Keto Diet: Friend Or Foe For Bone Health?

The ketogenic diet has become increasingly popular in recent years, with many people adopting it for weight loss, blood sugar control, and other health reasons. However, there are growing concerns about its potential negative health consequences. While previous studies have linked low-carb, high-fat diets to impaired bone growth, reduced bone mineral content, slower fracture healing, and increased bone loss, particularly in children, recent research suggests that the keto diet may also negatively impact bone health in adults. A 2020 study found that elite race walkers on a ketogenic diet showed early signs of bone loss. Another study from the same year reported that ketogenic diets may cause a steady rate of bone loss, as measured in the spine, due to the acidic nature of ketones. This can lead to a chronic acidotic state, increasing the risk of bone mineral density loss. While human studies on the long-term effects of keto diets on bone health are limited, the available evidence suggests that this type of diet may impair bone health and increase the risk of bone-related issues.

Keto diet and osteoporosis

The ketogenic diet has become an increasingly popular way to lose weight and body fat. It involves eating a high-fat, low-carb, and moderate-protein diet, which causes the body to enter a metabolic state called ketosis, where it burns fat for fuel instead of glucose. While this diet can lead to rapid weight loss, it has also been associated with several negative side effects, including impaired heart health, digestive issues, and nutritional deficiencies. One of the more recent concerns is the potential impact of the keto diet on bone health.

The Link Between Keto and Bone Loss

Several studies have found a link between the keto diet and bone loss. A 2020 study by researchers from the Australian Institute of Sport and Harvard Medical School put 30 elite race walkers on either a ketogenic or high-carb diet for three and a half weeks. The results showed that the keto group had decreased markers for bone metabolism and formation and increased markers of bone breakdown. This indicates that the keto diet may impair the body's ability to build new bone and increase the risk of bone loss.

Another study by the International Society of Sports Nutrition also found that keto diets have an "ergolytic effect," meaning they impair athletic performance. This effect was seen in both high- and low-intensity workouts and was associated with increased feelings of fatigue and mood disturbances during physical activity.

Osteoporosis Risk

While the studies suggest that the keto diet may contribute to bone loss, it is important to note that they do not directly establish a link between the keto diet and osteoporosis. Osteoporosis is a condition characterized by low bone density and a deterioration of bone tissue, which can lead to an increased risk of fractures. While bone loss is a risk factor for osteoporosis, it is not the only factor involved. Other factors that contribute to osteoporosis include age, family history, hormone levels, and lifestyle factors such as smoking and alcohol consumption.

Additionally, the studies on keto and bone health have been relatively small and short-term. More research is needed to fully understand the long-term effects of the keto diet on bone health and the potential risk of developing osteoporosis.

Recommendations

If you are considering the keto diet, it is important to speak with your healthcare provider and a registered dietitian to ensure that you are meeting your nutritional needs and maintaining bone health. A diet that eliminates or severely restricts healthy foods like fruits, whole grains, beans, and starchy vegetables may put you at risk for nutritional deficiencies and bone loss. It is important to prioritize a balanced and varied diet that includes all the essential nutrients your body needs to function optimally.

Ketogenic diet and bone mineral density

The ketogenic diet has become a popular approach to weight loss and management of obesity and body weight. It involves a low-carbohydrate, high-fat regimen, with up to 90% of daily calories coming from fats. While the diet has shown effectiveness in reducing body weight and improving body composition, there are concerns about its potential negative impact on bone health, particularly bone mineral density (BMD).

Impact on Bone Mineral Density

Recent studies have linked the ketogenic diet to potential bone loss. Research suggests that the diet may decrease the body's ability to form new bone and increase bone breakdown, leading to a decline in bone mineral density. This effect was observed in a study involving elite race walkers, where those on a ketogenic diet exhibited early signs of bone loss. However, it is important to note that the long-term effects of the ketogenic diet on bone health are not yet fully understood.

Mechanisms and Risk Factors

The ketogenic diet can lead to metabolic acidosis, which increases the excretion of acid in the urine to maintain pH balance. This process can result in calcium loss from bones, contributing to a decrease in bone mineral density. Additionally, ketogenic diets have been associated with altered vitamin D levels, growth factors, and a high "acid load," all of which can impact BMD.

Comparison with Other Diets

When compared to low-fat diets, such as the Ornish diet, ketogenic diets have been found to impair artery function and negatively impact blood flow to the heart. This can have consequences for heart health, as heart disease is a leading cause of mortality. However, it is important to note that both types of diets can be constructed healthily or unhealthily.

Recommendations and Precautions

While the ketogenic diet may aid in weight loss, it is crucial to consider the potential risks to bone health. Before adopting this diet, individuals should consult with their primary care provider and a nutritionist to ensure they are receiving adequate vitamins and minerals, including calcium and vitamin D, to support bone health. Additionally, combining the ketogenic diet with physical exercise may help mitigate muscle mass loss and improve cardiometabolic health.

Keto diet and bone fractures

The keto diet is a popular, low-carb, high-fat diet that has been adopted by many people looking for quick weight loss. While it has delivered results in that area, it has also been linked to several negative health consequences, including impaired heart health, digestive issues, and nutritional deficiencies.

Bone Health and the Keto Diet

Recent studies have added bone health to the list of possible health issues caused by the keto diet. A 2020 study by the Australian Institute of Sport and Harvard Medical School found that a short-term keto diet could cause bone loss. The study, which put 30 elite race walkers on a ketogenic diet for three and a half weeks, showed a decrease in markers for bone metabolism and formation and an increase in markers of bone breakdown.

