Atkins Vs. Keto: Why Atkins Fails The Keto Test

The Atkins and keto diets are two of the best-known low-carb diets. Both diets aim to promote weight loss and improve health by limiting carb intake. However, there are some key differences between the two. The keto diet is much more restrictive than the Atkins diet, which may make it difficult to stick to. The Atkins diet is less restrictive and may be more sustainable in the long run because it allows for a gradual increase in carb intake and a wider variety of foods. The keto diet, on the other hand, requires the body to stay in ketosis by extremely limiting carb intake, which can be challenging and may not be healthy in the long term.

Atkins is less restrictive than keto

The Atkins and keto diets are both low-carb diets that aim to promote weight loss and improve overall health. However, one of the key differences between the two is that Atkins is less restrictive than keto.

The keto diet is very restrictive and is typically done under strict medical supervision. It requires a drastic reduction in carbohydrates, with a limit of 20-50 grams of net carbs per day to maintain ketosis. In addition, the keto diet restricts protein intake to 20% of daily calories. This can be challenging, as it requires careful monitoring of food choices and macronutrient targets.

On the other hand, the Atkins diet is more flexible and allows for a wider variety of foods. While it also involves a significant reduction in carbohydrates, the Atkins diet is broken down into four phases that gradually increase the daily carb allowance. During the introductory phase, Atkins restricts carbs to 20-25 grams of net carbs per day. In phase 2, this increases to 25-50 grams, and in phase 3, it raises to 50-80 grams. Finally, in the maintenance phase (phase 4), people can consume up to 80-100 grams of carbs per day.

Unlike keto, Atkins does not cap protein intake, allowing for up to 30% of calories from protein. This makes it easier to incorporate a greater variety of foods, such as more fruits, vegetables, and even some grains. The gradual increase in carb intake and flexibility with protein sources makes Atkins less restrictive than keto.

In addition to being less restrictive, Atkins may be easier to stick to in the long run. The keto diet can be challenging to maintain due to its strict rules and restrictive nature. The Atkins diet, on the other hand, allows for a gradual reintroduction of carbohydrates and has been linked to fewer side effects.

Overall, while both diets can be effective for weight loss and improving health, Atkins provides a less restrictive approach that may be more sustainable for some individuals.

Atkins is more sustainable long-term

The Atkins diet is more sustainable long-term than the keto diet. While the keto diet is extremely restrictive and may be difficult to stick to, the Atkins diet is less restrictive and allows for a wider variety of foods. The keto diet is a very low-carb, moderate-protein, high-fat diet plan that requires a drastic reduction in carbs, including sweets, sugary drinks, breads, grains, fruits, legumes, and potatoes. The Atkins diet, on the other hand, is a low-carb, moderate-protein, and high-fat diet that is broken down into four phases, with the carb allowance gradually increasing in each phase.

The first phase of the Atkins diet is similar to the keto diet, as it restricts net carbs to 20-25 grams per day, which is likely to cause the body to enter ketosis and start burning fat. However, in the second phase, the Atkins diet prescribes a carbohydrate intake of 25-50 grams per day, which may also be low enough for many individuals to enter ketosis. As you approach your goal weight and advance through the phases of the Atkins diet, your daily net carb allowance increases, allowing you to incorporate a greater variety of foods.

The keto diet, on the other hand, requires your body to stay in ketosis by extremely limiting your carb intake. This can be challenging, especially in the long term. The Atkins diet is more flexible and allows for a gradual increase in carb intake, which makes it easier to stick to and less likely to lead to binge eating or falling off the diet.

Additionally, the Atkins diet does not require you to monitor ketone levels, which can be challenging and costly. The keto diet may also lead to nutrient deficiencies if you do not pay careful attention to your diet quality. The Atkins diet, with its gradual increase in carb intake, allows for a greater variety of foods and makes it easier to meet your nutritional needs.

While there is limited evidence on the long-term safety or effectiveness of the keto diet, the Atkins diet has been around for decades and has been shown to be a safe and effective way to lose weight and improve overall health. The Atkins diet is a more realistic and sustainable approach to a keto diet, offering a clear and structured plan with defined phases to suit a variety of goals.

Atkins allows for more protein

While the keto diet restricts protein to 20% of your daily calories, the Atkins diet allows for up to 30% of calories from protein, depending on the phase. Atkins is not considered a high-protein diet, but an optimal protein diet.

