Keto Diet: Why Does It Fail For Some?

The ketogenic diet, commonly known as the keto diet, is a high-fat, low-carbohydrate, and low-protein diet. It has gained popularity in recent years, with many people adopting it for weight loss and health reasons. However, the keto diet does not work for everyone. While some people experience positive results and improvements in their health and weight, others find that it does not work for them or even worsens their health.

There are several reasons why the keto diet may not work for some individuals. Firstly, the keto diet can be challenging to maintain due to its restrictive nature, requiring a significant overhaul of eating habits. Secondly, it may not be suitable for those with pre-existing insulin issues, as it can worsen insulin metabolism and increase insulin resistance. Additionally, the keto diet has been associated with an increase in bad LDL cholesterol and a risk of nutrient deficiencies, particularly in micronutrients like selenium, magnesium, phosphorus, and vitamins B and C. Furthermore, the high consumption of saturated fats encouraged in the keto diet can have detrimental effects on heart health.

Other factors that may impact the effectiveness of the keto diet include gut health, thyroid health, and hormone production. The keto diet has been linked to an increase in inflammatory compounds in the gastrointestinal tract, which can affect overall health and make it challenging to stick to the diet. Additionally, the diet's high-fat content can interfere with proper thyroid function and hormonal imbalances, particularly in women.

The keto diet may worsen insulin metabolism and increase insulin resistance

The keto diet is a low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet that has been shown to reduce weight. It changes metabolism so that energy comes from fat instead of sugar. However, there is some evidence that the keto diet may worsen insulin metabolism and increase insulin resistance, which could have negative health effects.

Evidence from animal studies

A study on rats found that a keto diet resulted in decreased sensitivity to peripheral insulin and impaired glucose tolerance. Consuming a high-carbohydrate meal after being on a keto diet induced significantly greater insulin and glucose levels compared to controls. These effects were reversible upon cessation of the keto diet.

Another study on mice found that keto-fed mice showed a poorer ability to regulate blood sugar compared to mice on a high-fat, high-carbohydrate diet. The main reason for this was that the livers of the keto-fed mice were not responding as well to insulin, a condition known as insulin resistance, which raises the risk of developing type 2 diabetes.

Evidence from human studies

A meta-analysis of 13 studies found that the keto diet improved glycemic control and lipid metabolism in patients with type 2 diabetes. However, the analysis did not specifically look at the effects of the keto diet on insulin resistance.

Some case reports and anecdotal evidence suggest that the keto diet may worsen insulin resistance and increase the risk of developing type 2 diabetes. For example, one person reported that they had to go back on medication for their depression after initially being able to get off it while on the keto diet. Another person reported high levels of ketones in their blood, which can be a sign of ketoacidosis, a dangerous condition.

Overall assessment

While the keto diet has been shown to be effective for weight loss and improving glycemic control in some people, there is some evidence that it may worsen insulin metabolism and increase insulin resistance. This could be due to the high-fat content of the diet, which can lead to increased levels of saturated fat and cholesterol in the blood. More research is needed to fully understand the effects of the keto diet on insulin resistance, especially in humans. In the meantime, it is important for people considering the keto diet to consult with a doctor and a registered dietitian to ensure that it is safe for them.

The diet can cause digestive issues and negatively impact gut health

The keto diet can cause digestive issues and negatively impact gut health in several ways. Firstly, the high-fat content of the keto diet can be difficult for some people to digest, leading to stomach pain, nausea, and constipation. This is because the body needs specific enzymes to break down large amounts of fat, and some people's bodies may not produce enough of these enzymes naturally.

Secondly, the keto diet can cause dehydration, which can contribute to stomach pain and constipation. This is because the body loses water when it burns through glycogen, and the keto diet also lowers insulin levels, allowing excess fluid to be released. Therefore, it is crucial to drink plenty of water and consume electrolytes when following the keto diet.

Thirdly, the keto diet restricts many foods that are good sources of fibre, such as grains and legumes. Fibre is essential for regular bowel movements and maintaining a healthy gut. A lack of fibre in the diet can lead to constipation and other digestive issues.

Finally, the keto diet can disrupt the balance of gut bacteria. Probiotics and fermented foods are essential for maintaining a healthy gut microbiome, but there are limited options for these on the keto diet due to sugar content restrictions. Therefore, some people may experience digestive issues or other negative side effects due to an imbalance in their gut bacteria.