Bone Fractures in Children on the Keto Diet

Ketogenic diets have been linked to a steady rate of bone loss, as measured in the spine, and this has particularly affected children. Bone fractures, along with slowed growth and kidney stones, are side effects that have disproportionately affected children placed on keto diets. This is presumed to be because ketones are acidic, and keto diets can put people in a "chronic acidotic state".

Long-term Effects of the Keto Diet on Bone Health

The 2020 study mentioned above is one of the first to test the potential long-term effects of the keto diet on bone health. While previous studies have linked low-carb, high-fat diets with impaired bone growth, reduced bone mineral content, slower fracture healing, and increased bone loss in children, these studies have been conducted over a period of 24 hours to several days.

The authors of the 2020 study noted that their research identified "clear and consistent effects on bone metabolism at rest and in response to exercise" and that further study is warranted, particularly given the long-term health outcomes associated with poor bone health.

Mitigating Bone Health Risks on the Keto Diet

If you are considering the keto diet, it is important to talk to your healthcare provider and a nutritionist to ensure you are receiving the right amounts of vitamins and minerals to maintain bone health. Calcium supplementation during the keto diet has been shown to reduce bone loss.

Ketogenic diet and vitamin D levels

Vitamin D is an important micronutrient involved in several processes. Evidence has shown a strong association between hypovitaminosis D and cardio-metabolic diseases, including obesity. A ketogenic diet has proven to be very effective for weight loss, especially in reducing fat mass while preserving fat-free mass. The aim of this review was to investigate the effect of a ketogenic diet-induced weight loss on vitamin D status in a population of obese adults.

Impact of Ketogenic Diet on Vitamin D Levels:

A review of intervention studies examined the effects of ketogenic diets on vitamin D levels in healthy adults, individuals with type 2 diabetes, and patients with epilepsy. Here's a summary of their key findings:

• Low levels of vitamin D were initially observed in ketogenic diet patients, but supplementation increased vitamin D levels.
• Ketone bodies produced by the ketogenic diet can create an acidic environment, inactivating liver and kidney hydroxylase enzymes and preventing vitamin D conversion into its active form, 1,25(OH)2D.
• Acidosis, caused by ketone bodies, can also reduce vitamin D binding protein, lowering circulating active vitamin D.
• Individuals on ketogenic diets tend to consume more high-fat foods, which can lead to increased vitamin D intake and higher circulating vitamin D levels.
• Fatty acids interact with cholecalciferol during intestinal absorption, and vitamin D supplementation is more effective when paired with high-fat meals.
• Bile acids, increased by fat consumption, activate vitamin D receptors.
• The impact of dietary protein, another macronutrient, on vitamin D metabolism enzymes requires further investigation as current data is lacking.
• Weight loss, a common outcome of ketogenic diets, may have obscured the net effects of the diet on vitamin D levels in the studied populations.
• A comparison between a very-low-calorie ketogenic diet and a Mediterranean diet showed a significant increase in serum 25(OH)D levels with the former, while the latter showed no significant change.
• The ketogenic diet's ability to improve insulin sensitivity may positively impact vitamin D metabolism by reducing FGF23, a hormone that inhibits the conversion of vitamin D into its active form.
• The ketogenic diet's potential to modulate gut microbiota and increase microbial diversity could also influence vitamin D absorption, although more research is needed.
• Genetic variations, particularly in genes related to cholesterol synthesis, hydroxylation, and vitamin D transport, can affect vitamin D levels, suggesting that individual responses to ketogenic diets may vary.

In summary, the ketogenic diet's impact on vitamin D levels is multifaceted and influenced by various factors. While some aspects of the diet may initially lower vitamin D levels, supplementation and long-term dietary changes can lead to increased vitamin D levels, particularly in obese individuals. Further studies are needed to fully understand the complex interactions between the ketogenic diet and vitamin D metabolism, including the role of weight loss and gut microbiota changes.

Keto diet and kidney health

The keto diet is a high-fat, adequate-protein, and low-carbohydrate nutrition plan that stimulates the body to burn fats and use alternative metabolic fuel resources by stimulating endogenous ketone production. This diet has been linked to several health complications, including kidney issues.

Kidney Stones

Ketogenic diets have been associated with kidney stones in children and adults. The high animal fat and protein content of the keto diet generates a high dietary acid load, which can lead to a condition called acidosis. Acidosis increases the risk of kidney stones by lowering urine pH and urinary citrate levels while increasing urinary calcium excretion.

Chronic Kidney Disease

The keto diet has also been linked to an increased risk of developing chronic kidney disease (CKD). The high protein content of the diet leads to hyperfiltration, where the kidney must work harder due to increased blood flow to the filtrating unit, which contributes to the progression of CKD. Additionally, the keto diet can worsen metabolic acidosis, a common complication of CKD, which in turn affects bone and muscle health.

Renal Impairment

There have been reports of renal impairment and decreased bone density in individuals following a ketogenic diet. A case study described a 36-year-old female with no underlying renal problems who developed acute renal injury after starting a ketogenic diet. She presented with symptoms of persistent nausea, vomiting, fatigue, and malaise. Laboratory investigations showed elevated creatinine and hypokalemia, and she was diagnosed with acute kidney injury induced by the ketogenic diet.

Alternative Diets for Kidney Health

For individuals with or at risk for kidney disease, it is important to consult with a physician or nephrologist to determine appropriate dietary modifications. A healthy lifestyle with balanced and portioned meals that include adequate amounts of protein, carbohydrates, fat, fiber, and other micronutrients is recommended for weight management. Restricting salt intake, ensuring proper hydration, and paying attention to potassium and phosphorus intake can also help alleviate stress on the kidneys.

Frequently asked questions