The RDA recommendation for protein is .36 grams per pound of body weight for adults per day. However, research indicates that adults may benefit from higher amounts of protein, especially when losing weight. On the Atkins diet, it is recommended to consume two to four 4- to 6-ounce servings of protein per day. This is based on your gender and height and will fill you up after your meal but leave you hungry in time for your next meal.

Protein helps you lose weight for several reasons. Firstly, it keeps you fuller for longer. Secondly, it stabilises your blood sugar levels, reducing cravings for sweets or salt. Thirdly, eating protein boosts your metabolic rate and helps you burn more calories. One study showed that healthy, young women experienced 100% higher thermogenesis (calorie burning) after eating protein meals, even two and a half hours later than when they ate a high-carbohydrate meal.

Protein is a crucial component of the Atkins diet. When combined with healthy dietary fat, it makes it easier to cut your carbohydrate intake without feeling like you're missing out.

Atkins doesn't require ketosis monitoring

The Atkins diet is a low-carb, high-fat diet that was introduced in 1972 by cardiologist Robert Atkins. It has since evolved to offer a variety of plans, but the original version, now called Atkins 20, is still the most popular. Atkins is broken down into four phases, which are based on your daily allowance of net carbs.

The first phase, or the induction phase, is the most restrictive, allowing for just 20-25 grams of net carbs per day until you are 15 pounds from your goal weight. Phase 2 increases the daily carb allotment to 25-50 grams of net carbs per day until you are 10 pounds from your goal weight. During Phase 3, your net carb allowance is raised to 50-80 grams per day until you have met your goal weight and maintained it for one month. The final phase is a maintenance phase, allowing for 80-100 grams of net carbs per day for ongoing weight maintenance.

While the Atkins diet is a type of ketogenic diet, it does not require the same level of ketosis monitoring as the classic keto diet. The keto diet is extremely restrictive and may be difficult to stick to, as it involves limiting your protein intake to 20% of calories while maintaining a very low carb and very high fat intake. Some people may also feel the need to monitor their ketone levels, which can be challenging and costly.

In contrast, the Atkins diet is more flexible and less restrictive. It allows for a higher protein intake, with up to 30% of calories coming from protein, and does not require strict monitoring of ketone levels. The Atkins diet involves gradually increasing your carb intake, which will eventually kick your body out of ketosis. This flexible carb limit allows for a wider variety of foods, including more fruits, vegetables, and even some grains.

Overall, the Atkins diet is a less restrictive approach to the keto diet, as you do not have to monitor ketones or stick to certain macronutrient targets to stay in ketosis. It is important to note that most people can reap the benefits of low-carb diets without being in ketosis, and moderate carb restriction is usually sufficient for most individuals.

Atkins has fewer side effects than keto

The Atkins and keto diets are both low-carb diets that aim to promote weight loss and improve overall health. However, there are some key differences between the two, including the amount of protein allowed and the level of restrictiveness. These differences can lead to varying side effects for those following the diets.

The keto diet is generally considered more restrictive than the Atkins diet. Keto places a strong emphasis on carb elimination and restricts protein sources, as the body may break down proteins into glucose for energy. In contrast, the Atkins diet allows for a moderate protein intake and gradually reintroduces carbs, eventually kicking the body out of ketosis. This flexible carb limit allows for a wider variety of foods, including more fruits, vegetables, and even some grains.

Because of its restrictiveness, the keto diet is associated with several side effects, including "keto flu," which can include symptoms such as headache, fatigue, and nausea due to the loss of water weight. The keto diet can also lead to deficiencies in essential vitamins, minerals, fiber, and water-soluble vitamins. Additionally, long-term adherence to keto has been linked to an increased risk of heart disease and kidney stones.

On the other hand, the Atkins diet has been linked to fewer side effects. Its less restrictive nature makes it easier to stick to and allows for a more balanced intake of nutrients. While any diet that involves ketosis can cause adverse effects such as keto breath, keto skin rashes, and keto flu, the gradual increase in carb intake on the Atkins diet may help mitigate these side effects to some extent.

Overall, while both the keto and Atkins diets have their benefits and drawbacks, Atkins has fewer side effects due to its less restrictive nature and gradual reintroduction of carbohydrates.

Frequently asked questions