Carb Ups: Friend Or Foe In Keto Adaptation?

Carb ups, or cyclical ketosis, is a strategy where individuals on a ketogenic diet increase their carbohydrate intake for a meal, a day, or a couple of days. This practice is intended to bring about several benefits, such as breaking a weight loss plateau, improving hormonal balance, and enhancing muscle growth. However, it is important to note that carb ups are not suitable for everyone, especially beginners, as they can lead to keto flu and restart the fat adaptation process. To prevent this, it is recommended to wait until the body has adapted to burning fat, usually after 4-6 weeks, before attempting carb ups.

Carb ups can help with weight loss

Carb ups can be an effective strategy for those on a ketogenic diet to help with weight loss. Carb ups, also known as "carb re-feeds" or "cyclical ketosis", involve periodically increasing carb intake and reducing fat intake for a meal, a day, or a couple of days. This strategy can be beneficial for several reasons:

First, carb ups can help to break a weight loss stall. By shocking the body with a flipped eating pattern, carb ups can prevent the body from adapting to a low-calorie diet and help overcome plateaus. This strategy can be especially effective when combined with intermittent fasting and a steady workout routine.

Second, carb ups can improve hormonal balance. The introduction of carbs can help regulate hormones, particularly in women, which can have a positive impact on reproductive and menstrual cycles.

Third, carb ups provide nutritional diversity. By including a wider variety of fruits, grains, legumes, tubers, and vegetables in the diet, individuals can ensure they are getting a full range of micronutrients.

Finally, carb ups can be enjoyable and help with adherence to the keto diet. Including occasional carb-up meals or days can provide a mental break from the restrictions of the keto diet and allow individuals to indulge in foods they may have been craving.

However, it is important to note that carb ups are not suitable for everyone. Individuals should ensure they are already fat-adapted and have a solid understanding of their body and their goals before incorporating carb ups. Additionally, carb ups should be done in a controlled manner to ensure a return to keto and to avoid triggering strong carb cravings. Overall, when done appropriately, carb ups can be a valuable tool to enhance the benefits of a ketogenic diet and help with weight loss.

They can improve hormonal balance

Carb ups, or "carb re-feeds", are a period of time, usually a day, where a person on the keto diet intentionally consumes more carbs than usual. This practice is not recommended for beginners, but for those who have already mastered the standard ketogenic diet and have a solid workout routine, it can be beneficial. Carb ups can help improve hormonal balance, especially in women, whose hormones seem to be more affected by weight loss.

A very low-calorie diet, including some low-carb diets, may disrupt certain hormones in some women. The hypothalamus, pituitary, and adrenal glands interact in complex ways to keep hormones in balance, and this balance can be disrupted by factors such as calorie intake, stress, and exercise levels. Eating too few carbs or calories and experiencing chronic stress may disrupt this balance, causing hormonal problems.

A low-carb diet may cause irregular menstrual cycles or amenorrhea in some women, especially lean women. Amenorrhea is defined as the absence of a menstrual cycle for 3 months or more and can be caused by a drop in levels of many hormones, such as gonadotropin-releasing hormone, luteinizing hormone, follicle-stimulating hormone, estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone. A low level of leptin, a hormone produced by fat cells, may also be a cause of amenorrhea and irregular menstruation. Research suggests that women need a certain level of leptin to maintain normal menstrual function. If a woman's carb or calorie consumption is too low, it may suppress her leptin levels and interfere with leptin's ability to regulate reproductive hormones.

Carb ups can help to reset leptin levels and keep the body's metabolism on point, which can help with weight loss stalls or prevent weight regain. Carb ups can also help to improve thyroid function, which can be negatively impacted by a very low-carb diet. Carbohydrates can be beneficial for thyroid function, and consuming too few of them can lower thyroid hormone levels, leading to fatigue, weight gain, and low mood.

In addition, carb ups can provide nutritional diversity, ensuring adequate micronutrient intake, and can help to keep the body "guessing", which is thought to be beneficial for various bodily functions.

