Keto Vs Low-Calorie Diet: Why Choose Keto?

The ketogenic (keto) diet and the low-calorie diet are two popular methods for weight loss. The keto diet is a low-carb, high-fat eating plan that shifts the body's energy source from carbohydrates to fats, while a low-calorie diet focuses on consuming fewer calories than the body needs. The keto diet restricts carbohydrates to induce ketosis, a state where fat becomes the primary fuel source, while a low-calorie diet promotes gradual weight loss by creating a negative energy balance. The keto diet may lead to quicker initial weight loss, but it is more restrictive and may be challenging to maintain in the long term. On the other hand, a low-calorie diet offers flexibility and a wide range of food choices, making it easier to sustain. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual goals, lifestyle, and health considerations.

Keto may be better for those with type 2 diabetes or non-alcoholic fatty liver disease

Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) is a major cause of chronic liver disease, affecting an estimated 25% of the population in most Western countries. It is characterised by hepatic fat accumulation and the potential development of inflammation, fibrosis, and cancer. Insulin resistance and high insulin levels are known to promote excessive storage of liver fat, and NAFLD has been linked to an increased risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

A ketogenic diet can be beneficial for people with NAFLD because it can decrease insulin levels, suppress appetite, promote weight loss, and improve heart health markers. Studies have shown that a low-carb diet can reduce liver fat and abdominal fat, and may even reverse the disease process.

For people with type 2 diabetes, a ketogenic diet may improve blood glucose (sugar) levels while also reducing the need for insulin. The diet can help the body use fat for energy instead of carbohydrates or glucose, which can ease diabetes symptoms. Research has shown that a ketogenic diet can lead to more significant improvements in blood sugar control, A1C, weight loss, and discontinued insulin requirements than other diets.

In summary, a ketogenic diet may be better for those with type 2 diabetes or non-alcoholic fatty liver disease because it can help to manage insulin levels and improve related health markers.

Keto may lead to quicker initial weight loss

The keto diet is a low-carb, high-fat eating plan that shifts the body's energy source from carbohydrates to fats. By significantly reducing carbs, the body enters a state called ketosis, where fat becomes the primary fuel source. This metabolic state promotes fat burning and helps reduce appetite.

Initial Weight Loss

Research suggests that the keto diet can aid initial weight loss due to reduced insulin and appetite suppression. When following a keto diet, carbs are typically reduced to 30-50 grams per day, which is a more restrictive approach than a low-calorie diet. This drastic reduction in carbs can lead to a quicker initial loss of weight, especially water weight.

Ketosis and Weight Loss

Ketosis is a metabolic state where the body breaks down fat into molecules called ketones, which are used for energy instead of glucose. To reach and maintain ketosis, a person on a keto diet must drastically reduce their carbohydrate intake, typically to less than 50 grams per day. This can be challenging as it involves excluding grains, sugars, high-carb fruits, starchy vegetables, and legumes.

Calorie Deficit and Weight Loss

In comparison, a calorie deficit diet, which is another popular approach to weight loss, focuses on consuming fewer calories than the body burns. This approach allows for more flexibility and balanced food intake across all macronutrients. However, it may not lead to as rapid initial weight loss as the keto diet.

Considerations

While the keto diet may lead to quicker initial weight loss, it is important to consider the challenges and potential risks associated with this restrictive diet. Maintaining ketosis requires strict adherence, and long-term data on the keto diet is limited. Additionally, the keto diet may lead to potential nutrient deficiencies and impact lipid levels due to the restriction of essential fruits, whole grains, and fiber.

Furthermore, the keto diet is associated with an increased risk of "keto flu," which includes symptoms such as fatigue, mental fogginess, and irritability. It is also important to consult a healthcare provider before starting any diet, as individual health considerations and goals should be taken into account when deciding between a keto and a low-calorie diet.

A low-calorie diet is more flexible and less restrictive

A low-calorie diet does not restrict specific food groups, making it more flexible than a keto diet. It allows for a wider range of food choices, including nutrient-dense, low-calorie options such as lean proteins, whole grains, leafy greens, low-sugar fruits, healthy fats, and high-fiber foods. This variety ensures a balanced intake of essential nutrients and can be tailored to suit different dietary preferences and cultural cuisines.

The flexibility of a low-calorie diet also extends to its ability to be combined with other dietary approaches. For example, it can be paired with intermittent fasting, where eating times are restricted, or with strength and aerobic exercises, to further enhance weight loss and support muscle retention. This adaptability makes it a sustainable option for those with varying lifestyles, dietary restrictions, or personal goals.

