Keto And Pcos: A Dangerous Mix?

The ketogenic diet is popular among women with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS). PCOS is a hormonal disorder that affects the ovaries and ovulation in women of childbearing age. It is associated with high levels of male hormones, irregular or skipped periods, and cysts in the ovaries. While the keto diet may be effective in treating PCOS, there are concerns about its long-term impact. Some argue that the keto diet may be too restrictive and stressful to follow, potentially leading to increased stress hormones and negative impacts on gut health and hormonal balance. There are also concerns about nutrient deficiencies and the lack of long-term research on the effects of keto on PCOS.

Keto may negatively impact the gut microbiome

The gut microbiome plays a crucial role in health and disease. A healthy gut contributes to the digestion and absorption of nutrients from food, immune function, the regulation of inflammation, the production of essential vitamins, hormonal balance, insulin sensitivity, and mental health.

Research has shown that women with PCOS generally have less diverse gut bacteria than women without PCOS, which may contribute to PCOS symptoms and the progression of the disease. Higher levels of androgens are associated with lower gut bacterial diversity in women with PCOS.

One of the best ways to support gut health is to eat a diet rich in fibre, which helps improve and protect healthy bacteria levels in the gut. Fibre is also essential for promoting regular bowel movements, a primary way that the body eliminates excess hormones and toxins.

However, the keto diet restricts many fibre-rich foods, including fruits, starchy vegetables, and legumes, which may negatively impact the gut microbiome in individuals with PCOS.

Experienced clinicians have observed gut dysbiosis in patients following a ketogenic diet and speculate that this could allow pathogens to colonize the gut. Recent evidence has also linked a diet low in fermentable fibres to inflammatory diseases like PCOS.

Therefore, the keto diet's restrictive nature and limited fibre intake may negatively impact the gut microbiome, potentially exacerbating PCOS symptoms.

The Importance of Gut Health for PCOS Management

Supporting gut health is essential for effectively treating PCOS. A healthy gut contributes to hormonal balance, insulin sensitivity, and the regulation of inflammation, all of which are crucial factors in managing PCOS.

By improving the diversity and health of the gut microbiome, individuals with PCOS may be able to alleviate their symptoms and improve their overall health.

The Impact of Keto on Gut Health

The keto diet's restriction of fibre-rich foods can disrupt the delicate balance of the gut microbiome. This disruption can have far-reaching consequences, as a healthy gut is essential for overall health and disease management.

The gut microbiome plays a vital role in nutrient absorption, immune function, and hormone regulation. By restricting the intake of fibre-rich foods, the keto diet may negatively impact the diversity and health of the gut microbiome, potentially leading to gut dysbiosis.

The Link Between Gut Health and PCOS

The gut-hormone connection is especially important for individuals with PCOS. A healthy gut contributes to hormonal balance and insulin sensitivity, which are often impaired in PCOS.

By supporting gut health through a fibre-rich diet, individuals with PCOS may be able to improve their overall health and manage their PCOS symptoms more effectively.

Alternative Approaches to Support Gut Health in PCOS

While the keto diet may not be optimal for supporting gut health in PCOS, other dietary approaches can be beneficial.

A holistic PCOS diet that includes a variety of fibre-rich foods, such as fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and legumes, can promote a healthy gut microbiome while also addressing insulin resistance.

Additionally, supplementing with prebiotics and probiotics can help support the growth of beneficial bacteria in the gut, further improving gut health and overall wellbeing.

In conclusion, while the keto diet may offer some benefits for individuals with PCOS, its restrictive nature and potential negative impact on the gut microbiome should be carefully considered. Prioritizing gut health through a well-rounded, fibre-rich diet may be a more sustainable and effective approach to managing PCOS symptoms and improving overall health.

Keto may harm hormones

While the keto diet may be beneficial for PCOS in the short term, there are some concerns about its long-term effects on hormones. Here are some ways in which keto may harm hormones:

Stress on the Body

The adrenal glands that regulate stress hormones are sensitive to changes in energy intake. Restricting carbohydrate intake is a form of stress on the body and can result in increased cortisol levels, the body's main stress hormone. High cortisol levels can worsen PCOS symptoms, including increased blood sugar levels, greater insulin resistance, increased inflammation, and higher levels of abdominal fat. Studies have shown that cortisol regulation is already impaired in women with PCOS, and a low-carb diet that adds stress to the body could make this worse.

Impact on the Gut Microbiome

The gut microbiome plays a crucial role in health and disease. A diverse species-rich gut microbe community is beneficial, while low bacterial diversity is harmful. Women with PCOS generally have less diverse gut bacteria, which may contribute to PCOS symptoms and progression. The keto diet may negatively impact the gut microbiome by restricting fibre-rich foods that are important for feeding healthy gut bacteria and promoting regular bowel movements.

Irregular Menstrual Cycles

Research has shown that overly restricting carbohydrates may result in irregular menstrual cycles or the complete loss of a period. This is particularly concerning for women with PCOS who already experience menstrual irregularities. By disrupting hormones, the keto diet may further exacerbate menstrual irregularities in this vulnerable population.

Negative Impact on Thyroid Hormones

Restricting calories or carbohydrates too severely may negatively impact thyroid hormones. Studies show that when calorie or carbohydrate intake is too low, T3 levels can drop, leading to symptoms such as weight gain, fatigue, poor concentration, and mood disturbances. This can be detrimental to overall health and well-being.

