Whey Protein And Keto: Friends Or Foes?

Whey protein can knock you out of ketosis, but only temporarily. This is due to a temporary insulin spike, which will peak at around 15 minutes after you’ve consumed your protein shake. However, your ketone levels will typically return to normal after approximately 30 minutes. You can somewhat control the spike in insulin by consuming fats with your whey. You can switch to casein protein. This provides a slower release of amino acids than whey, so your insulin levels won’t be affected as much.

Whey protein can cause a temporary insulin spike, which inhibits ketosis

With that being said, the spike in insulin levels caused by whey protein will only be temporary. In fact, once the insulin spike has reached its peak at the 15-minute mark, it will then begin to taper off. So, by around 30 minutes after whey protein ingestion, your ketone levels will generally go back to normal.

You can somewhat control the spike in insulin by consuming fats with your whey. You can switch to casein protein. This provides a slower release of amino acids than whey, so your insulin levels won’t be affected as much.

The more rapidly digestible the protein, the more insulin is released

The rate at which a protein is digested and absorbed by the body determines the amount of insulin released. The faster a protein is digested, the more insulin is released.

Proteins are made up of amino acids, which can be converted to glucose and trigger an insulin response. Insulin is a hormone that prompts cells to absorb blood sugar for energy or storage. When there is insufficient insulin, the body is unable to use sugar for energy. Instead, it uses fat for energy, producing ketones and prompting ketosis.

Whey protein is rapidly digested by the body and causes an almost instantaneous spike in insulin levels. This spike typically reaches its peak around 15 minutes after consumption and tapers off after the 30-minute mark.

The addition of fat to a whey protein shake can help to reduce the insulin spike. This is because whey protein is typically consumed in isolation without any fat. By adding fat to the shake, the outcome can be changed, allowing the body to still absorb the essential amino acids without experiencing a spike in insulin levels.

The rate at which a protein is digested is dependent on its physical shape and the ease with which peptide bonds can be hydrolyzed. Globular proteins, which are coiled and tightly packed, are comparatively soluble and more digestible. In contrast, fibrous proteins with long polypeptide chains, such as collagen, keratin, and elastin, are relatively insoluble and less digestible.

The digestibility of a protein is also influenced by the presence of additional dietary factors, such as trypsin inhibitors, which can be found in certain foods like navy beans and soybeans. Heating these foods can inactivate trypsin inhibitors, improving protein digestibility. However, strong heating, especially in the presence of carbohydrates or oxidized lipids, may make the protein resistant to enzymatic hydrolysis.

The rate of digestion is an important factor in determining the insulin response to a protein source. The faster a protein is digested and absorbed, the greater the insulin response. Therefore, the more rapidly digestible the protein, the more insulin is released by the body.

Gluconeogenesis is a process where the body turns protein into glucose

Gluconeogenesis is a metabolic pathway that results in the generation of glucose from non-carbohydrate carbon substrates, such as pyruvate, lactate, glycerol, and glucogenic amino acids. Gluconeogenesis is a process that occurs mainly in the liver, with a minor contribution from the kidney. It is a vital process that ensures an uninterrupted supply of glucose to the brain and allows the body to survive during starvation.

The body's ability to synthesise glucose is dependent on the supply of gluconeogenic substrates from peripheral tissues. The principal substrates for gluconeogenesis are lactate, alanine, and glutamine. During prolonged fasting, when there is marked lipolysis, glycerol becomes a major substrate. Gluconeogenesis is a cytosolic process that occurs in the liver and, to a lesser extent, the kidneys. It involves the conversion of pyruvate, derived from the transamination of the amino acid alanine, into glucose.

The process of gluconeogenesis is not simply a reversal of glycolysis, as several reactions of glycolysis are irreversible. However, many of the steps are shared by both pathways. Gluconeogenesis is regulated by hormones such as glucagon, epinephrine, and glucocorticoids.

Whey protein can cause a temporary spike in insulin levels, which may inhibit ketosis. This is due to the rapid absorption of whey protein by the body, which can result in an exaggerated insulin response. However, the impact of whey protein on ketosis is not clear-cut, and some individuals may not experience any negative effects. The addition of fats to a whey protein shake may help to mitigate the insulin spike and maintain ketosis.

While whey protein can potentially disrupt ketosis, it is important to note that the body's ability to remain in ketosis depends on various factors, including the overall diet, activity level, and individual metabolism.

The body will still use fat for energy, even with high amounts of protein

Whey protein can knock you out of ketosis, but this is not necessarily a bad thing. Ketosis is when your body is low on blood sugar, and your liver is forced to burn stored body fat to produce ketones for energy. Insulin is released when blood sugar levels rise, and insulin allows your cells to use and store blood sugar for energy. The more carbohydrates you eat, the higher your blood sugar and insulin levels.

Consuming whey protein can cause a temporary spike in insulin levels, which will typically peak around 15 minutes after you've consumed your protein shake, and your ketone levels will generally go back to normal after approximately 30 minutes. This is because the body can turn excess protein into glucose through the process of gluconeogenesis. However, there is no scientific evidence that consuming too much protein will knock you out of ketosis. In fact, there is a study that suggests that even with high amounts of protein, your body will still limit the use of glucose so that gluconeogenesis won't be necessary.

If you want to limit the impact of an insulin spike, you can add fats to your protein shake, or change your protein powder completely. Casein protein provides a much slower release of amino acids than whey, so your insulin levels won't be affected as much.

Casein protein is a better choice than whey protein for keto dieters

Whey protein is a popular supplement for those looking to increase their protein intake, especially when trying to build muscle. However, for those on a keto diet, whey protein may not be the best option. This is because whey protein can cause a temporary spike in insulin levels, which inhibits ketosis. While this spike is short-lived and ketone levels typically return to normal within 30 minutes, there is a better alternative—casein protein.

Casein protein is also derived from milk but provides a much slower release of amino acids than whey. While whey protein is typically absorbed within 30-60 minutes, casein can take up to 3-4 hours. This slower release means casein has a lesser impact on glucose and insulin responses in the body. Some studies even suggest that casein may aid sleep, making it an ideal pre-bedtime snack for those on a keto diet.

Casein is also a more versatile ingredient than whey. Its ability to increase texture and thicken means it can be used to make high-protein treats such as pudding, pancakes, or ice cream. For those who prefer to get their protein from whole food sources, cottage cheese is a good source of casein and can be easily incorporated into meals.

While whey protein is a convenient and tasty way to increase your protein intake, for keto dieters, casein is the better choice. It won't disrupt ketosis and may even offer additional benefits such as improved sleep. So, if you're looking to stay in ketosis and build muscle, casein protein is the way to go.

Frequently asked questions