In contrast, a keto diet is more restrictive and may not be suitable for everyone due to its limited food choices. It eliminates entire food groups, including grains, rice, starchy vegetables, legumes, most fruits, and processed snacks. This restriction can make social situations and dining out challenging, as it requires careful planning and consideration to stay within the strict carbohydrate limits.

While a keto diet may offer faster initial weight loss, a low-calorie diet is often more effective for long-term weight management due to its flexibility and adaptability. The variety of food choices in a low-calorie diet can make it easier to stick to and incorporate into daily life, increasing the likelihood of sustainable weight loss results.

Ultimately, the decision between a keto and a low-calorie diet depends on individual goals, lifestyle, and health considerations. A low-calorie diet offers flexibility, variety, and a balanced approach to weight loss, making it a sustainable and adaptable option for those seeking a less restrictive dietary plan.

Keto may be more difficult to stick to long-term

The keto diet is a very low-carb, high-fat diet that can be challenging to stick to over time due to various factors. Firstly, it is highly restrictive, limiting entire food groups such as grains, legumes, dairy, fruits, starchy vegetables, and processed snacks. This restriction can make it challenging to find suitable meal options, especially when eating out or travelling. The diet also requires careful planning and preparation to ensure one stays within the strict carb limits, which can be time-consuming and inconvenient.

Secondly, the keto diet can lead to potential nutrient deficiencies, as it eliminates many foods that are good sources of essential micronutrients. These include whole grains, fruits, and some vegetables, which are rich in vitamins, minerals, and fibre. Fibre is particularly important for digestive health, weight maintenance, and lowering the risk of cardiovascular disease. By cutting out these food groups, individuals on the keto diet may miss out on these essential nutrients, potentially impacting their overall health and well-being.

Additionally, the keto diet can be difficult to maintain due to its potential side effects. One well-known side effect is the "keto flu," which includes symptoms such as dizziness, nausea, and fatigue. These symptoms can be off-putting and make it hard for people to continue with the diet. Other possible side effects include constipation, fuzzy thinking, and mood swings, which can further deter people from sticking to the diet long-term.

Furthermore, the keto diet may not be suitable for everyone, especially those with certain medical conditions. It is important for individuals to consult with their healthcare providers before starting the keto diet, as it could exacerbate existing liver or kidney problems. The high-fat content of the diet, including saturated fats, can also be a concern for those at risk of heart disease or with high cholesterol. These potential health risks may deter people from continuing the keto diet over an extended period.

While the keto diet may offer initial weight loss and health benefits, it is important to consider the challenges of maintaining this diet long-term. The restrictive nature of the diet, potential nutrient deficiencies, side effects, and health risks can make it more difficult for individuals to stick to the keto diet over an extended period.

A low-calorie diet may be easier to maintain

Flexibility and Food Choices:

• A low-calorie diet allows for a more balanced and flexible approach to eating. It does not restrict entire food groups, giving you the freedom to choose from a variety of foods across all macronutrients. This makes it easier to stick to the diet and adapt it to your personal preferences and lifestyle.
• With a keto diet, you have to be more restrictive with your food choices. It limits the intake of carbohydrates, including grains, legumes, starchy vegetables, and certain fruits. This restriction can make it challenging to find suitable meal options, especially when eating out or travelling.

Sustainability:

• A low-calorie diet is often more sustainable in the long term. It does not require strict adherence to a specific macronutrient ratio like the keto diet, which demands a careful balance of high fat, moderate protein, and very low carb intake. This flexibility makes it easier to maintain a low-calorie diet over an extended period.
• The keto diet's restrictive nature can lead to potential nutrient deficiencies and impact lipid levels due to the limited consumption of essential fruits, whole grains, and fiber. It may be challenging to follow for an extended period, especially if you crave variety in your meals.

Individual Goals and Preferences:

• The best diet depends on individual goals, lifestyle, and personal preferences. Some people may find a low-calorie diet more manageable because it allows for favourite foods in moderation, making it easier to stick to in the long run.
• In contrast, the keto diet may be better suited for those seeking rapid initial weight loss or managing specific conditions like Type 2 diabetes or non-alcoholic fatty liver disease. However, it requires strict adherence to maintain ketosis, and the long-term effects of the keto diet are still being studied.

Health Considerations:

• A low-calorie diet can be adapted to include a variety of nutritious, whole foods that provide essential vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. This ensures you get adequate nutrition while maintaining a calorie deficit, which is crucial for overall health and well-being.
• The keto diet, with its high-fat requirement, can be challenging to follow if you have certain health conditions. It may impact cholesterol levels and is associated with an increased risk of "bad" LDL cholesterol, which is a risk factor for heart disease. Consult with your healthcare provider to ensure the diet you choose aligns with your health goals and does not exacerbate any existing conditions.

Frequently asked questions