Carb ups can enhance muscle growth

Carb ups can be an effective strategy for enhancing muscle growth, particularly for bodybuilders and athletes. This strategy, also known as "carb loading" or "carb refeeding", involves intentionally consuming more carbohydrates than usual for a short period, typically one day, or as short as one meal. While it may not be suitable for beginners, those with a solid workout routine and a good understanding of their body and goals may benefit from this approach.

Additionally, carb ups can be particularly beneficial for individuals who have been on a ketogenic diet for an extended period. After several weeks of ketosis, introducing carbs can help break a weight loss stall and improve hormonal balance. It can also enhance muscle growth by increasing energy expenditure and leptin concentration.

However, it is important to approach carb ups in a controlled manner. Returning to a ketogenic diet after a carb up is crucial to avoid losing the benefits of ketosis. It is also important to be mindful of calorie consumption and to choose healthy carb options such as whole foods with a lower glycemic index.

For bodybuilders and athletes, strategic carb ups can be a powerful tool for optimising body composition and maximising muscle growth. By timing carb ups with workout routines, individuals can take advantage of enhanced performance and improved recovery to train harder and promote muscle growth.

They can increase energy expenditure

Carb ups can increase energy expenditure and leptin concentration. However, there is some controversy surrounding this claim.

Carb ups, or "carb re-feeds", are a period of time, usually a day, where someone following a ketogenic diet will consume more carbohydrates than usual. This will kick the person out of ketosis, which is the purpose. Carb ups can help to break a weight loss stall, improve hormonal balance, and enhance muscle growth.

However, the idea that carb ups increase energy expenditure is disputed. Proponents of low-carbohydrate diets have claimed that such diets result in a substantial increase in total energy expenditure (TEE) of 400-600 kcal/day. However, a recent systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled feeding studies found no meaningful TEE effects when comparing isocaloric diets with equivalent amounts of protein but varying in their proportion of carbohydrates to fat.

It is important to note that carb ups are not recommended for beginners of the keto diet.

Carb ups can help with constipation

Carb ups can be an effective way to help with constipation, especially if you're on a keto diet. The keto diet is a very low-carb, high-fat diet that can provide health benefits such as increased energy, weight loss, improved mental function, and blood sugar control. However, one of its side effects is constipation, which can be uncomfortable and troublesome for some people.

Carb ups, or carb refeeding, is a period where you intentionally consume more carbs than usual for a day or a couple of days. This strategy can help with constipation by providing your body with more fibre, which is often lacking in a low-carb diet. Fibre is essential for regular bowel movements, and increasing your fibre intake can help soften stools and make them easier to pass.

When doing carb ups, it's important to choose healthy carb options that are high in fibre. Some good choices include:

• Split peas: They are rich in both soluble and insoluble fibre, which help to draw water into the gastrointestinal tract and increase water absorption, respectively. Split peas also contain resistant starch, which is broken down by gut bacteria to produce beneficial short-chain fatty acids.
• Fruits: All fruits contain fibre, but some like raspberries, pears, and apples are particularly high in fibre content. Fruits also provide essential vitamins and minerals.
• Starchy vegetables: Acorn squash and potatoes are good options, but remember to keep the skin on for maximum fibre.
• Legumes: Navy beans, lentils, and chickpeas are excellent sources of fibre and protein.
• Whole grains: Pearled barley and bulgur are fibre-rich whole grains that can help improve digestion.

It's important to note that you should not use carb ups as an excuse to cheat on your keto diet. Choose whole, natural foods with a lower glycemic index to avoid blood sugar spikes and cravings. Additionally, make sure to drink plenty of water, as fibre needs water to be effective in relieving constipation.

Overall, carb ups can be a helpful strategy to relieve constipation on a keto diet. By incorporating more fibre-rich carbs into your diet, you can improve your digestive health and regularity. However, remember to introduce high-fibre foods gradually and stay well-hydrated to prevent worsening constipation.

Frequently asked questions