Long-Term Weight Gain

While the keto diet may lead to initial weight loss, the long-term impact may be different. The keto diet can lead to higher cortisol levels, which, if not managed, can result in changes in appetite, weight gain, and an increased risk of metabolic syndrome. Additionally, because the keto diet is so restrictive, it may be challenging to follow long-term, leading to weight regain and yo-yo dieting, which is linked to an increased risk of obesity.

Keto may lead to weight gain

The keto diet is incredibly restrictive, and as such, it may be difficult for many people to stick to long-term. Because of this, any weight that is lost while on the diet is likely to be regained once the diet is stopped. This can lead to yo-yo dieting, which is linked to a greater risk of obesity. Restrictive dieting also contributes to a variety of metabolic changes in the body, including greater fat storage, loss of lean body mass, and a reduced resting metabolic rate.

Additionally, the keto diet can lead to higher cortisol levels, which, if not managed, can lead to changes in appetite, weight gain, and an increased risk of developing metabolic syndrome. Metabolic syndrome is a collection of symptoms that raises the risk for heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

The keto diet is not a sustainable or preferred diet plan for most people. It is incredibly stressful and socially isolating due to its restrictive nature. It takes a lot of effort to count and micromanage every piece of food that goes into your body.

Furthermore, the keto diet lacks important micronutrients. Carbohydrates that are restricted on a keto diet provide essential micronutrients, which are crucial for normal bodily functioning. If you are following a ketogenic diet, you are likely missing out on crucial vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants from foods like colourful fruits and vegetables that have anti-inflammatory and protective effects on the body.

Finally, while the keto diet may lead to initial weight loss, this may be the result of a loss of lean body mass, which includes muscle and can thus negatively impact metabolism.

Keto lacks important micronutrients

Micronutrients are essential for the body's proper functioning and survival. They are needed for various processes, including vision, growth, development, immune system support, DNA production, red blood cell formation, bone health, nerve function, energy production, and more.

The keto diet, by eliminating whole food groups, including starchy vegetables, grains, and most fruits, can make it challenging to obtain certain micronutrients. This is particularly true for those who are used to getting their nutrients primarily from high-carb foods.

Vitamins:

• Vitamin C: Typically found in fruits (especially citrus fruits) and vegetables (bell peppers and tomatoes). Vitamin C is water-soluble and necessary for healing and protein synthesis. It also has antioxidant properties.
• Folate: A water-soluble B-vitamin needed for DNA production, red blood cell formation, and preventing neural tube defects. Found in dark green leafy vegetables, fruits, nuts, beans, seafood, eggs, dairy products, meat, poultry, and grains.
• Vitamin D: A fat-soluble vitamin required for calcium absorption, bone formation, and immune function. Good sources include fatty fish, fish oils, fortified milk/milk substitutes, and sun exposure.

Minerals:

• Magnesium: Plays a role in blood pressure control, muscle contraction, nerve function, energy production, and bone development. Also, helps with insulin sensitivity. Found in beans, whole grains, green leafy vegetables, nuts, seeds, milk, yogurt, and some fish.
• Potassium: Critical for nerve and muscle function, cell function, fluid balance, and blood pressure control. Potassium can be lost in the urine during the first phase of ketosis. Good sources include fruits, vegetables, milk, yogurt, beans, meat, poultry, and fish.
• Calcium: The most abundant mineral in the human body, important for bone health, blood vessel health, nerve function, and muscle function. Found in milk, cheese, yogurt, fortified dairy substitutes, tofu made with calcium, sardines with bones, and leafy green vegetables.

To ensure adequate intake of these micronutrients while on a keto diet, it is recommended to include a variety of keto-friendly whole foods, such as nuts, seeds, and non-starchy vegetables. Supplementation may also be necessary in some cases, especially for those who are older, have difficulty accessing nutritious foods, or have conditions affecting nutrient absorption.

Keto may be psychologically unhealthy

The ketogenic diet can be psychologically unhealthy for people with PCOS. Here are some reasons why:

Stress and Social Isolation

The keto diet can be stressful and socially isolating due to its restrictive nature. It requires a lot of effort to count and monitor every piece of food that goes into your body. This can be exhausting and overwhelming, especially for those with busy lives. The social aspect of food is also important to consider, as you may have to miss out on fun foods and social events that involve eating.

Eating Disorders

The keto diet may induce disordered eating in at-risk PCOS patients. Restrictive diets can further deteriorate an already tenuous relationship with food, especially if individuals are also dealing with anxiety or depression. PCOS patients are already at a higher risk of developing eating disorders, with disordered eating affecting them roughly five times more than the general population.

Hormonal Impact

The adrenal glands that regulate stress hormones are very sensitive to changes in energy intake. Overly restricting carbohydrates can lead to increased cortisol levels, one of the body's main stress hormones. High cortisol levels can worsen PCOS symptoms, including increased blood sugar, greater insulin resistance, increased inflammation, and higher levels of abdominal fat. Studies have shown that cortisol regulation is already impaired in women with PCOS, and a low-carb diet that adds stress to the body could make this worse.

Weight Gain and Yo-Yo Dieting

The long-term impact of elevated cortisol levels from a restrictive diet may lead to weight gain and yo-yo dieting. As mentioned, elevated cortisol levels can lead to changes in appetite and weight gain. Yo-yo dieting, or weight cycling, is linked to an increased risk of obesity. Restrictive dieting also contributes to metabolic changes, such as greater fat storage, loss of lean body mass, and a reduced resting metabolic rate.

Frequently asked questions