Overall, while the keto diet can be effective for some people, it is crucial to be aware of the potential negative impacts on digestive health and take steps to mitigate these issues, such as staying hydrated, consuming enough fibre, and taking digestive enzyme supplements if needed.

It can cause hormonal imbalances, particularly in women

The keto diet can cause hormonal imbalances, particularly in women. This is due to the diet's restriction of carbohydrates, which can affect serotonin, progesterone, and insulin levels in women. These shifts can cause insulin levels to rise, leading to weight gain. Additionally, cortisol levels rise as a result of the body burning stored fat and muscle. Prolonged high cortisol levels can lead to hormonal imbalances where estrogen and testosterone levels are affected. This can exacerbate menstruation and conditions like endometriosis.

The keto diet's high-fat content can also cause an increase in estrogen levels, which can suppress the thyroid and lead to weight gain. This suppression affects multiple hormonal interactions due to the sensitive and complex nature of hormonal requirements in women. As a result, women on the keto diet may experience initial weight loss, but hormonal imbalances may cause weight gain over time.

Furthermore, the keto diet can be stressful to the body, and premenopausal and perimenopausal women's bodies are especially sensitive to dietary changes. Any signs of nutrient deficiencies can influence women's hormones even in the short term. In addition, specific health conditions or low nutrient status, in combination with the keto diet, can lead to adverse health outcomes.

While the keto diet may offer benefits such as weight loss and improved insulin regulation, it is important to consider the potential risks of hormonal imbalances, especially in women.

It may increase cholesterol and lipid levels

The keto diet may not be a good fit for some people as it can increase cholesterol and lipid levels. The keto diet involves eating high amounts of fat, moderate amounts of protein, and minimal amounts of carbohydrates. This shift in macronutrient ratios can have an impact on cholesterol levels.

Some studies suggest that the keto diet can lower levels of high-density lipoprotein (HDL), or "good" cholesterol, while raising levels of low-density lipoprotein (LDL), or "bad" cholesterol. As a result, the keto diet may not be suitable for everyone, especially those with high cholesterol or fat-induced lipemia.

Research has shown conflicting results regarding the impact of the keto diet on cholesterol levels. Some studies have found that the keto diet leads to an increase in LDL cholesterol levels, while others have shown a decrease. It is important to note that the duration of the diet and the presence of underlying health conditions may play a role in these conflicting results.

For individuals with high cholesterol, it is crucial to consult a healthcare professional before starting the keto diet. Adjustments to the diet may be necessary, such as avoiding artificial trans fats, processed meats, and fried foods, as well as replacing some saturated fats with monounsaturated fats. Avocados, olive oil, nuts, and nut butters are healthy sources of monounsaturated fats. Additionally, including polyunsaturated fats like omega-3 fats from flax seeds, chia seeds, walnuts, and fatty fish can help lower triglyceride levels and increase HDL cholesterol.

Furthermore, it is important to remember that a keto diet should not be low in fiber. Fiber-rich foods such as nuts, seeds, berries, and low-carb vegetables can help lower cholesterol levels.

The diet is unsustainable and difficult to customise

The keto diet is a high-fat, low-carbohydrate, and classically low-protein diet. It is often praised for its weight-loss benefits, but it is not a sustainable diet for everyone.

The keto diet requires a major overhaul of eating habits, which can be challenging to maintain in the long term. It involves significantly reducing carbohydrate intake, which can be restrictive and difficult to stick to. This diet requires careful planning and preparation, and it can be challenging to find suitable meal options when eating out. The repetitive nature of the meals can also be off-putting for some.

Additionally, the keto diet is not easily customisable to fit individual needs. The diet requires a high consumption of fats and proteins and a minimal intake of carbohydrates. However, finding the right balance can be tricky, and the specific ratios required for optimal results can vary widely. Some people may also experience undesirable side effects such as fatigue, brain fog, and digestive issues, which can make it even more challenging to adhere to the diet.

Furthermore, the keto diet is associated with an increased risk of nutrient deficiencies, as it restricts many nutrient-rich foods such as fruits, vegetables, and grains. It also encourages the consumption of processed meats and dairy products, which are high in saturated fat and cholesterol, contributing to a heightened risk of heart disease.

The keto diet can be challenging to maintain due to its restrictive nature, the potential for undesirable side effects, and the difficulty in customising it to individual needs. As a result, it may not be a sustainable diet for everyone.

Frequently asked questions