, especially if they have been strictly adhering to the keto diet for an extended period.

To minimize the negative impact of cheat meals, it is recommended to opt for keto-friendly alternatives, practice portion control, and space out cheat meals generously. Ultimately, the decision to include cheat meals in your keto diet should be based on your individual goals, preferences, and tolerance for carbs.

A single cheat meal can easily exceed your daily carb allowance and take your body out of ketosis

Because 50 grams of carbs is relatively few, a single cheat meal can easily exceed your daily carb allowance and take your body out of ketosis. For example, a medium bagel contains about 50 grams of carbs. Similarly, something as minimal as a banana with 30 grams of carbs, plus two slices of toast with 15 grams of carbs per slice, could qualify as cheating on the keto diet and take you out of ketosis.

If you do choose to indulge in a cheat meal, be mindful of your overall carb intake for the day. For instance, if you enjoy a slice of birthday cake at a friend's celebration, be sure to consume plenty of leafy greens and high-quality protein throughout the day. Additionally, consider testing your ketone levels to determine if you've been kicked out of ketosis.

It's worth noting that the number of carbs needed to kick you out of ketosis can vary depending on individual factors such as your carb tolerance and how long you've been following the keto diet. However, any high-carb meal over your recommended daily carb limit will likely take you out of ketosis.

If you find yourself craving carbs and sweets, opt for keto-friendly alternatives like at-home keto pizza or already-made keto cookies. Ultimately, it's up to you to decide whether the occasional cheat meal is worth it, but it's important to be mindful of the potential impact on your ketosis state and make conscious decisions accordingly.

Cheat meals can cause a temporary gain in water weight

Cheat meals on a keto diet can cause a temporary gain in water weight. This is because a keto diet is a low-carb, moderate protein, and high-fat eating plan. The goal is to restrict carbs to achieve ketosis, a state in which the body burns fat instead of carbs for energy. When you indulge in a cheat meal or day, you are likely to consume more carbs, which can cause your body to retain water. This is because, during ketosis, the body uses up its glycogen stores for energy, and when you eat carbs, your body replenishes these glycogen stores, which can lead to temporary water weight gain.

The amount of water weight gain can vary depending on the number of carbs consumed during the cheat meal or day. Additionally, the time it takes to get back into ketosis after a cheat meal or day can affect the duration of the water weight gain. It is important to note that not everyone will experience the same amount of water weight gain, and individual factors such as metabolism and activity levels can play a role.

To minimize the impact of cheat meals or days on water weight gain, it is recommended to resume your low-carb keto lifestyle as soon as possible. This will help your body get back into ketosis and reduce the duration of water weight gain. Additionally, tracking your carb intake and practicing portion control during cheat meals or days can also help mitigate the effects on water weight gain.

While cheat meals or days can cause temporary water weight gain, it is important to remember that this is usually temporary and should not deter you from your keto diet. The key is to indulge in moderation and make sure that your overall calorie intake and macronutrient ratios are in line with your keto goals.

Cheat meals can increase heart health risks among diabetics

Cheat meals are a common strategy for strict diets, where a person allows themselves to deviate from their usual eating habits for a single meal. While cheat meals can be beneficial for mental health and motivation, they can also have negative consequences, particularly for people with diabetes.

For diabetics, cheat meals can introduce the risk of sudden spikes in blood glucose, which can be dangerous if not managed properly. This can lead to a roller-coaster effect on blood sugar levels, affecting the body's insulin sensitivity and increasing the risk of prolonged elevated glucose levels. This, in turn, can lead to an increased risk of heart health issues, weight gain, and higher cholesterol.

In fact, a small study found that cheat meals on a ketogenic diet may increase heart health risks among diabetics. The study suggested that suddenly reintroducing a high-carb meal to a ketogenic diet may damage blood vessels, which could contribute to elevated risks for a heart attack.

Therefore, while cheat meals can be a strategic way to indulge cravings and maintain mental well-being, they must be approached with caution, especially for those with diabetes. Diabetics should be mindful of their blood sugar levels and work with healthcare professionals to determine the safest approach for their specific needs.

Additionally, it is important to note that the term "cheating" on a diet can have negative connotations and imply self-deception. Instead, reframing these meals as mindful indulgences or strategic breaks from a strict diet can be more empowering and help individuals make informed choices that align with their health goals.

Cheat meals can lead to overeating, which may sabotage weight loss efforts

Cheat meals can be a double-edged sword. On the one hand, they can be a tasty reward for all your hard work, a welcomed break from your diet, and a way to indulge in some of your favorite meals. On the other hand, they can lead to overeating, which may sabotage your weight loss efforts and promote unhealthy eating habits.

The keto diet is highly restrictive, and it's natural to crave forbidden, carby foods, especially if these are your favorite foods. A cheat meal can be something to look forward to and a strategic diet cheat may have some psychological benefits like reduced cravings and the ability to stick to your meal plan better overall. However, it's important to remember that cheat meals can also lead to overeating.

In a study on 248 young adults, cheat meal frequency was positively correlated with overeating episodes. The more we cheat, the more we overeat. Overeating can lead to weight gain and digestive issues, even if you pick healthy cheat foods. A large cheat meal can add 1,000 or more calories to your day, while a whole cheat day will add much more and potentially undo all of your hard work.

If you're going to have a cheat meal, it's important to plan for it. Pick which meals you're going to cheat on and budget some calories and carbs in advance. Keep portions small to prevent overeating. Make it a rare treat and space them out generously. The less you cheat, the less likely you'll form bad eating habits.

Remember, the keto diet is already very restrictive. If you're not careful, cheat meals can easily become cheat days, and cheat days can turn into cheat weeks. Before you know it, you may have fallen off the keto wagon completely. So, if you're going to indulge in a cheat meal, do it mindfully and in moderation.

Frequently asked questions